Search results

I really like AD and but I think we have scored 4 tries in 4 weeks. Latu isn’t available and we need to do something to change. While I think AD should listen to the coach and have a team first mentality, I may have opted to have Luai in the centres given he is leaving. He is defensively sound...

He rarely meets the opposing line front anymore. He tends to back into the line looking for an offload by that negates his momentum. He came on in his second stint last night and looked so much more impactful as he got a few PCMs. I think shorter minutes, faster play the balls, good contact...

I agree corruption is a long bow but I think the levels of inconsistency really riles fans.

Knowing what Twally has been like over the years, this seems really out of character. I reckon Salman has said something inappropriate that has upset Twally. The replay showed the delayed reaction from Salman as well - World Cup diving at its best

Watching Benji’s presser, it was the first time I have really seen him out of ideas and he looked despondent. He said they prepared really well and I think he expected a strong performance. Generally speaking coaches who don’t have ideas tend not to last long.

There is no attack. No decoys. No depth. I am not sure what’s wrong? We go one out for 5 tackles then kick and hope - and even then Bula hasn’t contested a ball.

@ShaunMielekamp - I really admire someone in your role who takes the time to talk with fans. It’s also a great input for fan sentiment. As a club, we have been told by previous leadership that we are a development club. That’s a great ambition but in your opinion do we have the required funding...

Theoretically we have but I have never seen him to do the 30 tackles and 100 run metres required for NRL 13 (along with the other ball distribution stuff).

Once we have our full forward pack back, I think we are ok (KPP, Api, a fully fit Samuela and Twally, Royce for impact). Where I would be looking is for a top tier 13. I think Twally does well in the middle with his go forward and excellent in defence but he doesn’t seem to play ball play at the...

I don’t think Douiehi or Shuster have the engine for a 13 but a Douiehi/Shuster share of the role might work?

Lost their way totally and they won’t find their way back this year. Massive losses have impacted confidence. Missed tackles, one off hit ups, no creativity and just a general lack of cohesion. We need to do something different next week. Luai and Douiehi just don’t work together. Makasini is...

I must admit, I didn’t know why the hype was about but watching him in the last 2 KOE games - he is an absolutely a talent.

Latu has been outstanding. Running and kicking game has been just a class above. The whole spine has been really good but Latu directed the show. St George had no answer to him. Have been watching him and Javon closely and both have been vocal, directing play. He should play next week

We have so lost our way. The intensity and the pride that we’re so evident at the start of the season have completely gone. I think the injury toll has really impacted the team’s attitude and morale. They haven’t been the same since the mid season floggings. Perhaps time look at next season and...

Rocket Reddy tops the list for me. Adam “the mechanic” Blair when he was at Melbourne- went to work using Jiu Jitsu holds to hurt players in tackles. Hoppa was a piece of work

As a potential outside back, I think Dunster is the most interesting if he can get an injury free run and Andrews the highest ceiling in that list.

I Think he is showing good progress and I don’t think he has reached his potential yet.

I think the Knights got a leg up in the middle as we fatigued. May cannot do a quality 80 minutes. He is a 60 - 65 minute player. He becomes a target in defence and his runs are ineffective. We need some more quality up front. Twal will no doubt help in the middle but Benji needs to ensure May...

His one on one defence needs a lot of work

I am not sure how he fits if he doesn’t want to do the hard stuff? Do you see him as a half. 13 or back rower?