Search results

  1. watersider

    Finals week 1, 2025 discussion

    Wow, Penrith actually being called regularly for offside!! When did the refs decide to enforce that against them? Bulldogs, Penrith, Melbourne all are excellent at pushing the boundaries (and going beyond) of that offside line.
  2. watersider

    Finals week 1, 2025 discussion

    Bulldogs defense was excellent, Melbourne look really erratic. It looks great sometimes, but Grant and Munster are such adlib players and it seems to stifle their attack at times. I think sexton, Galvin, Burton all in the side was better for them. Galvin probably the least threatening of all of...
  3. watersider

    Finals week 1, 2025 discussion

    Bulldogs showing why they're top 4. Really good defensive contact earning turnovers and intimidating opposition forcing a grind. Galvin has been ordinary but looks much more threatening at 5/8, sexton has a more varied game and plays much faster than Galvin. Melbourne have been very poor...
  4. watersider

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    NAS hasn't been a wrecking ball this year, he's been terrible and barely gets a run. What are you all watching? Highlights from 4 years ago? He's the exact opposite of what we need: He's ill disciplined, he doesn't seem to have much of a motor these days, he's not a particularly effective...
  5. watersider

    LIVE GAME Rd 27 live discussion NRL

    KPP is average as other have said. Seems particularly lacking in what we urgently need physicality and aggression. Frizell looks much better than him on a well beaten side.
  6. watersider

    LIVE GAME Rd 27 live discussion NRL

    1. Does the Canberra result mean they can't win the comp (50+ in a game)? 2. Eels showing what a team making progress under a rookie coach looks like.
  7. watersider

    OFFICIAL Starford To’a #253

    He's a very talented player. Great front foot player, but we'd be better off with a less skilled and dynamic hard worker. Until he gets somewhere near Taylan for toughness and aggression he's a liability in a team that needs players doing gritty work without momentum. I could see him go to...
  8. watersider

    LIVE GAME Round 27 v Titans

    Perfect reflection of our season that one. So much promise that you almost start to believe but then just horrible weak mentality and massive disappointment. There's a lot of quality footballers in our team now but we are collectively fragile. They need the best psychologists and physical...
  9. watersider

    OFFICIAL Jarome Luai - #295

    Reynolds, mam , Hughes, Munster, Moses, Fogerty, C Walker, s walker, Metcalf, Dearden Cleary, katoa are all better. Is Campbell better? Probably, although I haven't watched him defensively. I don't think there's much between him and Hynes. That said, he'd be starting half at most clubs. Hynes...
  10. watersider

    LIVE GAME Round 27 v Titans

    The bunker allowed us to score a try!!!
  11. watersider

    TEAM LIST Round 27 VS Titans

    Yeah, wouldn't want to get him angry!
  12. watersider

    TEAM LIST Round 27 VS Titans

    I find it incredible how little impact seyfarth has as a 'hot head'. Surely we should get a hard run or a strong tackle to go with all the ill discipline and sin binnings? His consistent low impact mildly spoken below average play doesn't match his apparent inability to control his temper.
  13. watersider

    LIVE GAME Rd 27 live discussion NRL

    Just about every tackle Melbourne go for the extra push in the tackle. Not dominant in the tackle, just a flagrant extra push. It's really poor defense and they're lucky not to be penalised a lot more. Melbourne teams of the past earnt it more in the tackle with stronger tackling and more...
  14. watersider

    OFFICIAL Jarome Luai - #295

    For all luai's adlib plays he rarely seems to make errors. I think that doesn't get much of a mention. Passing is always excellent and he usually sets up players around him well. Long kicking is accurate and short kicking is ridiculously good (why doesn't he do it more?). The only issue for luai...
  15. watersider

    TEAM LIST Round 27 VS Titans

    Gee titans team is good on paper. Their forward pack in particular is stacked. I think it's only their spine that is a little weak, but still pretty good. They shouldn't be last.
  16. watersider

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    Yeah, I get the hope from everyone but as much progress as we've had, we're still a long way from good. It's just not good enough playing competitive losses and it's a long way to convert that to winning. So many say, 'if only we'd won a few of those narrow games', but we're losing them because...
  17. watersider

    OFFICIAL Royce Hunt #298

    Yeah, that's the problem with Hunt: Great player with the ball and momentum but if we're on the back foot you need to get him off the field immediately because his movement around the ruck is sloppy and slow. That said, he brings something our team doesn't have in really strong running but I'm...
  18. watersider

    LIVE GAME Round 26 v Raiders

    Really liked our physicality again. Just about every tackle we hit them and pushed them back. Sione fainu, Samuela, Latu, the mays all love hitting. Sione was at one stage defending our line was laughing at Canberra and hitting hard, I love that confidence and intimidation. In years passed...
  19. watersider

    Rd 26 live game discussion

    Whyte is one of the best props in the game at the moment. Roosters must be one of the most inconsistent teams in history. Potentially the best and worst team in the comp. Last night they were both...although that's a bit of hyperbole because they weren't that bad in the 1st half. But that 2nd...
Back
Top