Club at war: Why the latest Wests Tigers’ self-sabotage could cost them Jarome Luai
The Wests Tigers have become a laughing stock once more, but the team’s newest instance of civil war could cost them the services of their superstar Jarome Luai, writes BRENT READ.
December 2, 2025 - 12:09PM
The Wests Tigers are a laughing stock again. A joke. A symbol of rugby league ineptitude. All the good work chair Barry O’Farrell and chief executive Shane Richardson have done over the past 12 months has been undone by the Holman Barnes Group, who have decided they need to wrest back control of a club that became an embarrassment on their watch.
Let’s revisit history for a moment. The Tigers have gone more than a decade without playing finals football. They have languished in mediocrity for as long as anyone can remember.
Before this season, they had won three successive wooden spoons. They were going nowhere fast. Then O’Farrell and Richardson took control and the Tigers started to look like a rugby league club again.
They turned a profit. They secured funding for Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown Stadium. They made some key signings and showed significant improvement on the field.
Most importantly, they had an air of stability. When was the last time you could say that? Now, with Christmas fast approaching, the club is once again at war.
O’Farrell is gone, the independents are too and it seems only a matter of time before Richardson follows them. If he has any brains, he won’t be hanging around.
Why would you? Remember, this is the same Holman Barnes Group that has been wracked by internal politics and investigations in recent times.
Inner West mayor Darcy Byrne, who helped save Leichhardt Oval, called on the NSW government to intervene.
“This is bizarre and out of keeping with basic corporate governance standards,” Byrne wrote.
“Loyal and long suffering Wests Tigers fans deserve better than this. Our team is competing in the most professional rugby league competition on earth.
“But our head office continually operates like an amateur committee for a park footy team. “Petty and short sighted governance of Wests Tigers has been holding our club back for far too long.
“I’m calling for the NSW Government to intervene to fix the undemocratic and seemingly improper governance of the Holman Barnes Group.
“That’s what the fans want, and that is what’s needed for Wests Tigers to survive and thrive. “The current system, in which tens of thousands of members of Wests Ashfield have no real democratic say at all, is improper and unjustifiable.
“We’ve finally got things moving in the right direction on the football field. Tigers fans can’t afford backroom brawling to undermine our football team’s long-awaited recovery in 2025.”
What must Jarome Luai be thinking right now? Luai, in an interview with this masthead only last month, made note of the Tigers’ history when discussing the clauses in his contract that allowed him to leave in 2027.
As Luai said, the Tigers don’t have a great track record. You can say that again. Richardson had been working hard in the background to convince Luai to take the clauses out of his deal but we’re tipping that doesn’t happen now.
No-one could blame Luai for having one eye on the exit. If you’re in charge of Perth, you’re certainly asking the question.
“Tigers haven’t had the best track record,” Jarome Luai says as he talks about what comes next for him at the Wests Tigers
It’s all so petty. Holman Barnes board members apparently didn’t like that the new jersey was ‘too Balmain’. Spare me.
The truth, at least in the eyes of some in the inner sanctum, is that the Western Suburbs Magpies fraternity want their club back.
They have the money and the power in the relationship. They got the baseball bats out on Monday afternoon as they savaged the board and suggested they had been kept out of the loop on key decisions.
If that is indeed the case, they may be better off looking within. After all, they had two representatives on the very same board.
Two board members who apparently voted in line with their Tigers colleagues when it came to stadium strategy and jerseys.
There is a reason the Tigers haven’t played finals football in more than a decade. Self-sabotage has invariably been at the heart of all their failures.
Now, with some blue sky on the horizon, the Tigers have committed harakiri again.