Your Team v Manly Scum

1.Thompson
2.Noffa
3.Marsters
4.Talau
5.Momo
6.Marshall
7.Brooks
8.Twal
9.Liddle
10.Clark
11.Lawrence
12.MCK
13.Matterson ©

14.Mikaele
15.Reynolds
16.Taylor
17.McQueen

last edited by Tiger_Fan18

Bring in Liddle and Talau… maybe mcqueen…

Also can u change the Title to Manly Scum 🙂

Great opportunity for Liddle now… For me I think Liddle starts at 9 and he have Reynolds at 14 to cover if needed and also bring a spark of energy that we need.
3 reason for using Reynolds -

  1. If fit he would be a good cover if injuries come up and if Liddle starts to struggle with fitness.
  2. We are trying to offload him and what better way then to put him on the TV and show that he still has the game and hopefully a team likes what they see.
  3. You know he will give his all as he is desperate to play first grade again.

I would also rest Mbye regardless as we cannot take any risks on a do or die game.

Not sure why anyone would be naming Mbye…

  1. Thompson

  2. Nofoaluma

  3. Marsters

  4. Talau

  5. Momo

  6. Marshall

  7. Brooks

  8. Twal

  9. Liddle

  10. Clark

  11. Lawrence

  12. MCK

  13. Matterson

  14. Aloiai

  15. Mikaele

  16. McQueen

  17. Reynolds

@willow said in Your Team v Manly:

Not sure why anyone would be naming Mbye…

  1. Thompson

  2. Nofoaluma

  3. Marsters

  4. Talau

  5. Momo

  6. Marshall

  7. Brooks

  8. Twal

  9. Liddle

  10. Clark

  11. Lawrence

  12. MCK

  13. Matterson

  14. Aloiai

  15. Mikaele

  16. McQueen

  17. Reynolds

now this, is a team i can see smashing manly by 60

@willow said in Your Team v Manly:

Not sure why anyone would be naming Mbye…

  1. Thompson

  2. Nofoaluma

  3. Marsters

  4. Talau

  5. Momo

  6. Marshall

  7. Brooks

  8. Twal

  9. Liddle

  10. Clark

  11. Lawrence

  12. MCK

  13. Matterson

  14. Aloiai

  15. Mikaele

  16. McQueen

  17. Reynolds

I think it was Tyga who said Madge is reluctant to play grub atm incase he gets injured and can’t find another club. I don’t think he’ll play again this year. I think ET will be the back up to Liddle.

@GNR4LIFE said in Your Team v Manly:

I think it was Tyga who said Madge is reluctant to play grub atm incase he gets injured and can’t find another club. I don’t think he’ll play again this year. I think ET will be the back up to Liddle.

Reynolds played yesterday in Reggies…Of course I guess the chance of injury is less playing reserve grade than NRL…

@Geo said in Your Team v Manly:

@GNR4LIFE said in Your Team v Manly:

I think it was Tyga who said Madge is reluctant to play grub atm incase he gets injured and can’t find another club. I don’t think he’ll play again this year. I think ET will be the back up to Liddle.

Reynolds played yesterday in Reggies…Of course I guess the chance of injury is less playing reserve grade than NRL…

I doubt he sees FG again.

1 Thompson
2 Momo
3 Talau
4 Marsters
5 Nofoaluma
6 Marshall
7 Brooks
8 Clark
9 Liddle
10 Packer
11 Garner\Lawrence
12 Matterson
13 Eisenhuth

14 Twal
15 Mikaele
16 MCK
17 Reynolds

Tough to pick a team this week as we don’t have great depth in any position. Matterson is our best 2nd rower and our best lock. Aloiai has a hand injury, we don’t have a 3rd backup hooker and Garner may get suspended in the judiciary lottery.

@GNR4LIFE said in Your Team v Manly:

@Geo said in Your Team v Manly:

@GNR4LIFE said in Your Team v Manly:

I think it was Tyga who said Madge is reluctant to play grub atm incase he gets injured and can’t find another club. I don’t think he’ll play again this year. I think ET will be the back up to Liddle.

Reynolds played yesterday in Reggies…Of course I guess the chance of injury is less playing reserve grade than NRL…

I doubt he sees FG again.

So you get less injured playing reserve grade…?

@Geo said in Your Team v Manly:

@GNR4LIFE said in Your Team v Manly:

@Geo said in Your Team v Manly:

@GNR4LIFE said in Your Team v Manly:

I think it was Tyga who said Madge is reluctant to play grub atm incase he gets injured and can’t find another club. I don’t think he’ll play again this year. I think ET will be the back up to Liddle.

Reynolds played yesterday in Reggies…Of course I guess the chance of injury is less playing reserve grade than NRL…

I doubt he sees FG again.

So you get less injured playing reserve grade…?

I’m not a sports scientist.

@Tiger_Fan18
Mbye couldn’t possibly be considered for the Manly game after his bad decision to play after injury in the warm up cost us dearly against Bulldogs and was futher compounded by Robbies injury and why Liddle was not included on the bench by Madge considering he’s No.1 pick for hooker next year he should be getting as much exposure as possible is a complete boo boo.

Garner is pleading not guilty and will front the judiciary Tuesday night

For the people saying liddle should have played you are just wrong tbh. He needs to be playing 80 mins a game as we dont have a second opition next year. Robbie has done 80 mins on his year for years its only a freak accident that does him in. Having 4 forwards on the bench has been effective

@WT2K said in Your Team v Manly:

Garner is pleading not guilty and will front the judiciary Tuesday night

“So what club do you play for?”
“Ah, WestsTigers your honour.”
“Guilty as charged. Next case!”

Recent Topics

Support our community by clicking here and joining our Forum Support Scheme

Can’t log in or access your account?
Send an email to contact@weststigersforum.com and we’ll get you back online.