End of season player ratings

1 the worst score and 10 the highest.
*This list is not categorized in a particular order.

  1. Benji - 9
    2.Brooks - 8
  2. Marsters - 6
  3. garner -7
  4. nofoaluma - 9
    6.Jennings - 5
    7.Twal -7
    8.farah - 8
  5. Mbye - 7
    10.Momirovski - 8
    11.Matterson - 9
  6. Eisenhuth - 7
  7. Taylor - 6
    14.Reynolds - 6
  8. Mikaele - 7
  9. aloiai - 7
  10. Chee-kam - 7
    18.clark -6
    19.Thompson - 8
  11. fonua - 6
    21.Talau - 6
  12. Matulino -6
    23.Lawrence - 7
  13. McQueen - 6
  14. Liddle - 7
  15. packer - 5

Not sure how matto could be anything other than a 10. That bloke should be the next captain.

@UP-THA-TIGERS said in End of season player ratings:

1 the worst score and 10 the highest.
*This list is not categorized in a particular order.

  1. Benji - 9
    2.Brooks - 8
  2. Marsters - 6
  3. garner -7
  4. nofoaluma - 9
    6.Jennings - 5
    7.Twal -7
    8.farah - 8
  5. Mbye - 7
    10.Momirovski - 8
    11.Matterson - 9
  6. Eisenhuth - 7
  7. Taylor - 6
    14.Reynolds - 6
  8. Mikaele - 7
  9. aloiai - 7
  10. Chee-kam - 7
    18.clark -6
    19.Thompson - 8
  11. fonua - 6
    21.Talau - 6
  12. Matulino -6
    23.Lawrence - 7
  13. McQueen - 6
  14. Liddle - 7
  15. packer - 5

There’s some very generous summations there

Marsters - 6… should’ve been (-6)

So everybody gets a pass mark - more than generous I’d say.

Masters 3.5
Jennings 2 (thats for putting on the jersey)
McQueen 4
Thompson 9
Farah 7
Twal 8
Matterson 10
Brooks 10
Garner 8
Eisenhuth 6
Taylor 7

The rest about the same.

alright let’s set a scale:
10= steve smith like
0= didn’t take the field

@UP-THA-TIGERS very generous marking there. Are you basing this on the skill level of Tigers players or against players in the rest of the comp? Nofo gets a 9? Wow!

G’day @UP-THA-TIGERS: I’d like to take this opportunity to wish you, and all our Forumers “A Very Happy CHRISTMAS” 🎄 🤶 🎄 🤶🎄 🤶🎄 🤶 🎄 🤶 🎄 .

my points.
8.9—Benji Marshall—the world’s most exciting player ever and still an attacking weapon.
8.5—Luke Brooks—I wouldn’t trade him for any other no. 7. Guts and determination personified.
8.4—Matterson—deserves to be Wests Tigers next captain.
7.9—Thompson—100% effort every game.
7.8—Garner— a star in the making.
7.3—Twal, Taylor, Aloiai, Mikaele and Mbye.
7.2—Farah.
7.1—Lawrence.
7.0—Momorovski—my most improved.
6.9—Eisenhuth.
6.7—Clark—will probably be an 8.0 be next year.
6.5—Reynolds— I hope he stays with us and injury-free.
6.4—Liddle—A good replacement for Farah if he stays injury-free.
6.0—Nofoaluma and Chee-kam.
5.0— Marsters.
4.0—Jennings.

This post is deleted!

8 Benji, Brooks & Matterson.
7 Thompson, Garner, Aloiai, Mikaele & Nofo
6 Twal, Taylor, Momorovski, Eisenhuth, Farah, Lawrence, Chee-kam, Mbye & Clark.
5 Liddle, Marsters, McQueen, Matulino & Fonua
4 Reynolds & Jennings
3 Packer & Talau

last edited by Earl

@Earl jeez bit harsh on Talau, he’s had more linebreaks than Jennings and he’s only played one game. I wouldn’t include him in these ratings on the one game he played.

@Madge said in End of season player ratings:

@Earl jeez bit harsh on Talau, he’s had more linebreaks than Jennings and he’s only played one game. I wouldn’t include him in these ratings on the one game he played.

He played one game. I don’t see how you rate him any higher.

10 Matterson
8 Benji, Brooks
7 Thompson, Garner, Aloiai, Mikaele
6 Twal, Taylor, nofo, Farah, Lawrence, Momirovski
5 MCK, Eisenhuth, Clark
4 Mbye, Fonua, Matulino, Liddle, Reynolds
3 McQueen
2 Marsters
1 Packer, Jennings

@WT2K said in End of season player ratings:

10 Matterson
8 Benji, Brooks
7 Thompson, Garner, Aloiai, Mikaele
6 Twal, Taylor, nofo, Farah, Lawrence, Momirovski
5 MCK, Eisenhuth, Clark
4 Mbye, Fonua, Matulino, Liddle, Reynolds
3 McQueen
2 Marsters
1 Packer, Jennings

Bit harsh on Marsters there, the rest seems about right.