Wests Tigers Forum Dud of the year 2024

[FrodoTBaggin]

Has to be Stefano, contract year and didn't set the world on fire at all.

 

[old_man_tiger]

Has to be Bateman for me judged 80% on field and 20% off field.

Stefano just pips him off field, but when he occasionally played like he cared he had a few good games.

I thought Bateman was slightly more acceptable in a few games early on, but when he was captain and played dumber than the rookies I was sold. Dud.

Of course he wasn't the problem, it was the young guys. Just ask him!

 

[westTAHger]

These would win by far if on the poll.
Ref's and official's

 

[hank37w]

So many to choose from, so hard to choose only one. 🤔

 

[Buttface]

Ask the President of the hater club @Snidest 0 😆

I am pretty sure I’m VP or Secretary and I haven’t received any communication regarding our input on the biggest gerri of the club. Have you Mr President? @Snidest 0

 

[boonboon]

The thing with Steph is people are disappointed he is leaving but statistically he had a better year then last year so can't say he disappointed on field

 

[Moh]

The thing with Steph is people are disappointed he is leaving but statistically he had a better year then last year so can't say he disappointed on field

Salty fans bro. Future tier one prop if he isn't one already.

RE thread - definitely Bateman. Awful.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

No Bud?
Easily forgotten i guess.

 

[TIGERS]

Can we rename this poll, "who do the haters on this forum hate the most"? Utoikamanu obviously played well enough to earn a gigantic contract offer from us. Instead he's off to Melbourne to try and win a premiership. He will almost certainly get his chance. It's bizarre and lame to think you can call him a dud. If he's a dud, then we get rejected by duds. But sure guys, whatever, duds, fine.

 

[Tiger Woods]

Dud of the year ?
All of the above
😉

 

[Suzie-Q]

Where is Doobie?

Was he disappointing, though? I was more surprised with his 1 great game

 

[WhiTe Tiger]

Can I vote for the geriatric Balmain director who came out in the paper wanting Balmain to split from the merger?

 

[BAGNF05]

Outside backs as a collective, lead by Naden

 

[BAGNF05]

Can we rename this poll, "who do the haters on this forum hate the most"? Utoikamanu obviously played well enough to earn a gigantic contract offer from us. Instead he's off to Melbourne to try and win a premiership. He will almost certainly get his chance. It's bizarre and lame to think you can call him a dud. If he's a dud, then we get rejected by duds. But sure guys, whatever, duds, fine.

Some will never learn. Endlessly bash our best, highest paid players then watch them flourish elsewhere.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

It’s not a bashing thread… more so who failed to live up to your expectations.

 

[Winston Churchill]

Dud of the year thread and no Dud Sullivan on the list.

 

[innsaneink]

Bateman
Apparently Warrington want to keep him next season onwards
Let us pray 🙏

 

[Red88_Tiger]

Out of that list Steph gets it hands down purely on lack of effort. Even when he had a good game there were times he was lazy off the ball

 

[tig_prmz]

Not surprised that Stefano is on the list, but I don't think he belongs on it.

Klemmer as the most senior player to me has been the worst. He should have been the one leading the charge at training. For his experience and stature in the game, I am very disappointed in his efforts.

Bateman, a close second.

Sezer, Olam, To'a and Tupou as well purely because of lack of game time.

 

[weststigerman]

This is easy. Bateman. Rueben Porter was an upgrade on him.

If Stef wasn't leaving I don't think he'd be in the top 3 here. Underperformed slightly, but also played well before all the contract talk started.