Simple - Mbye isn’t worthy of bring WTs captain. He just isn’t up to it.

Not so simple - Who should be our captain??

For me it’s either Aloiai or Twal. Why? They both appear to be leaders and will bleed for this team. With Aloiai playing prop and being rotated, I think it has to be Twal.

If he was a regular it is easily Marshall but otherwise give it to Brooks. It’ll force him to take control.

The moment when Cummings said to him to control grub…it’s like he didn’t think he could do the job. Same went for BJ last week too. Need someone who has a set. There’s no standout really!

If he was a regular it is easily Marshall but otherwise give it to Brooks. It’ll force him to take control.

@rihannafan1 said in We need a new captain:

If he was a regular it is easily Marshall but otherwise give it to Brooks. It’ll force him to take control.

Brooks is not captain material.

Mmbye is not that bad a captain we dont have anyone else except Marahall.
It is a tough balance as some on here bagged out Robbie for his passion

@Jedi_Tiger said in We need a new captain:

Mmbye is not that bad a captain we dont have anyone else except Marahall.
It is a tough balance as some on here bagged out Robbie for his passion

Not only a new captain…nearly 1/2 a new squad roster…

that us true True Tiger half a new squad might be a start

We need a new 1-17, captain is the very least of the Tigers worries.

Changing who has the C next to their name literally won’t change anything. Everyone will still talk just as much as they do now. More important things to worry about

@avocadoontoast said in We need a new captain:

@rihannafan1 said in We need a new captain:

If he was a regular it is easily Marshall but otherwise give it to Brooks. It’ll force him to take control.

Brooks is not captain material.

I hear you on that completely but figure it could be the vote of confidence he needs.

@rihannafan1 said in We need a new captain:

@avocadoontoast said in We need a new captain:

@rihannafan1 said in We need a new captain:

If he was a regular it is easily Marshall but otherwise give it to Brooks. It’ll force him to take control.

Brooks is not captain material.

I hear you on that completely but figure it could be the vote of confidence he needs.

I agree with Geo, I’d give it to Doueihi.

Of the current players available to play, I’d give captaincy to Reynolds, but his hanging the leg out on Graham puts him in the naughty corner. If it wasn’t for that incident, he communicates with the refs quite a bit.
So, I’d then pick Aloiai. I reckon he’s got it in him to be a leader for the future. I’d say Grant, but we don’t know what his future is after this year.

We have not 1 serious contender for captain imo

That’s why Cleary went for 6 or whatever number it was …

@hobbo1 said in We need a new captain:

We have not 1 serious contender for captain imo

That’s why Cleary went for 6 or whatever number it was …

That was the Oprah selection method:

You are captain.
And you are captain.
And you are captain.
And you (sic everyone) is captain!