Please Explain To Me The Alleged Knock-On???

[Honkylips]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

 

[tony soprano]

I didn’t see it either

 

[hobbo1]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry 😤

 

[Honkylips]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry ?

I replayed it a couple of times and I'm at a loss.

 

[hobbo1]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry ?

I replayed it a couple of times and I'm at a loss.

There needed to be a camera shot from the other side ... there was none ..
Games rigged ?

 

[Honkylips]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry ?

I replayed it a couple of times and I'm at a loss.

There needed to be a camera shot from the other side ... there was none ..
Games rigged ?

It was similar to when you are carrying a couple of books and they slip. You re-adjust to stop them from being dropped. It is madness.

 

[NJLM78]

Pleased that someone posted about this. I was fortunate enough to be at the game and sitting in line with that tackle. I really couldn't see a knock on. A genuinely good tackle but I never saw the ball being lost. From memory it took a while before the whistle was blown to rule a knock on?

 

[mike]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It wasn’t. You knew from that moment that it looked like Gee had money on the Panthers.

 

[Tim Sheens]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry ?

I just watched it again on Kayo, with him juggling the ball as Kikau half ripped it out whilst they were getting to their feet. The tackle had long been completed, the ball didn't hit another player after the opposition player dislodged it whilst removing his arm from under it, so stuffed if I know how it could be anything other than a penalty to WT if not play on, as it can't be a loose carry at that point.

 

[TheDaBoss]

Geenius play

 

[Needaname]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry ?

I just watched it again on Kayo, with him juggling the ball as Kikau half ripped it out whilst they were getting to their feet. The tackle had long been completed, the ball didn't hit another player after the opposition player dislodged it whilst removing his arm from under it, so stuffed if I know how it could be anything other than a penalty to WT if not play on, as it can't be a loose carry at that point.

I haven’t seen it close up but going off your description above that is 100% a knock on.
If a player loses possession into another player and then regathers it, it is a knock on. You described it as Clark lost control of the ball as Kikau removed his hand, with his hand on the ball and Clark grabbed it again. That unfortunately as the rules state a knock on. Some more fortunate teams may have been overlooked here but it’s still a knock on.

 

[Tim Sheens]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry ?

I just watched it again on Kayo, with him juggling the ball as Kikau half ripped it out whilst they were getting to their feet. The tackle had long been completed, the ball didn't hit another player after the opposition player dislodged it whilst removing his arm from under it, so stuffed if I know how it could be anything other than a penalty to WT if not play on, as it can't be a loose carry at that point.

I haven’t seen it close up but going off your description above that is 100% a knock on.
If a player loses possession into another player and then regathers it, it is a knock on. You described it as Clark lost control of the ball as Kikau removed his hand, with his hand on the ball and Clark grabbed it again. That unfortunately as the rules state a knock on. Some more fortunate teams may have been overlooked here but it’s still a knock on.

Clark, what's it got to do with him?

No, hands on the ball is not allowed after a tackle is completed and it didn't touch the opposition after being removed. If it was stripped in a tackle then hit the ground it would be a knock on against the stripper and six again if the attacker regained possession, which is what happened, as Kikau effectively stripped it as he removed his arm after the tackle was completed. It would be totally different had he held position as a tangled defender and Garner had dropped it.

 

[rah53]

Just watched it again, Kikau racked the ball. And we got done for a loose carry.

 

[Needaname]

The tackle that gave Penrith the ball for them to score their first try. I foget who it was got smashed in the tackle and as he was standing up the ball slipped down to his hip where he kept hold of it. How is that a knock on???
I rarely knock refs but last night was horrible.

It was all the blind refs interpretation

No one will ever know as there was no replay

We were ripped off ..

I’m still angry ?

I just watched it again on Kayo, with him juggling the ball as Kikau half ripped it out whilst they were getting to their feet. The tackle had long been completed, the ball didn't hit another player after the opposition player dislodged it whilst removing his arm from under it, so stuffed if I know how it could be anything other than a penalty to WT if not play on, as it can't be a loose carry at that point.

I haven’t seen it close up but going off your description above that is 100% a knock on.
If a player loses possession into another player and then regathers it, it is a knock on. You described it as Clark lost control of the ball as Kikau removed his hand, with his hand on the ball and Clark grabbed it again. That unfortunately as the rules state a knock on. Some more fortunate teams may have been overlooked here but it’s still a knock on.

Clark, what's it got to do with him?

No, hands on the ball is not allowed after a tackle is completed and it didn't touch the opposition after being removed. If it was stripped in a tackle then hit the ground it would be a knock on against the stripper and six again if the attacker regained possession, which is what happened, as Kikau effectively stripped it as he removed his arm after the tackle was completed. It would be totally different had he held position as a tangled defender and Garner had dropped it.

Garner, right, I actually thought it was him. But someone mentioned Clark at the game so I got mistaken.

I think the most recent poster explained what I was trying to say. Whether or not he dropped it, it is ruled a loose carry ‘unless’ the referee decides that Kikau had striped the ball out of his hands. As he wasn’t, and as you mentioned he removed his arm after the tackle was completed and we bobbled it whether or not it feel to the ground he still lost control by way of a strip that wasn’t called.
Should have been called a strip 6 again, but obviously the ref didn’t think Kikau made a deliberate attempt to strip the ball. He was just wrapping the ball up.

 

[Tim Sheens]

Just watched it again, Kikau racked the ball. And we got done for a loose carry.

Yeah, but unlike dislodging by contact with the arm, it can't be a loose carry when the ball is touched.

 

[rah53]

Just watched it again, Kikau racked the ball. And we got done for a loose carry.

Yeah, but unlike dislodging by contact with the arm, it can't be a loose carry when the ball is touched.

I not disagreeing with you. But that is what the ref saw. We could've challenged & I believe we would've won, but it is way too early in the game to risk & use up the challenge.

 

[weststigers]

It cost us a huge momentum early on...one of several bad calls during the game.

 

[clontarfkid]

That poor initial decision set the tone for the game..as did the absence of Joey in the defensive line for the ensuing try.Bad start.
It was a great tackle,but no knock on
.....and the other decion which impacted the game was Korosais chep shot on Luciano which just received a penalty and no more

 

[Fraze23]

If only there was a way for us to challenge these bad calls...

 

[Telltails]

If that was a loose carry then every player should be on notice. Absolutely atrocious call and cost us dearly.