Talent lost under Madge’s watch:
Ryan Matterson - not everyone’s cup of tea. But the one and only year he was here nearly made the 8 and he had his best season in NRL.
Luciano Leilua - arguably our best forward. Reckons he loves Madge and one of the few players who has improved. Massive offer from Cowboys but why wasn’t he locked away on a better deal earlier.
Kelma Tuilagi - Killed it in NSW cup last year and was only given a 1 year extension for 22. Manly swooped. If you watched cup games last year he was scoring a lot tries and a handful for opposition teams. Not sure why he wasn’t offered minimum 2 year deal.
Benji Marshall - Moved on from the club. Again we didn’t improve at all. If anything went backwards.
Josh Mow my lawn Aloai - he was a tough player, had an error in him but offers a lot more than what we have currently.
Not sure what we can do to turn this around. This ship has sunk to new lows.
You forgot to mention
Packer
Mbye
Reynolds
McQueen