Search results

May is a top 3 prop in the game at the moment, so lets move him? Haas plays big minutes, so I guess he should be moved to lock to. I don't know what everyones obsession is with moving players for the sake of it. The best thing for the team is keep a top 3 front rower in the front row. If we...

We have other areas of the top 17 that need improvement well before the prop rotation. The four man prop rotation of Pole, May, Sione and Hunt I would say is one of the better 4 man rotations in the comp. Add in Seyfarth and Twal and it’s good depth. The point being, getting salary cap balance...

TDS is a MUCH better prospect than Haywood. Haywood is u19 this year. Tallyn was u19 only last year. By u19, TDS had already made his first grade debut and absolutely dominated SG Ball that year (he had something like 9 tries in 10 games). He then went and played 6 games of first grade that...

Completely disagree, it would screw up our cap and roster balance. You can't have 7-8 props in a 30 man roster with the money that they are all on. Its not fantasy football. That's why its much more important to get a second rower and lock to free up Seyfarth and Twal to play prop. If we...

We don't need a prop, we need a lock and a second rower. Once we get those two, Twal and Seyfarth move back to the bench and prop/middle rotation. Pole, May, Hunt, Sione, Twal, Seyfarth... That's 6 props for 4 positions in the 17.

Hopefully the club can get KPP over during the Bye period. Hunt or Sione to start for Pole, KPP to start and Seyfarth to the bench to cover front row. Latu and Skelton are both back after this week which is a positve.

Yeah obviously his form needs to be there. I actually think he would be better off the bench in general as he’s an unstructured player. He would be much better served coming on after 30mins when the game opens up, taking advantage of the tired forwards around the middle and edge of the ruck.

I would play him off the bench, probably at 14 or in Bird's current role. Playing him in reserve grade would just bring more negative attention to the club, playing group and Benji from the media/his management. You can just imagine the stuff Isaac Moses will come out with if Galvin in reserve...

Looking at potential signings for next year and considering realistic options and salary cap, I would be looking at bringing in the following: Taylan May, Kai Pearce-Paul, Tyrone May, Harrison Hassett and a quality starting lock (perhaps a swap for Galvin. I would also look at re-signing...

Andrew Webster mentioned on 360 tonight that when Galvin told the club he wasn't re-signing, they were of the opinion that he was going to the Bulldogs. He also said that WT are still of that opinion... Gus also gave some very strange answers today when asked about Sexton re-signing and also...

Lomax just arrived at Parra. He’s not leaving.

Seyfarths new contract is 550k fyi. Samuela is now on less.

I respect your opinion, but he does not walk into every teams 17. Hate to be 'that guy' but iv'e spoken to two good friends who are at two different clubs (top 30) and they have both mentioned that Seyfarth is consistently identified as the point of attack (weak link) due to his poor discipline...

I would think Seyfarth and Bird would be competing for the same bench spot with the other being the 18th man. Which is great for squad depth. Both cover the backrow with Bird also able to cover the centres and Seyfarth able to cover the front row. It may even change depending on who were are...

That sounds like 'we've signed them under conditions'. To me that sounds like they've signed Taylan May to a train on deal for this season (or similar) with a top 30 spot for next season. Similar to Ferguson at the Roosters back in the day when he was training with the Roosters squad for the...

Disagree, think hes much better off the bench in a middle role, covering edge if need be. Good work ethic, but he is still struggling a little with errors and discipline. He also struggles with run metres and post contact metres (lowest of our starting pack). All those should improve in a bench...

Don't need prop depth... Not sure why this keeps popping up. We have two props who can play 60+ minutes in Pole and May. Twal, Seyfarth, Hunt and Sione F can all play there and do a job. Worst case scenario IF 3 of those guys go down, even Kit can come onto the bench and give a 15-20 minute...

One of the bigger benefits of getting KPP is that we won't need to get another prop as Seyfarth is then free to play in the middle from the bench. May, Pole, Hunt, Sione F, Seyfath and Twal. That's 6 props/middles and that means that one would probably need to miss out on the 17... Not to...

With Laulilii coming through and Staines/Naden for depth. No need for another winger, especially one on 500k. Dom Young has speed and that's about it. He has feet for hands and defensive reads that would make Nofoaluma laugh.

He would be a good depth option, but you wouldn’t want him as your starter. Could do a job for a couple weeks if there was an injury. Theres a massive halves shortage so to be able to get a back up like May on a cheap deal is great for squad balance and salary cap management.