Side for next week vs Dogs

Suggestions?

Selections will say a lot about where we are. Youngsters mean we are looking to next year, the usual suspects means that the coaching staff are living in denial and either think we can still make the 8 this year, or desperate to protect their reputations and avoid the spoon.

but who have we got to pick, there is no young talent to pick unfortunately, if lawrence or benji get another contract for next year im out

Game of the round next week. Woopidideedoo.

Any player that is not in our future plans needs to be dropped.
I don’t care who we play as long as they’re a keeper

1 Doueihi (there is no other option)
2 Nofa
3 BJ
4 Talau
5 Hoffman/Kepaoa
6 Reynolds
7 Madden
13 McIntyre
12 Luci
11 Blore
10 Twal/Mikaele
9 Liddle/Simpkin
8 Packer

14 Twal/Mikaele
15 Aloiai
16 Lawrence
17 Walters/Brooks/Mbye

Time to stick with 12 or 13 you think are worth feeding, hooking hasn’t worked.

Bring in Reynolds, Liddle if he’s up to it.
Mbye- bye
Rest of the spine, who cares?
Most of the pigs I’d keep. Seriously, you going to bother dropping people to bring in Garner and McQueen?
I’d definitely keep the 3 quarter line, don’t like seeing young blokes dropped when experienced players are marshmallows.
Didn’t watch the second half but doubt it would change my opinion.

last edited by old_man_tiger

@Hangonaminute said in Side for next week vs Dogs:

Any player that is not in our future plans needs to be dropped.
I don’t care who we play as long as they’re a keeper

Forfeit then you suggest

Worth a try …might confuse the Dogs

Season is truly done and dusted now so id be trying a few new things

Having a crack

  1. Mbye
  2. Nofo
  3. Leilua
  4. Talua (with better spikes please)
  5. AJ/Doueihi (no better option)
  6. Reynolds
  7. Marshall (happy to swap but got no other alternatives)
  8. Aloiai
  9. Brooks
  10. Packer
  11. Leilua
  12. Blore/McIntyre
  13. Eisenhuth
  14. Twal
  15. Blore/McIntyre
  16. Mikaele
  17. Lawrence

-Brooks, has an IQ of about 5 so can’t be anywhere near the halves. Unfortunately we have signed him long term. Id give him a crack at 9, likes to run and can pass not like we have any better options
-Winger, no idea AJ had a stinker under the highball, douehi is no better
-Marshall, who can replace him?
-mbye best option of a bad bunch at fullback, in no way is he a 9

after have a crack at that i feel sorry for madge, got nothing to work with. About 4 people pick themselves the rest is who is the least worse in that position

last edited by izotope

Look does it really matter now
1 Nofoaluma
2 Talau
3 BJL
4 Doueihi
5 Kepaoa
6 Reynolds
7 Madden
8 Twal or Eisenhuth
9 Liddle or Simpkins
10 Packer
11 Garner
12 LL c
13 McIntyre

14 Mybye
15 Aloiai
16 Blore
17 Twal or Eisenhuth

Douehi
Nofaluma
Joey
Talau
Kepaoa
Reynolds
Brooks
Twal
Blore
Luciano
Aloia
Mbye
Packer

Mikelle
Eisenhuth
McIntyre
Liddle

With Reynolds/Brooks we have played 5 games - smashed the COwboys and the Dogs, Run Raiders and Panther really close and gone down to Souths by 8. 4 of those 5 are our top 4 games of the year

Not amazing but compared to our results with Benji where he has won only 3 from 9 games beating the Dragons in R1 who at the time were the worst team in the comp and still scored 3 tries through Benji, v Sharks in Round 3 where again they were in horrible form but nearly beat us through the Benji corridor and we beat the Broncos which has been shown to be really really easy. Other then that we have seen 6 losses where Benji plays including to Titans, Warriors and flogged twice by the Knights.

  1. Doueihi

  2. Nofo

  3. Talau

  4. BJ

  5. AJ

  6. Reynolds

  7. Madden

  8. Aloiai

  9. Mbye

  10. Packer

  11. Garner

  12. LL Cool J

  13. Eisenhuth

  14. Twal

  15. McIntyre

  16. Blore

  17. Liddle

  1. Doueihi

  2. Nofoaluma

  3. J. Leilua

  4. Talau

  5. Kepaoa

  6. Reynolds

  7. Marshall (let him finish the yea)

  8. Aloiai

  9. Liddle

  10. Packer

  11. McIntyre

  12. L. Leilua

  13. Twal

  14. Mikaele

  15. Blore

  16. Garner

  17. Mbye

1 Doueihi
2 Nofa
3 Joey
4 Talau
5 Asu
6 Reynolds
7 Madden
8 Aloiai
9 Mbye
10 Packer
11 Luciano
12 Garner
13 Twal
14 Eiso
15 Mikaele
16 Blore
17 Liddle

@Harvey said in Side for next week vs Dogs:

Suggestions?

Selections will say a lot about where we are. Youngsters mean we are looking to next year, the usual suspects means that the coaching staff are living in denial and either think we can still make the 8 this year, or desperate to protect their reputations and avoid the spoon.

Can we pick 10 year olds?

Honest question

They seriously would give it a crack and cost a cent

We could save money for a future marquee player like Jordan Rankin or even bring back Bwaith

At least than we’d have a couple of decent players in our sidw

@Harvey said in Side for next week vs Dogs:

Suggestions?

Selections will say a lot about where we are. Youngsters mean we are looking to next year, the usual suspects means that the coaching staff are living in denial and either think we can still make the 8 this year, or desperate to protect their reputations and avoid the spoon.

But seriously Harvey sorry about that comment buy Madge is the right coach but will need years to fix this rabble so let’s not expect miracles or we will all end up at the asylum

Recent Topics

Support our community by clicking here and joining our Forum Support Scheme