Top 5 Most Hated Wests Tiger Coach or Player



  • 1 JT
    2 Lamb ( whoever signed him)
    3 Blair
    4 Anastasia
    5 Sheens



  • @:

    1 JT
    2 Lamb ( whoever signed him)
    3 Blair
    4 Anastasia
    5 Sheens

    Sheens?
    I can’t think of anyone who hates the guy.
    He just got stale.
    He was our best coach by a long way.


  • ForumSupporter

    Terry Hill A+



  • @:

    @:

    1 JT
    2 Lamb ( whoever signed him)
    3 Blair
    4 Anastasia
    5 Sheens

    Sheens?
    I can’t think of anyone who hates the guy.
    He just got stale.
    He was our best coach by a long way.

    Yeah did get stale but started our terrible culture at the club IMO



  • 1 Terry Lamb
    2 John Hopoate
    3 Mitchell Moses
    4 Braith Anasta
    5 Reserved for Cleary



  • 1. Waste Anasta
    2. Teddy Blair
    3. Michelle Moses
    4. Soft Woods
    5. How to pay back a club who helped you through two serious knee injuries - Tedesco



  • Can’t believe I forgot Andrew Fifita… I’ll add him to my list



  • I can’t believe I forgot Nick Graham

    Everyone should add him to their lists and bloody near the top as well



  • The following is based on guys who tried to destroy the club through arrogance or greed.
    1. JT a no talent coach who rather than learning from his multiple stupid mistakes justified his unbelievable selections, eg Jordan Rankin
    2. Terry Hill. Paid top dollar, couldn’t shut his mouth and apparently was the reason why Craig Bellamy didn’t sign with the club
    3. Terry Lamb
    4. Tim Sheens (last years as coach) destroyed team spirit by moving on players still on contract, who wanted to stay and who put out for the club(eg Bryce Gibbs Chris Heighington, Andrew Fifita) and signed Adam Blair, Braith Anasta
    5. Mitchell Moses.
    Can’t understand why guys have been nominated who were at the end of their careers but still tried or legends of the club who may have played on too long.



  • Hmmm, so many options. 😂

    This all most needs be broken down into the first and second decades. These ones come to mind without a thought:

    Adam Blair
    Corey Patterson
    Justin Hunt
    Jordan Rankin
    Nathan Milone



  • Ive got Wayne Pearce number one. Massive Balmain fan but Junior set us on the road to ruin. He had a huge salary cap and blew it on morons like Terry Hill. Whats more he had no coaching skill.

    I pretty much hate everyone who has been appointed because they used to play for Wests or Balmain. every single one of them has damaged the club.

    1. Pearce
    2. Lamb ( dead set useless)
    3. Taylor ( as above )
    4. Cleary
    5. Woods



  • 1. JT - nothing good came while he was at he club
    2. Mitchell Moses - last game had more missed tackles than metres gained
    3. Johnny Cronk - should never had been near half back
    4. John Carlaw - just awful
    5. Shannon McDonnell - Overhyped to the max



  • Can’t believe I forgot Fitzy. Made an entire career out of being a passenger. I think John Wilson was a far better player, and was a lot more deserving of a spot in the 05 side.

    Joel Caine was another infuriating player from the early years. Stumbling, bumbling hack.



  • @:

    1. JT - nothing good came while he was at he club
    2. Mitchell Moses - last game had more missed tackles than metres gained
    3. Johnny Cronk - should never had been near half back
    4. John Carlaw - just awful
    5. Shannon McDonnell - Overhyped to the max

    That wasn’t his fault., blame Sheens for that. He was a hooker, who Sheens tried to mold, and failed miserably. Morris gave it his all when he played for us. Didn’t miss a game in 3 years. You don’t play 300 games if you aren’t a decent player.



  • @:

    @:

    1. JT - nothing good came while he was at he club
    2. Mitchell Moses - last game had more missed tackles than metres gained
    3. Johnny Cronk - should never had been near half back
    4. John Carlaw - just awful
    5. Shannon McDonnell - Overhyped to the max

    That wasn’t his fault., blame Sheens for that. He was a hooker, who Sheens tried to mold, and failed miserably. Morris gave it his all when he played for us. Didn’t miss a game in 3 years. You don’t play 300 games if you aren’t a decent player.

    I know - I probably would have disliked him less if he missed a few games


Log in to reply
 

Recent Topics