Recent content by Camel2281

Not if he plays 13 and 9 over say 50-60 mins a week

He can't/won't defend. Never has

Transition Hemasi to the right. With all his rugby he would be used to playing both sides of the field in attack anyway

But even his good games are only good in attack. He's an arm grabber. That's why Newcastle never rated him

Bye Bye Starford. Rugby Centres play both sides of the field depending on where the ruck is. Hopefully Masi can transition to Right centre in the off season

I think it's lack of depth in those games off the bench meaning the like of Terrell was gassed. Mason, Sukkar and To'a are miles from NRL players and when all on the field cause us to capitulate

We're a right centre away from our backs being NRL class. To'a is a massive liability. He was awful tonight. His defence is worse than Douehi's ever was

Not defensively. And he's too hot and cold. I'd love someone with a higher workrate and played at a higher intensity like Taylan. The Broncos have Grant Anderson coming so Shibusaki, Arthurs and Deine Mariner are shooting out for limited spots. I'd kill for one of those three

Don't forget Perth come in 2027. So it may be a case where Mav wanted options to head there if he goes ok for us too

I'd honestly like a right centre to replace Toa and he be the depth centre if I am honest

Sione is playing great but is better suited to the middle. He's actually an ideal starting 13

He'd be our best 2nd rower. Sione goes back into the middle rotation

Yeah and Alex also gives away multiple penalties, sin bins and suspensions every year. If it's an effective tackle, who gives a crap if it's ferocious. In fact aggressive and ferocious defence tends to result in misses and mistakes/penalties

He's got great offload ability too

I read Newcastle and the Cows