Page 1 of 1

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 3:04 pm
by IronTiger
Moltzen will not be coming back this year, definately.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 5:41 pm
by Robbie
Moltzen will not be coming back this year, definately.
Im not so sure, i think Sheens might use him at some point this year.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 5:53 pm
by Fraze23
Robbie wrote:
Moltzen will not be coming back this year, definately.
Im not so sure, i think Sheens might use him at some point this year.
Well we've finished 3rd without him. I would feel a bit annoyed if i was in the side and got punted in the finals to make room for moltzen. Sure i'd love to have him there but with no match fitness etc i think the blokes there can get the job done

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 7:36 pm
by Love the WestsTigers
Fraze23 wrote:
Robbie wrote:
Moltzen will not be coming back this year, definately.
Im not so sure, i think Sheens might use him at some point this year.
Well we've finished 3rd without him. I would feel a bit annoyed if i was in the side and got punted in the finals to make room for moltzen. Sure i'd love to have him there but with no match fitness etc i think the blokes there can get the job done
Sometimes we have to do whats best for the team..
If Lui has to sacrifice his spot for Molz so we can win the GF so be it .. I'm sure he will agree..Its not like Molzten hasnt played all year , he did start unfortunately couldnt play the whole year ..

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 7:53 pm
by benjibrotown
Although Id love Moltz to be playing in this finals series I cant agree with Love WestsTigers point about Lui. As far as im concerned if Lui has played there for most of the whole season while Molten has been injured and done a good job of it then its his right to play out the finals series. If Sheens feels Moltzen is a better player he can take his position next year.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 8:01 pm
by willow
Robbie wrote:
Moltzen will not be coming back this year, definately.
Im not so sure, i think Sheens might use him at some point this year.
He won't. He's only 5-6 months post op. The club won't risk him. I really don't know why people keep hoping he will play again this year. It simply isn't going to happen.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 8:10 pm
by Centaur
Love the WestsTigers wrote:
Fraze23 wrote:
Robbie wrote:Im not so sure, i think Sheens might use him at some point this year.
Well we've finished 3rd without him. I would feel a bit annoyed if i was in the side and got punted in the finals to make room for moltzen. Sure i'd love to have him there but with no match fitness etc i think the blokes there can get the job done
Sometimes we have to do whats best for the team..
If Lui has to sacrifice his spot for Molz so we can win the GF so be it .. I'm sure he will agree..Its not like Molzten hasnt played all year , he did start unfortunately couldnt play the whole year ..
And this is where the issue lies.

It is arguable whether having Molzten over Lui at halfback is best for the team. My personal view is that Lui is the way to go for now.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 8:19 pm
by Peaches
If Moltzen was to come back this season, he would be off the pace, hesitant and severely targeted. He needs an off-season to get confidence in his knee and his whole game in general. Lui is the best option for this season. Come 2011, Moltzen may be the better option in the halves.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 9:04 pm
by sunshine coast tiger
Did anyone that went notice if any of the u20's were training. I still think Ben Murdoch-Malsla could go alright in the top grade.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 9:10 pm
by Bazzinator
hyland, murdoch, woods were there trainng as well as meaney, latu

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 10:45 pm
by RatedRKO
Allan Towle wrote:If Moltzen was to come back this season, he would be off the pace, hesitant and severely targeted. He needs an off-season to get confidence in his knee and his whole game in general. Lui is the best option for this season. Come 2011, Moltzen may be the better option in the halves.
Yeah he shouldn't be played this season, it wouldn't end well for him IMO.

See how he goes in next years trials then see how he compares to Lui.

Is Lui eligible for NYC next year?

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Tue 07 Sep, 2010 11:35 pm
by stryker
Love the WestsTigers wrote:If Lui has to sacrifice his spot for Molz so we can win the GF so be it .. I'm sure he will agree..Its not like Molzten hasnt played all year , he did start unfortunately couldnt play the whole year ..
Have you ever played footy mate?
Moltzen coming into this side after what has transpired this year for him, could only hamper progress.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Wed 08 Sep, 2010 8:39 am
by Robbie
If Moltzen were to come back i think it would be on the bench or possibly fullback.

Re: Open Training Session

Posted: Thu 17 Feb, 2011 7:24 am
by Tigerjosh99
Hey do you know what time they train thanks[img][quot[*]e][/quote][/img]