It's Official - we're racist

AmericanHistoryX

Well-known member
SMH 21/11/12

Commuters were subjected to a horrifying display of racism and threats of violence on a Melbourne bus when a French woman was abused for singing in her native tongue.

Video footage of the incident, taken by Melbourne stand-up comedian Mike Nayna, shows three people — including a man pushing a pram — threatening the woman, calling her a c–-, a dog and a [This word has been automatically removed].
\
\
Nasty stuff ... a screen shot of the racist rant, filmed by another commuter. Photo: YouTube

"Speak English or die, motherf---er," a middle-aged man shouted at the woman, who was sitting at the back of the bus.

He later continued: "Everyone on the bus wants to kill ya! You're gonna have to get off eventually [This word has been automatically removed]. You worked that out yet?"

He then threatened to cut off her breasts if she continued.
\
\
Captured on camera ... three people caught abusing a female commuter aboard the bus. Photo: YouTube

Mr Nayna said a woman, believed to be the partner of a man with a pram, heckled the French woman, to which she replied: "Just go; you can go now."

He said that prompted the man with the pram to shout: "I'll f---ing boxcutter you right now, dog, talk to my missus like that.

"Yeah, come on c---, get off. F---ing ding. Look at ya. You've been told about four times, get off."

When the man pushing the pram left the bus, he smashed the window closest to the woman from the outside.

The bus was a rail replacement running on the regular Frankston line from Mordialloc to Caulfield about 10.30pm on Sunday, November 11.

Mr Nayna said it was worrying how the abusers fed off each other and became a mob.

"It didn't make any sense. There was no logic," he said.

"It was just weird mob mentality. They were feeding off each other and breaking off into rants and encouraging each other over some racist stuff — it was like a bonding session."

Mr Nayna, who has light-brown skin, said at one point he tried to stop the fracas but he was also abused with a rant about how black people should sit at the back of the bus.

Another passenger offered one of the abusers his fishing knife and gave him a beer.

"Then he went off on a tangent about filleting people and saying 'They're just scared c---- at the back of the bus," Mr Nayna said.

Mr Nayna said Victoria Police had contacted him about the footage and would speak to them later on Wednesday.

He said he had uploaded the footage to shame those involved and who were featured in the video into realising what they had done.

"I don't care about these people, I feel like they can reap what they sow, so good luck to them, but what I'd prefer to do is ... show how embarrassing it is and get people talking about that maybe racism is a problem," Mr Nayna said.

"I want those people to see it and hopefully it will change the way they think by being shamed.

"There were just a lot of scared faces and confusion ... there was just no sense to be made of it."

The video has had more than 300,000 views on YouTube and has drawn attention of media outlets across the world.

In 2010, three men were the first in Victoria charged with inciting racial hatred, accused of verbally and physically assaulting an Indian man on a bus between Frankston and Rye. All three had charges against them dropped last year.
\
\
Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/racist-rants-mar-suburban-bus-ride-20121121-29p2r.html#ixzz2CosjxiMr
 
As the guy who took the footage said "It didn't make any sense. There was no logic"

I mean what can you make of all this? Idiots together equals a mob of idiots? Is everyone like this? Well no, I've never seen something like that happen…
 
Thread title is a little misleading. Because a few Victard bogans on a bus decide to threaten someone we're all racist?

That's akin filming someone having a beer and declaring we're all alcoholics.
 
It's official, some people are racist, that doesn't mean the whole country is and we aren't the only country that this sort of stuff happens in.

Not justifying the behaviour here, but we need some perspective. Racism happens all over the world from a variety of different ethnic groups.
 
I think that was disgusting I watched the clip and couldn't believe my eyes Melbourne is getting worse day by day first it was Jill magher now Sarah cafferkey now this racist crap, those people obviously need to wake up to themselves and relies this is a multi cultural country
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
Wow, thread title is the most idiotic I've read on here in a while. Just goes to show some people have never traveled the world and spent even the slightest time in other cultures (and no, a 6 day Club Med package to Bali doesn't count) have no idea about world history,geography and basically everything that is going on in the world at the moment but are more than happy to label all of us racist because of a few drunken losers on a bus to nowhere.

CB's point and example is perfect, you see me drinking a beer so we must be all alcoholics. You see me call a Kiwi a dole bludger then we must all be racist (no offence intended to our kiwi friends, just an example to make my point).

Try living in China, India, Central Asia or any country in the Middle East and you'll see REAL racism. How about parts of South East Asia, Africa and South America? Try living in any of those countries or parts of those continents for a year or 5 and then comment on how racist we are.

I have. I see it on a daily basis. I live in China, I've lived in the Middle East. I spend huge amounts of time in India and Sth East Asia. Just yesterday another 2 Tibetans performed self immolation in the Chinese province of Gansu. Can you imagine how that can come to be? Can you imagine the racial and cultural oppression these people suffer on a daily basis to see no other way out but to self suicide by lighting yourself on fire, just in hope that it will grab the worlds attention and something will be done…...this stuff happens on a weekly basis and yet the world does nothing........but when a drunken idiot yells at someone to speak English.....woaaahh, How racist is that?!...just shocking!! Us Australian's are horribly racist people, aren't we.

By the way, have you ever been to France?? Try checking into a hotel and tell them you are a Brit. See their attitude change in an instant once you say you are joking and you show an Aussie passport.
\
\
\
\
Anyways isnt it more accurate to say these idiots were being Xenophobic, rather than Racist. The term racist gets thrown around far too much these days.

xenophobia: intense or irrational dislike or fear of people from other countries (Oxford Dictionary)
xenophobia: unreasonable fear and hatred of strangers or foreigners or of anything that is strange or foreign (Merriam-Webster)
 
The Frankston line, what a shock that is.

The Shalvey of Melbourne.

These are the same people who have been on welfare every day of their adult lives yet complain loudly that the brown people and lately the boat people take away jobs from "Aussies".

It is all just very sad and shouldn't be tolerated in a normal functioning society anywhere
 
We aren't all racists , its just the Balmain fans

The Wests fans are far more accepting of their fellow men

Wests fans are just sexist , thats all
 
Unfortunately, fear and hatred of things that are foreign is a very human trait. When you get enough people together, they feel brave enough to let these base emotions surface. Sad, but hardly unexpected…
 
@reyre2000 said:
Wow, thread title is the most idiotic I've read on here in a while. Just goes to show some people have never traveled the world and spent even the slightest time in other cultures (and no, a 6 day Club Med package to Bali doesn't count) have no idea about world history,geography and basically everything that is going on in the world at the moment but are more than happy to label all of us racist because of a few drunken losers on a bus to nowhere.

CB's point and example is perfect, you see me drinking a beer so we must be all alcoholics. You see me call a Kiwi a dole bludger then we must all be racist (no offence intended to our kiwi friends, just an example to make my point).

Try living in China, India, Central Asia or any country in the Middle East and you'll see REAL racism. How about parts of South East Asia, Africa and South America? Try living in any of those countries or parts of those continents for a year or 5 and then comment on how racist we are.

I have. I see it on a daily basis. I live in China, I've lived in the Middle East. I spend huge amounts of time in India and Sth East Asia. Just yesterday another 2 Tibetans performed self immolation in the Chinese province of Gansu. Can you imagine how that can come to be? Can you imagine the racial and cultural oppression these people suffer on a daily basis to see no other way out but to self suicide by lighting yourself on fire, just in hope that it will grab the worlds attention and something will be done…...this stuff happens on a weekly basis and yet the world does nothing........but when a drunken idiot yells at someone to speak English.....woaaahh, How racist is that?!...just shocking!! Us Australian's are horribly racist people, aren't we.

By the way, have you ever been to France?? Try checking into a hotel and tell them you are a Brit. See their attitude change in an instant once you say you are joking and you show an Aussie passport.
\
\
\
\
Anyways isnt it more accurate to say these idiots were being Xenophobic, rather than Racist. The term racist gets thrown around far too much these days.

xenophobia: intense or irrational dislike or fear of people from other countries (Oxford Dictionary)
xenophobia: unreasonable fear and hatred of strangers or foreigners or of anything that is strange or foreign (Merriam-Webster)

x2
\
\
Yes those 3 on the video were mindless idiots but when it comes to china and india and there racism there are about 2.4 billion mindless idiots.Middle east hmm anyone try opening a meet pie shop there or shouting merry christmas in Saudi arabia.Why do all these people still put there lives on the line to come to this godforesaken racist country full of rednecks.Hmmmmmm while this certainly is a bad postcard moment for australia I wonder if this bloke of arabic background who took these images spent more time on our millions of positive images and less time on the frankston line taking shots of these mugs whether hed be so quick to point out why we are the lucky country.If he dont like it maybe he can go back to his mother country for gee I dont know 2 weeks and take some images of jihad bombings on schools in the middle east as 6 year old kids get murdered while singing Santa claus is coming to town.
 
Back
Top