NSW changes?

[system]

Will NSW make any changes?

I think if there any chance of winning up at qld they need to get rid of uate and creagh. They need to lift to another level if they can get the series and can't with these two.

Bring in woods for creagh and who would be the next in line winger?
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[jason1976]

Barring injuries it will be the same 17.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[hellman]

I think they may have to get rid of Uate. He is a liability defensively.

 

[Tiger_Al]

Yeah, Creagh has to go.
If they are going to use him as a prop, why not just put a prop there?
We again lost go forward when Grant & Tamou came off.

 

[happy_tiger]

Same side I'd imagine

Qld will be a different story Word is that Slater has done a PCL and will be out from 2-6 weeks depending on severity

 

[Rambo2714]

I think 3 of the 5 tries QLD have scored this series have been on Akus wing ,
a fourth was scored because he failed to catch a bomb ,

The fifth wasn't a try , but again it was from a kick to his Wong which he failed to have any impact on .

He has to go , he has had a role in every Queensland try …..

Who is next in line for the wing spot?

Has to be Josh Morris ? I think he would be great ?
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Rambo2714]

Sorry Brett Morris , very easy mistake to make
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Guest]

Woods for Merrin, Ryan for Uate and Douglas for Creagh.

 

[Rambo2714]

Woods For Merrin would be a great Move, but I Cant see Ricky making it

 

[Fraze23]

Yeah, Creagh has to go.
If they are going to use him as a prop, why not just put a prop there?
We again lost go forward when Grant & Tamou came off.

Spot on Al. That's what I can't figure out is they go into the game full well knowing they're going to use Creagh in the front row. I feel we're a prop short given how they use Merrin. For me I'd have any of Woods, Galloway, Gibbs, Douglas, Mannah, Snowden ahead of both Creagh and Merrin.

As for Uate he could run 100m to score a try but he'd let 4 in on the way. Letting the bomb bounce is unacceptable at origin level. I'd have Morris, Ryan or Ferguson in for him in a heartbeat. IMHO Ryan has been the best winger in the competition to date.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[ragedmachine]

Alot of public opinion is spurring around B. Ryan to replace Uate

Wow, what a change in tune, Beau deserves it if so, and will not let anyone down!

 

[Marshall_magic]

No unforced changes

 

[magpiecol]

Woods for Merrin, Ryan for Uate and Douglas for Creagh.

And Lawrence for Jennings.

No way through that backline.

 

[gold_on_black]

They should keep the same side… But if they do drop uate... Merritt maybe... Great finisher and he is a terrific goal kicker... Mini,ryan,ferguson

But for mine uate didn't make the same mistakes as last game and will b better the 3rd game... He started running hard at the end.

I think uate is the long term wing option... So we should persist
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[steve-o]

how quickly people forget… uate was one of our best players last series. he's had two bad games, i doubt he'll have a 3rd. and as gold on black said, hes the best long term option, so we should stick with him. if there was a winger crying out to be picked then fair enough, but theres not. id rather uate over morris, ryan, ferguson and anyone else thats been mentioned. im with marshall_magic - no unforced changes

 

[gold_on_black]

Woods for Merrin, Ryan for Uate and Douglas for Creagh.

And Lawrence for Jennings.

No way through that backline.

I think you have your tiger glasses on mate
Jennings had a great game game 1\. And game two whilst didn't offer much in attack his try saver on Tate was something
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[steve-o]

again, i have to agree with gold on black in the jennings v lawrance debate. jennings was great in origin one, and was solid last night. lawrence has been below average all year

 

[magpiecol]

Lawrence getting back to form. Best defensive centre in the game by far. Strong runner who knows how to feed his wingers. Very quick and because of his size, very hard to control.

Jennings, fast. Defense suspect. Dropped to reserve grade because of bad form.

As far as It is concerned, if he did not play in the first two games, NSW would be leading 2-0\. Weststigers glasses or not, Ryan is the form winger in the NRL at the moment. Would not let anyone down. Can at least catch a bomb and knows when to come in defensively.

No brainer.

 

[steve-o]

Lawrence getting back to form. Best defensive centre in the game by far. Strong runner who knows how to feed his wingers. Very quick and because of his size, very hard to control.

Jennings, fast. Defense suspect. Dropped to reserve grade because of bad form.

As far as It is concerned, if he did not play in the first two games, NSW would be leading 2-0\. Weststigers glasses or not, Ryan is the form winger in the NRL at the moment. Would not let anyone down. Can at least catch a bomb and knows when to come in defensively.

No brainer.

best defensive centre in the game? hodges, cooper and lyon are better for starters. i think hes lacking a bit of pace this year, could have something to do with his niggling injuries earlier in the year.

jennings was dropped more for attitude than bad performances. he was one of NSWs best in origin one, and he shouldnt have been sinbinned for what he did anyway.

i love beau, but origin is a class above him. form in the NRL does not make a good origin player. look at wolfman or steve turner as an example. uate, morris, and ferguson would be better options on the wing. no one other than tigers supporters have put beaus name out there, so it clearly has something to do with those tigers coloured glasses

 

[Marshall_magic]

Beau in my opinion would be another selection in the Turner, Quinn, Williams, McManus, Morris mold. He does everything asked of him at club level, but might not have that next level in him. If being a safe finisher was all it took for a winger to make origin, Michael Robertson would have a closet full of NSW jerseys, but he doesn't even have one. Uate and Hayne whilst they may have mistakes in them, have a lot more X-factor to their games than Beau.