Rank the Coaches



  • Just wondering how people will rate the 2017 coaches from 1-16 and how their ranking will affect their performances and sitting on the table next year

    Mine

    1 Bellamy
    2 Green
    3 Flanagan
    4 Arthurs
    5 Barrett
    6 Brown
    7 Bennett
    8 Robinson
    9 Stuart
    10 Cleary
    11 McGregor
    12 Griffin
    13 Seibold
    14 Brennan
    15 Pay
    16 Kearney

    Thoughts ?? Your 16 in order ??



  • 1. Cleary

    rest do not matter……



  • @:

    Just wondering how people will rate the 2017 coaches from 1-16 and how their ranking will affect their performances and sitting on the table next year

    Mine

    1 Bellamy
    2 Green
    3 Flanagan
    4 Arthurs
    5 Barrett
    6 Brown
    7 Bennett
    8 Robinson
    9 Stuart
    10 Cleary
    11 McGregor
    12 Griffin
    13 Seibold
    14 Brennan
    15 Pay
    16 Kearney

    Thoughts ?? Your 16 in order ??

    Nathan Brown at number 6? You need your head read!



  • 1. Bellamy by a mile
    2. Arthurs- doing great with Parra
    3. Bennett - can’t stand him but his record is great
    4.Cleary - from what I’ve seen so far
    5. Flanagan - has built a great roster
    6. Green - getting better and better
    7. Barrett - on the way up
    8. Brown - seems to get players respect
    9. Robinson - not sure. Needs to win 2018 I think
    10. McGregor - goes ok in patches
    11.seibold
    12. Brennan
    13. Pay
    14.Stuart - way too tense and uptight
    15. Griffen - doesn’t get player buy in
    16. Kearney - doesn’t seem to have it



  • @:

    @:

    Just wondering how people will rate the 2017 coaches from 1-16 and how their ranking will affect their performances and sitting on the table next year

    Mine

    1 Bellamy
    2 Green
    3 Flanagan
    4 Arthurs
    5 Barrett
    6 Brown
    7 Bennett
    8 Robinson
    9 Stuart
    10 Cleary
    11 McGregor
    12 Griffin
    13 Seibold
    14 Brennan
    15 Pay
    16 Kearney

    Thoughts ?? Your 16 in order ??

    Nathan Brown at number 6? You need your head read!

    Thats Happy for ya…always a ‘controversial’ element to his pieces…wait for the reply!
    Shoulda been a DT journo, or talk back shock jock Hap



  • 1.Bellamy
    2. Green
    3. Arthurs
    4. Flannagan
    5. Bennett
    6 .Barrett
    7. Cleary
    8. Robinson
    9. Brown
    10. Stuart
    11 McGregor
    12 Griffin
    13. Pay
    14. Seibold
    15. Brennan
    16 Kearney


  • ForumSupporter

    A Coach is mostly only as good as their rosters…

    Rank the Rosters would have been a better idea…



  • Cleary is a good coach. He handled some petulant players with poor attitudes extremely well last season and cut the cancer out of the club. He has then bought reasonably well and hopefully we perform better than what we did last year.

    I don’t care where he gets rated because the coach is only as good as his cattle. If Cleary gets the most out of the team he has at his disposable that is all we can ask.



  • Very hard to rank coaches as there are many attributes which contribute to their outcomes.

    Executive Management & the Balance of Talent in the Squad all play a major part.

    I’ve put them into Tiers:

    Teir 1: Bellamy, Green, Bennett
    Teir 2: Robinson, Flanagan, Arthur
    Teir 3: Brown, Barrett, Stuart, Griffin, Cleary
    Teir 4: McGregor, Kearney, Brennan
    Teir 5: Seibold, Pay



  • Where they finished last year with the exception of Pay he goes to 16 and every coach on that finished under the dogs moves up one spot.



  • 1. Bellamy
    2. Green
    3. Robinson
    4. Flanagan
    5. Arthur
    6. Bennett
    7. Barrett
    8. Stuart
    9. Cleary
    10. Brown
    11. Griffin
    12. McGregor
    13-15 (in no order as they are untested) Brennan, Pay, Seibold
    16. Kearney.

    Kearney is last because he is honestly the most hopeless first grade coach I have seen. He makes JT look like Jack Gibson.



  • Bellamy by the greatest margin, Not cause he has the big 4 plus the rest (Inglis, Hoffman etc)

    Virtually every player i can think of is a better and more disciplined player after time under him.



  • @:

    @:

    @:

    Just wondering how people will rate the 2017 coaches from 1-16 and how their ranking will affect their performances and sitting on the table next year

    Mine

    1 Bellamy
    2 Green
    3 Flanagan
    4 Arthurs
    5 Barrett
    6 Brown
    7 Bennett
    8 Robinson
    9 Stuart
    10 Cleary
    11 McGregor
    12 Griffin
    13 Seibold
    14 Brennan
    15 Pay
    16 Kearney

    Thoughts ?? Your 16 in order ??

    Nathan Brown at number 6? You need your head read!

    Thats Happy for ya…always a ‘controversial’ element to his pieces…wait for the reply!
    Shoulda been a DT journo, or talk back shock jock Hap

    Brown was a hard one Ink

    He has seen both ends of the spectrum , early on he had a team of superstars that should of won a premiership and didn’t and it cost him his job

    Then he had a side that no one expected anything from and has attracted many players despite winning two consecutive spoons

    I think Brown would have learnt a lot from his first stint as an NRL coach and I think that Newcastle will challenge far more greatly for a Top 8 spot than the WT’s will personally

    Cleary had a fantastic record making the Top 8 4 of his first 5 seasons but has only done it once in the last 5 years

    The WT’s will need to recruit some much needed talent in 2018 to be a Top 8 chance in 2019

    We are very likely to be spoon favourites in 2018 along with the Titans


  • ForumSupporter

    @:

    @:

    @:

    @:

    Just wondering how people will rate the 2017 coaches from 1-16 and how their ranking will affect their performances and sitting on the table next year

    Mine

    1 Bellamy
    2 Green
    3 Flanagan
    4 Arthurs
    5 Barrett
    6 Brown
    7 Bennett
    8 Robinson
    9 Stuart
    10 Cleary
    11 McGregor
    12 Griffin
    13 Seibold
    14 Brennan
    15 Pay
    16 Kearney

    Thoughts ?? Your 16 in order ??

    Nathan Brown at number 6? You need your head read!

    Thats Happy for ya…always a ‘controversial’ element to his pieces…wait for the reply!
    Shoulda been a DT journo, or talk back shock jock Hap

    Brown was a hard one Ink

    He has seen both ends of the spectrum , early on he had a team of superstars that should of won a premiership and didn’t and it cost him his job

    Then he had a side that no one expected anything from and has attracted many players despite winning two consecutive spoons

    I think Brown would have learnt a lot from his first stint as an NRL coach and I think that Newcastle will challenge far more greatly for a Top 8 spot than the WT’s will personally

    Cleary had a fantastic record making the Top 8 4 of his first 5 seasons but has only done it once in the last 5 years

    The WT’s will need to recruit some much needed talent in 2018 to be a Top 8 chance in 2019

    We are very likely to be spoon favourites in 2018 along with the Titans

    I think you forgot a team called the NZ Warriors while you were away…



  • I know your deliberately keeping your expectations low Happy, but there’s no way we’ll be fighting for the spoon in 2018.


Log in to reply
 

Recent Topics