Search results

  1. M

    2021 Grand Final discussion Souths v Panthers

    My daughter a Penrith Fan. Penrith lost their first GF to Raiders in 1990 then won in 1991. Will this be repeated 30 years later! 2003 Penrith won with a Father/Son Combo John and Martin Lang. Go Panthers in a close one
  2. M

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    I love the Forum and it's passionate contributors. We all want our club to be successful but there is no silver bullet. I have followed Western Suburbs since 1977 and Wests Tigers since 2000 with only 2005 the only Grand appearance and win. Very slim pickings. Let's hope we improve on 13th spot...
  3. M

    Luke Brooks

    Brooks needs a fresh start. I would offer him to Raiders for one of their young backs. I think Brooks is a running 5/8 and has played in wrong position for his skill set.
  4. M

    Pre-Lim Finals *Spoilers

    Great to see Marshall play last Game in a Grand Final. Thanks for the memories. Storm to win back to back.
  5. M

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Is Harley Smith-Shields from Canberra available. Looked a real prospect.
  6. M

    What would make you a believer, in 2022?

    New Board, new coach and new players. Not much to ask for
  7. M

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Happy to get whatever player it takes to play semi finals Laurie Gildart Walker* Scott* Ken M AD Hastings Stefano Liddle Taupau* Blore Tulligi Elliott* Mikeale Twal Big Joe/ Musgrove LLCoolJ Simpkins Simpkin New Coach and Support Coaches
  8. M

    Season Snapshot: Luke Garner

    Thank you - Next.
  9. M

    Luke Brooks

    Half back is the key role in an NRL team. Brooks is not the answer. Time to go and Noffo can go as well.
  10. M

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    If Maguire is sacked will the new coach be determined by the players he can attract to the club? We all agree the current squad needs overhaul and injection of talent and experience from other clubs.
  11. M

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Bateman, Lomax, Woods and Simms would be my targets. Need some experience players. Bateman is a winner and tough nut. Remember we have Hastings and English Centre as well. Side note Momers good enough to push Crichton to the wing. Interesting. Wish we got Matt Burton as he is something special.
  12. M

    Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

    NRL at the end of the day is a results driven business. Maguire 3 years our attack and defence have regressed. He needs to go even though sacking coaches does not deal with other issues underpinning the results on the field. Tough offseason.
  13. M

    Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

    I look at physical evidence and for last 3 years WT defence and attack has regressed. No line speed, no structure in attack and what 5th tackle option. Hail Mary and wish for the best. I don't like sacking coaches but Maguire on the evidence available plus lack of ability to attract top talent...
  14. M

    We need one overpaid signing to get us going

    Let's sort out the coach first then decide on players. I think we should learn from past errors of overpaying players. A big no from me. 1.6 million banded around should be able to buy mid range experience players to compliment the juniors. Stefano needs an urgent upgrade or he will walk.
  15. M

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Until coaching situation is publicly known good luck signing any decent players. I think WT need to part company with Maguire asap, hire a new coach before November then players might come here. Not an easy fix.
  16. M

    2021 Reflections

    One word regression. Sum up season 2021. Other words would break Forum rules.
  17. M

    keepers

    100% agree. Great post
  18. M

    Maguire post match comments insanity?

    Maguire, Brooks and Noffo need to be shown the door asap to let the healing begin. Good luck keeping Stefano with better clubs banging down the door pre season. I really don't know how each player can be happy collecting their pay this week.
  19. M

    Tigers board to undertake post-season review

    Will this really lead to real change as last 10 years has been so painful and we appear to be going backwards. If Maguire and Brooks are here in 2022 then nothing has been learned.
Back
Top