Cleary persisting with MCK



  • Why is ivan cleary persisting with mck on the right edge he has bad reads in defence he cannot turn and chase he is at best a bench 2ndrower. Why is cleary sticking with him?



  • No idea but what are our other options ?



  • I would say it’s because we have no one else. He gave MWZ a run and doesn’t rate him there for whatever reason and we have no one else in reserves ready to stand up. Marsters is being blooded which may change things later in the season



  • @:

    No idea but what are our other options ?

    I would go with marsters in the centre’s with nofoaluma drop cheekham to the bench at least to start the game.



  • Really shows our lack of depth when we are starting guys like MCK, Grant, Lovett, Sue, Kevin at FB and previously Littlejohn. All mentioned would struggle to make most other team’s ISP sides. based on this Cleary is still a few solid first grade level forwards off a decent side next year.



  • Because there’s no one better? Very harsh judging his team selections this year.


  • ForumSupporter

    Nathan Milone has been among the best performers week in week out in ISP this year…

    Unfortunately ISP are getting flogged as well week in week out…as well…



  • @:

    Nathan Milone has been among the best performers week in week out in ISP this year…

    Unfortunately ISP are getting flogged as well week in week out…as well…

    Seriously Geo?
    The board would go into meltdown. 😆



  • I really think Cleary would be better off naming Ivan at centre than Michael 😆 😆 😆 :supporter:



  • I can only assume, as some people have noted, he does not rate MWZ highly enough, or MWZ is carrying an injury.

    Also he must think Marsters is not a is a stop-gap option for centres, or if he is, he doesn’t have 80 mins in him.



  • @:

    I can only assume, as some people have noted, he does not rate MWZ highly enough, or MWZ is carrying an injury.

    Also he must think Marsters is not a is a stop-gap option for centres, or if he is, he doesn’t have 80 mins in him.

    Mwz is playing wing



  • No depth so MCK it is…



  • @:

    @:

    I can only assume, as some people have noted, he does not rate MWZ highly enough, or MWZ is carrying an injury.

    Also he must think Marsters is not a is a stop-gap option for centres, or if he is, he doesn’t have 80 mins in him.

    Mwz is playing wing

    Rate him for centres.



  • @:

    Nathan Milone has been among the best performers week in week out in ISP this year…

    Unfortunately ISP are getting flogged as well week in week out…as well…

    I agree Milone has been playing well but he’s proved many times in the past that he is absolutely NOT first grade material.



  • @:

    Nathan Milone has been among the best performers week in week out in ISP this year…

    Unfortunately ISP are getting flogged as well week in week out…as well…

    That’s pretty standard.
    He’s always done well at ISP level.



Recent Topics