Wests Tigers All-Time best team



  • Using every Wests Tigers player in the past and present, what is your best 1-13 OR 1-17.

    1. Brett Hodgson
    2. Pat Richards
    3. Esan Marsters
    4. Kevin Naiqama ?
    5. Josh Addo-Carr
    6. Scott Prince
    7. Luke Brooks
    8. Andrew Fifita
    9. Robbie Farah
    10. Ryan Matterson
    11. Chris Lawrence
    12. Alex Twal
    13. Dene Halatau

    May have missed a few



  • We have a golden boot winner from a few years back you missed



  • This post is deleted!


  • Your team is a gee up, surely.



  • No offence meant but how you could possibly leave out our best forward to play for the JV (Ellis) and not pick Tuaki on the wing escapes me.Kevin Naq would make the bottom 50 players we have ever had,
    Benji for all his faults would have to be in the team also.



  • Tedesco
    Richards
    Whats Or masters
    Lawrence pre hammies/hip
    JAC Or Tui
    Benji
    Prince
    Fifita
    Farah
    Woods
    Ellis
    Matterson or Dwyer
    Galea (most underrated imo)

    Bench
    Twal
    Skando
    Heighno
    Hodgson

    Coach Tim Maguire

    Where I’ve hedged my bets I’ve used the long established WT tradition of paying out on potential



  • Hodgson
    Tuiaki
    Hill
    Lawrence (pre hip )
    Tuqiri
    Marshall
    Prince
    Taupau
    Farah
    Fifita
    Ellis
    Dwyer
    Payten

    Tedesco
    Laffranchi
    Woods
    McCracken



  • Hodgson
    Tuiaki
    Lawrence
    Hill
    Richards
    Marshall
    Prince
    Matterson
    Ellis
    Dwyer
    Fifita
    Farah
    Woods
    Twal
    Halatau
    Teo (still a germ though)
    Gibbs



  • How anyone hasn’t picked Taupau ……

    Luke O’Donnell probably unlucky as well

    The comment was past or present so form can be based on form from other clubs …



  • Tbh I forgot. I’d take him ahead of Galea



  • Some of these are absolutely taking the piss

    1. Hodgson
    2. Tuiaki
    3. Lawrence
    4. Whatiura
    5. Tuquiri
    6. Marshall
    7. Prince
    8. Skandalis
    9. Farah
    10. Galloway
    11. Ellis
    12. Laffranchi
    13. Galea

    14. Fulton
    15. Woods
    16. Payten
    17. Tedesco



  • not sure if you are joking.
    matterson?
    Naiqama?
    Twal?
    Brooks???

    may have missed a few??? really?
    :man_facepalming:



  • I think the only legitimate positional battle would be fullback (Hodgson v Tedesco).
    Wingers are either Tui, Tuqiri or Richards. JAC or Koro just miss….
    The rest, forwards and bench are almost kinda obvious.

    @happy_tiger - I like Dwyer.
    McCracken never really had a go with us, surely he can’t count…and Hill over Whatuira? I don’t think so…

    Centre has been our weakest position historically. I’d have Whatuira and Buddha - a bit of old school and a lot of x-factor!


  • ForumSupporter

    Terry Hill someone’s having a lend gawd even Elford or White l
    Legs over him…

    But must have missed Whats…



  • But as was mentioned past …… as in Manly …or even Wests …

    Terry Hill at his best was so far ahead of Whatuira its not even funny …


Log in to reply
 

Recent Topics