Tigers Ratings

Thompson - 3 - Alot of mistakes, lots of effort
Nofo - 10 - Best game in years. Amazing in attack + defence.
Joey L - 6 - Did nothing wrong (finding his feet).
Doueihi - 8 - He is a footballer. Some touches of class.
Jennings - 6 - Should have scored twice probably. Made a try saver. Needs to run harder.
Benji - 10 - Perfect.
Reynolds - 5 - In my opinion hes off the pace and doesnt look NRL standard anymore.
Twal - 9 - Best game hes had in two years.
Walters - 6 - Did some good things, lost the ball twice. I still have some questions.
Aloiai - 6 - Tried hard, don’t think hes a prop.
Garner - 7 - Solid
Lucy - 8 - Outstanding
ET - 8 - Outstanding

Mikaele - 9 - Best game for club
Musgrove - 9 - Great debut, welcome to the club.
Lawrence - 6 - Nothing wrong but no impact…can not be played at lock though.
MCK - 6 - Nothing wrong. Don’t think hes a lock though.

The Good

  • Doueihi, Lucy and Musgrove add another dimension. JL will too.
  • Mikaele, Twal and Musgrove is the best prop rotation weve had in a long time.

To improve on

  • Thompson is not a fullback.
  • Reynolds is off the pace.
  • Chee Kam and Lawrence aren’t really.a lock option off the bench. Aloiai may be better served there if we can find another prop.

I thought Aloiai was great and Musgrove wasn’t involved enough. I’d swap their scores.

last edited by Earl

Agree with most, but thought Aloiai was great.

last edited by ElleryHanley

Aloiai ran for 187m (most by either team), made 19 tackles with no misses and made no errors.

What should he have done to be more Prop-like?

Musgrove only played 26min, I hope he is not injured.

👍

@Sart0ri said in Tigers Ratings:

Musgrove only played 26min, I hope he is not injured.

Probably just because it is his first game back, will get more game time as the season progresses.

🤞

@Sart0ri said in Tigers Ratings:

Aloiai ran for 187m (most by either team), made 19 tackles with no misses and made no errors.

What should he have done to be more Prop-like?

I retract it. Good stats.

@ElleryHanley said in Tigers Ratings:

Agree with most, but thought Aloiai was great.

Absolutely. No way was Aloiai was a 6, he was one of our best.

@Sart0ri said in Tigers Ratings:

Aloiai ran for 187m (most by either team), made 19 tackles with no misses and made no errors.

What should he have done to be more Prop-like?

Yeah thought he was good …but less mobile than in the past

Thought the pack was huge.am worried about garner with no brooks combo and a different side of the ruck

@Sart0ri said in Tigers Ratings:

Musgrove only played 26min, I hope he is not injured.

@Sart0ri said in Tigers Ratings:

Musgrove only played 26min, I hope he is not injured.

Hasn’t played for almost two years - how much gas do you think he had?

For a pack that “experts” claimed was the worst in the NRL, they outgunned Graham Frizzel Vaughan and Sims. Good effort if you ask me. When we got in Dragons 20 I felt that was where we lacked a 9 with a crisp pass. Hoping the Grant deal materializes, I think it will give us another dimension.

👍

@McQueen_Magic said in Tigers Ratings:

Thompson - 4
Nofo -9
Joey L - 6
Doueihi - 6
Jennings - 1
Benji - 10
Reynolds - 6
Twal - 10
Walters - 7
Aloiai - 9
Garner - 5
Lucy - 7
ET - 9

Mikaele - 9
Musgrove - 7
Lawrence - 6
MCK - 6

amazing what a full preseason with no injuries does to a player. well done Nofo. chase that blue jumper son.

👍

@tiga4eva said in Tigers Ratings:

For a pack that “experts” claimed was the worst in the NRL, they outgunned Graham Frizzel Vaughan and Sims. Good effort if you ask me. When we got in Dragons 20 I felt that was where we lacked a 9 with a crisp pass. Hoping the Grant deal materializes, I think it will give us another dimension.

Agree. The other reason is on our sweep play was not effectie as Thompsons not the guy to hit. Hopefully if Doueihi ends up there he gives us another option there.

👍

Recent Topics

Support our community by clicking here and joining our Forum Support Scheme

Can’t log in or access your account?
Go to https://weststigersforum.com/reset to reset your password, otherwise send an email to contact@weststigersforum.com and we’ll get you back online.