Search results

  1. watersider

    OFFICIAL Kai Pearce-Paul #304

    Even in games I fluctuate between Sam fainu and kpp as my favourite players. Both very physical, fast, skillful, 80 minutes and full of heart. I wouldn't trade them for anyone. I expected a solid reliable toiler in KPP. To get a strike player at that price is terrific. Credit to Benji for...
  2. watersider

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    He's been so good that he gets a bonus third man of the match!
  3. watersider

    The Cambo Curse

    All this talk about new team and I want to believe. But let's win this weekend or all the same old talk resumes!
  4. watersider

    TEAM LIST Round 6 vs Knights

    With Klein in the box we need to really take our chances when we get them. He LOVES intervening in games and sees the games through the rulebook only and has no capacity to interpret or judge based on the circumstance or conditions of the game. For this reason he is a terrible referee. And just...
  5. watersider

    Dragons re-brand

    Terrible idea. There's nothing wrong with the name and fans of both original clubs would hate it. They need to get their juniors in order, surely the Illawarra has a wealth of talent yet doesn't seem like much is coming through for the club.
  6. watersider

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Taking away the better organiser and kicker doesn't improve that situation. Half of those sets were sabotaged by doueihi running in circles or getting caught with the ball. Players aren't perfect, teams have bad moments. Madden's kicking under pressure in those circumstances enabled us to win...
  7. watersider

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Gould really enjoys lying. It's funny the way he concocts that story. All that tells us is that he thinks Ciraldo made a big error and he's covering for him. No defending the decision at all in his little fantasy. Interesting how that plays out now that Gould is not agreeing with Ciraldo. In...
  8. watersider

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Madden has by far the better kicking game. Perhaps their range is similar, maybe even doueihi can kick it further, but Madden's placement, awareness and kick selection with his kicking is on another level. He is our best kicker. If you want any evidence of that simply look at who Benji gave...
  9. watersider

    LIVE GAME Round 5 versus Eels

    I get everyone being critical of Luke, he has many errors and makes mistakes in defense, however, he's a damn good runner and that is absolutely vital to every set of six. He's fast and low to the ground and very physical. Skelton also does it well, but he isn't anywhere near as fast and he also...
  10. watersider

    OFFICIAL Lachlan Galvin #277 *Released* Career Discussion.

    Yeah, I think he's making a lot of progress in all aspects of his game. His kicking is also a lot better this year. It's just that none of it would be at a top NRL level. And with most of us seeing his future being in 2nd row or lock, he is currently getting through his tackles, but he's not...
  11. watersider

    OFFICIAL Lachlan Galvin #277 *Released* Career Discussion.

    I'm not sure there's a worse halfback in the game. Perhaps Flanagan? But Flanagan's kicking game is pretty reliable. I'd say it's close between them. Galvin has potential if he can get much stronger, but without speed, consistent passing or kicking and his difficulty organising a backline, it's...
  12. watersider

    LIVE GAME Rd 5 NRL discussion

    I think the problem was the Storm's contact in defense. They have very good players and are at a very high level, but they've been inconsistent defensively for a while now, and they aren't strong tacklers and allowed lots of offloads and space out wide due to Penrith pushing through in...
  13. watersider

    The halves problem

    Yes, if we win games.
  14. watersider

    The halves problem

    I like luai, he's a good half. I specifically said I'm not talking about who is the better player but who plays the role better for us. Luai is not an organising halfback, so if madden stays in his current form you need madden at half back. Thats nowhere near certain as, like you say, it was...
  15. watersider

    The halves problem

    1. Madden, based on last night's form, would absolutely stay as our halfback even with his defensive issues. But let's see if he can stay at that level because yesterday he played like a top 5 halfback and it's not easy being that good. 2. I'm not convinced luai is a better option than AD. AD...
  16. watersider

    3-2-1 Round 4 vs NZ

    Yeah it's Madden by a mile. Madden madden Madden. Doueihi was excellent off the back of his ball playing, but it was Madden's straightening of the attack and exceptional kicking game that got us back in it and relieved pressure for us.
  17. watersider

    The halves problem

    If Madden stays in that form, you pick him first and the rest around him. A kicking game like that and an organising straight runner is what every club needs and we haven't had since Prince. It's a choice between luai and doueihi at 5/8 based on that and you don't drop doueihi when he plays...
  18. watersider

    OFFICIAL Kai Pearce-Paul #304

    Most of us were not excited by the signing. I was hoping for a solid dependable defensive player who gets through 80 minutes, sort of like Blore's role at the Storm. His performance yesterday was outstanding and he did so much more than that. He did both the little gritty things and the flashy...
  19. watersider

    TEAM LIST Round 2 Vs NQ Cowboys

    And especially when the offseason fluff pieces are in overdrive and there is contract uncertainty for our key players. Guaranteed big start to the year.
  20. watersider

    LIVE game discussion. Tigers Team Vs Penrith - Trial#2

    Madden v Doueihi: Totally understand the support for Madden, but you don't make decisions off of trial form. Madden was against reserve graders in both appearances and it is hard to judge his performance. No doubt his kicking and game management looks the best at the club, but the speed is...
Back
Top