This Team Keep or Punt

James Tadesco - Keep
David Nofoaluma - Keep
Blake Ayshford - Punt
Tim Simona - Keep
Joel Reddy - Punt
Benji Marshall - Punt
Curtis Sironen - Keep
Aaron Woods - Keep
Masada Iosefa - Punt
Adam Blair - Punt
Eddy Pettybourne - Punt
Ben Murdoch-Masila - Punt
Braith Anasta - Punt
Suaso Sue - Keep
Jack Buchanan - Keep
Ava Seumanufagai - Keep
Liam Fulton - Keep

Lawrence - Keep
Chris Lawrence - Keep
Bodene Thompson - Keep
Matt Utai - Punt
Keith Galloway - Keep
Lote Tuqiri - Punt
James Gavet - Keep
Matt Bell - Keep
Tim Moltzen - Keep

you kept Lawrence twice, and thats two times more than you should have.

lol just realised that I’ve got him twice

@Chris:

James Tadesco - Keep
David Nofoaluma - Keep
Blake Ayshford - Punt
Tim Simona - Keep
Joel Reddy - Punt
Benji Marshall - Punt
Curtis Sironen - Keep
Aaron Woods - Keep
Masada Iosefa - Punt
Adam Blair - Punt
Eddy Pettybourne - Punt
Ben Murdoch-Masila - Punt
Braith Anasta - Punt
Suaso Sue - Keep
Jack Buchanan - Keep
Ava Seumanufagai - Keep
Liam Fulton - Keep

Lawrence - Keep
Chris Lawrence - Keep
Bodene Thompson - Keep
Matt Utai - Punt
Keith Galloway - Keep
Lote Tuqiri - Punt
James Gavet - Keep
Matt Bell - Keep
Tim Moltzen - Keep

Pretty much in agreement with all this but would punt Bell and keep BMM.

Bell has been solid but you can’t have both him and Fulton in the 17. BMM would kill it if our forward pack could put up an even fight.

I will also give Marshall until the end of the year. He has earnt my patience but it is wearing thin.

Posted using RoarFEED 2013

Agree entirely with the first 17, keep Lawrence and moltzen though?

Posted using RoarFEED 2013

You kept Moltzen ,that ruins your post , but I do agree with the rest , barring Lawrence who is finished as a first grade centre

Punt Moltzen too

Posted using RoarFEED 2013

OP got it pretty much spot on.

Agree with absolutely all of those

@Black’n’White:

you kept Lawrence twice, and thats two times more than you should have.

Yeah I’d let go of Lawrence and keep BMM.

I just think Moltzen is good to keep with his utility value and I’d give Lawrence another chance and if that doesnt work then I’d give him a go in the forwards.

if only things were that easy, but in the real world contracts have to be paid.

Punt Lawrence
Keep BMM or Braith. preferable BMM.

@Chris:

I just think Moltzen is good to keep with his utility value and I’d give Lawrence another chance and if that doesnt work then I’d give him a go in the forwards.

I’m with you mate. Moltzen will cheap coming off a second ACL. Adds good depth but shouldn’t be first choice going forward. I would give Chris some more time. He is still young enough to turn around.

Posted using RoarFEED 2013

@Chris:

James Tadesco - Keep
David Nofoaluma - Keep
Blake Ayshford - Keep it was his first game back tonight and he was playing well b4 injury
Tim Simona - Keep
Joel Reddy - Punt
Benji Marshall - fix or punt something needs to be done but not sure punt
Curtis Sironen - Keep
Aaron Woods - Keep
Masada Iosefa - Keep only because who would be better in nsw cup ?
Adam Blair - Keep - has been playing well and was good tonight
Eddy Pettybourne - Punt
Ben Murdoch-Masila - Punt probably
Braith Anasta - Keep he has been a great influence on our team and good for junior halves
Suaso Sue - Keep
Jack Buchanan - Keep
Ava Seumanufagai - Keep
Liam Fulton - Keep

Chris Lawrence - Keep depending on how he comes back
Bodene Thompson - Punt - offers very little
Matt Utai - Punt
Keith Galloway - Keep
Lote Tuqiri - Punt
James Gavet - Keep
Matt Bell - Punt time is up and we have better options
Tim Moltzen - Keep but only as backup depth so if he costs too much punt

Recent Topics

Support our community by clicking here and joining our Forum Support Scheme

Can’t log in or access your account?
Send an email to contact@weststigersforum.com and we’ll get you back online.