Search results

What's happened to Gebbie?

Let me guess, Farah was also our best player since Hassan Saleh?

3 Mbye 2 Laurie 1 Brooks

I mean moreso the sign bins for high shots. Repeated set restart infringements I'm okay with. But the soft 'high tackle' sin bins are garbage.

Good for replays, terrible in live play.

4 sin bins in tonight's game. A but of a worry for what's to come. What happens when a game is 13 on 10, or descends into what's basically a 9s game. Especially when it's mostly for innocuous stuff. I can see it causing problems this round.

Minimal minutes but still pretty dismal.

Keen to see Regan Hughes and Israel Ogden. Big wraps on both.

From what I've seen of Madden in NSW Cup he isn't First Grade standard. Happy to be proven wrong but I don't think he's the answer.

I see Hastings as being a good #14. But I think in the halves we need somebody with a bit more attacking flair. Doueihi and Johnson has the potential to be a very good combination.

I wonder if the club should be looking at a Luke Brooks and Shaun Johnson player swap? SJ seems on the outer at Cronulla.

How does Stefano get dropped? He's been one of our best...

Yep, between the poor options, the poor kicking game and the poor direction and leadership I'm not sure what he's supposed to be offering. Even his running game has been crap lately.

Yep and that puts pressure on the rest of the team. Nobody seems to know who is getting the ball. Brooks seems to just make up his mind on the spot.

Agree. There's inconsistencies there. One of his takes over his shoulder was outstanding. He'll get better.

3 Doueihi 2 Laurie 1 Ofahengaue

This bloke is just here to collect a pay cheque

He still had some very good moments in that game. He's shown that he's deserving of a first grade spot. Definitely worth persisting with.

Surely we take the captaincy off Tamou and give it to Doueihi. Tamou doesn't deserve to have the C next his name.

Can't be any worse. Even if he is worse, it's time to move on from Brooks. Somebody else at least deserves a chance to show they might be better.