Joel Reddy

His work with ball in hand is good , can’t say the same for his defense

His shoulder grabbing ( and missing, before hurrel scored ) effort on hurrel in the 79th minute was disappointing to say he least …

Has anyone else watched him closely and developed an opinion on his ability and performers to date ?

IMO , he is playing the same football which resulted in Parramatta letting him go .


Posted using RoarFEED 2012

@Rambo2714:

His work with ball in hand is good , can’t say the same for his defense

His shoulder grabbing ( and missing, before hurrel scored ) effort on hurrel in the 79th minute was disappointing to say he least …

Has anyone else watched him closely and developed an opinion on his ability and performers to date ?

IMO , he is playing the same football which resulted in Parramatta letting him go .


Posted using RoarFEED 2012

Reddy had a long way to run to cover for Lote who was in the MIDDLE of the park!!! WTF???

@Rambo2714:

His work with ball in hand is good , can’t say the same for his defense

His shoulder grabbing ( and missing, before hurrel scored ) effort on hurrel in the 79th minute was disappointing to say he least …

Has anyone else watched him closely and developed an opinion on his ability and performers to date ?

IMO , he is playing the same football which resulted in Parramatta letting him go .


Posted using RoarFEED 2012

This is the same Reddy, who smacked into Glen fishiatis knee at full speed in the first half, and probably wasn’t the same since?

He’s been solid as all hell all year, and many other greater players will miss tackles on Konrad Hurrell during his football career, I can assure you of that,

@magpiecol:

@Rambo2714:

His work with ball in hand is good , can’t say the same for his defense

His shoulder grabbing ( and missing, before hurrel scored ) effort on hurrel in the 79th minute was disappointing to say he least …

Has anyone else watched him closely and developed an opinion on his ability and performers to date ?

IMO , he is playing the same football which resulted in Parramatta letting him go .


Posted using RoarFEED 2012

Reddy had a long way to run to cover for Lote who was in the MIDDLE of the park!!! WTF???

You do realise that the try was scored of a kickoff and the team does not have a set defensive line in that situation causing players to be out of their traditional positions when the kicking team regathers

It was a disappointing effort at tackling but the whole team just panicked. Even though it was obvious the Warriors would kick short and then pass the ball, nobody moved up on the other side of the field. Liam Fulton sprinted into the middle and then had to sprint back to cover out wide. The whole team and the coaching staff need to be better prepared for these situations.

But back to Joel… Despite the fact the try came from a kick off and the defensive lines were in ruins, the actual tackle was weak especially given it was needed to stop a try. The mitigating factors don’t give you a pass to make an ineffectual tackle. We’ve had a few of those in the final minute this year where it seemed the opposition player wanted it more than our guy.

That aside I think Reddy has been pretty good since he came into the team.

@Rambo2714:

His work with ball in hand is good , can’t say the same for his defense

His shoulder grabbing ( and missing, before hurrel scored ) effort on hurrel in the 79th minute was disappointing to say he least …

Has anyone else watched him closely and developed an opinion on his ability and performers to date ?

IMO , he is playing the same football which resulted in Parramatta letting Posted using RoarFEED 2012

x2…I would not like to tackle Hurrel myself but it was a really poor attempt.

I was actually speaking about the criticism of Lote being out of position, sorry to confuse. The attempted tackle by Reddy was very ordinary.

He has been better for us than I was expecting.

@rossop:

@Rambo2714:

His work with ball in hand is good , can’t say the same for his defense

His shoulder grabbing ( and missing, before hurrel scored ) effort on hurrel in the 79th minute was disappointing to say he least …

Has anyone else watched him closely and developed an opinion on his ability and performers to date ?

IMO , he is playing the same football which resulted in Parramatta letting Posted using RoarFEED 2012

x2…I would not like to tackle Hurrel myself but it was a really poor attempt.

Gents, long time follower of the forum, first time poster. Thought this would be a good time to chime in after a gutsy win at Leichhardt that I observed from the front Row of the Robinson stand. I’ve seen two posts from the this game regarding the last try, one bashing Lote and the other Reddy. As far as im concerned that last try was a freak and the boys might well have already been in the sheds celebrating. Defence was scrambling and you cant blame anybody. Have you see what other players Hurrell has shrugged off this year?? The haters on here are seriously clutching at straws. Reddy is solid

That last try was all ass and hurell is a freak he is massive and he can move. Like utai hard to tackle!

Reddy is a great plater and I am a big fan now…. He a asset to the tigers. Rate him highly.

@cochise:

I was actually speaking about the criticism of Lote being out of position, sorry to confuse. The attempted tackle by Reddy was very ordinary.

He has been better for us than I was expecting.

I sort have got the idea that the idea of this thread is that last try to the Warriors!!!
The Sheep Shaggers pulled off a great play but unfortunately they ‘were’ NEVER in a position to win the game, Joel Reddy has been sensational all year & while I’m a little critical of Lote if he continues to score 1 or 2 tries as opposed to the customary try he will allow to be scored down his side when out of position, then I’m a happy Tigers fan.

@GoldXR50Leroy:

@cochise:

I was actually speaking about the criticism of Lote being out of position, sorry to confuse. The attempted tackle by Reddy was very ordinary.

He has been better for us than I was expecting.

I sort have got the idea that the idea of this thread is that last try to the Warriors!!!
The Sheep Shaggers pulled off a great play but unfortunately they ‘were’ NEVER in a position to win the game, Joel Reddy has been sensational all year & while I’m a little critical of Lote if he continues to score 1 or 2 tries as opposed to the customary try he will allow to be scored down his side when out of position, then I’m a happy Tigers fan.

I too have been very happy with Reddy, that one tackle though was an ordinary attempt. He has been very strong for us and has forced his way into the centres, which at the start of the year I didnt think her would be a chance of doing

Lol at parra they lose 2 gun superstars joel reddy and tom humble that was useless they didnt re sign them oh well there tigers players now im glad they are go u tigers.

excellent player , few more games to blend in , same for blair , bells been great , humble good to

The thing thats gud about joel reddy he chases bombs thats what we need he will get trys out of it this year hopefully.

It’s hard to stomach any Parra rejects in a Tiger’s jumper. Hopefully we get back to full strength soon as I think they’ll struggle to even get s look in then.


Posted using RoarFEED 2012

Recent Topics

Support our community by clicking here and joining our Forum Support Scheme