This year's Hall of Fame nominees

Fullbacks

  1. Eric Simms
  2. Gary Belcher
  3. Garry Jack

Wing

  1. Denis Flannery
  2. Ian Moir
  3. Michael Hancock

Centre

  1. Steve Renouf
  2. Michael O’Connor

Five-eighth

  1. Kevin Walters

Halfback

  1. Geoff Toovey
  2. Stacey Jones
  3. Greg Alexander

Lock

  1. Les Cowie
  2. Bob Lindner

Second row

  1. Dick Thornett
  2. Terry Randall
  3. Rod Reddy
  4. Paul Vautin
  5. Paul Sironen
  6. Craig Fitzgibbon

Prop

  1. Craig Young
  2. Ruben Wiki
  3. Paul Harragon

Hookers

  1. Elwyn Walters
  2. Danny Buderus

Reckon I’d go Simms, Stacey Jones, Buderus.

I’d go Moir, Cowie and Fitzgibbon

@Masterton said in This year's Hall of Fame nominees:

Reckon I’d go Simms, Stacey Jones, Buderus.

Simms played 1 game for NSW (pre Origin) and only 8 tests.
Belcher 16 Origins and 15 tests
Garry Jack played 17 Origins and 22 tests
I watched Simms as a kid… great goalkicker but not much more to offer above average.

Jack, Renouf, Stacy Jones.

Jimmy Jack because obvious reason (bias)
Renouf because he was the best in his position for most of his career, even with Mal there
Jones because he is a massive part of NZ rugby league for over a decade.

@Geo is fuming , another HOF nomination humiliation

Belcher and Lindner for me

Especially Lindner absolute machine at SOO and Test Football

Jack, Buderus/Jones, Lindner/Wiki

@Russell Cowie for sure! But Fitzgibbon? Lol, lovely guy I will admit.

@happy_tiger said in This year's Hall of Fame nominees:

Belcher and Lindner for me

Especially Lindner absolute machine at SOO and Test Football

Yep, Lindner absolute great player.

Renouf, Wiki and Simms

@DieHarder said in This year's Hall of Fame nominees:

@Russell Cowie for sure! But Fitzgibbon? Lol, lovely guy I will admit.

Obviously didn’t watch his playing career. That’s cool!

They are my picks - you can make your own without him. That’s cool too!

Not sure they are putting 5 players in - are they?

@Russell the slash clearly shows either/or, I.e, one of Buderus or Jones and one of Lindner or wiki (same style/different playing days). I grew up very locally to Craig, not sure what you’re on about with this one as I’m usually the one backing you up !🤣🤣

@Russell Yes. I made my choices on the players that I saw play. Includes ‘Gibbon

Recent Topics

Support our community by clicking here and joining our Forum Support Scheme