Page 1 of 1

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 12:47 pm
by foreveratiger
PYMBLEPETE wrote:Just like in any video review of a try FT; if the replay clearly shows that the referee's decision was in error. In this case it was crystal clear on replay -doesnt matter how far it was from - that Woods was short of the line.
I disagree , from that camera angle there is no clear evidence to suggest he was short , for that reason he has got to say TRY based on the original Ref's decision on the field.

The Ref is a metre or 2 from where Woods planted that ball FFS .

I think all the Refs are to scared making there own decisions and send everything up stairs .

Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 12:49 pm
by hobbo
foreveratiger wrote:
PYMBLEPETE wrote:Just like in any video review of a try FT; if the replay clearly shows that the referee's decision was in error. In this case it was crystal clear on replay -doesnt matter how far it was from - that Woods was short of the line.
I disagree , from that camera angle there is no clear evidence to suggest he was short , for that reason he has got to say TRY based on the original Ref's decision on the field.

The Ref is a metre or 2 from where Woods planted that ball FFS .

I think all the Refs are to scared making there own decisions and send everything up stairs .
Woods was short !

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 12:53 pm
by foreveratiger
hobbo2803 wrote:
foreveratiger wrote:
PYMBLEPETE wrote:Just like in any video review of a try FT; if the replay clearly shows that the referee's decision was in error. In this case it was crystal clear on replay -doesnt matter how far it was from - that Woods was short of the line.
I disagree , from that camera angle there is no clear evidence to suggest he was short , for that reason he has got to say TRY based on the original Ref's decision on the field.

The Ref is a metre or 2 from where Woods planted that ball FFS .

I think all the Refs are to scared making there own decisions and send everything up stairs .
Woods was short !

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

So a Ref that's a metre or 2 from Woods has deemed it TRY , but you reckon his short :lol: .

It's all opinions in the end , just like i thought Moses should of been Sent off.

Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 12:56 pm
by hobbo
foreveratiger wrote:
hobbo2803 wrote:
foreveratiger wrote:
"PYMBLEPETE" wrote:Just like in any video review of a try FT; if the replay clearly shows that the referee's decision was in error. In this case it was crystal clear on replay -doesnt matter how far it was from - that Woods was short of the line.
I disagree , from that camera angle there is no clear evidence to suggest he was short , for that reason he has got to say TRY based on the original Ref's decision on the field.

The Ref is a metre or 2 from where Woods planted that ball FFS .

I think all the Refs are to scared making there own decisions and send everything up stairs .
Woods was short !

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

So a Ref that's a metre or 2 from Woods has deemed it TRY , but you reckon his short :lol: .

It's all opinions in the end , just like i thought Moses should of been Sent off.
I just watched it then ... Woods was short !!!
The refs don't have the confidence or the balls these days to make a clear cut decision .
Watch it again , he was short !
I remember watching it live and was disappointed in woods that he couldn't reach out and find the line !!!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 12:59 pm
by AmericanHistoryX
disappointed? I think Woods wasnt keeping anything back

Posted using RoarFEED Android 1.2.3

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:00 pm
by foreveratiger
hobbo2803 wrote:
foreveratiger wrote:
hobbo2803 wrote:
foreveratiger wrote: I disagree , from that camera angle there is no clear evidence to suggest he was short , for that reason he has got to say TRY based on the original Ref's decision on the field.

The Ref is a metre or 2 from where Woods planted that ball FFS .

I think all the Refs are to scared making there own decisions and send everything up stairs .
Woods was short !

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

So a Ref that's a metre or 2 from Woods has deemed it TRY , but you reckon his short :lol: .

It's all opinions in the end , just like i thought Moses should of been Sent off.
I just watched it then ... Woods was short !!!
The refs don't have the confidence or the balls these days to make a clear cut decision .
Watch it again , he was short !
I remember watching it live and was disappointed in woods that he couldn't reach out and find the line !!!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0
Well based on what you said ? he should of awarded a Try cause that is what he saw and originally deemed .

Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:14 pm
by hobbo
foreveratiger wrote:
hobbo2803 wrote:
foreveratiger wrote:
"hobbo2803" wrote: Woods was short !

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

So a Ref that's a metre or 2 from Woods has deemed it TRY , but you reckon his short :lol: .

It's all opinions in the end , just like i thought Moses should of been Sent off.
I just watched it then ... Woods was short !!!
The refs don't have the confidence or the balls these days to make a clear cut decision .
Watch it again , he was short !
I remember watching it live and was disappointed in woods that he couldn't reach out and find the line !!!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0
Well based on what you said ? he should of awarded a Try cause that is what he saw and originally deemed .
Once the refs decide to go up stairs it doesn't matter if he says I think it's a TRY or a NO TRY .
It's out of his hands then and the pressure is of him .
I believe they award a TRY after referring the division upstairs so they don't have players rush up and get in their faces ??

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:23 pm
by foreveratiger
Your saying ref's don't have the balls to make a decision, well he should of with the Woods Try cause he believed it was a Try.
It's sad we have to rely on a video ref to make a call when the Ref is right there on this instance.

Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:25 pm
by hobbo
foreveratiger wrote:Your saying ref's don't have the balls to make a decision, well he should of with the Woods Try cause he believed itwas a Try.
It's sad we have to rely on a video ref to make a call when the Ref is right there on this instance.
I'm not a ref mate !!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:26 pm
by foreveratiger
hobbo2803 wrote:
foreveratiger wrote:Your saying ref's don't have the balls to make a decision, well he should of with the Woods Try cause he believed itwas a Try.
It's sad we have to rely on a video ref to make a call when the Ref is right there on this instance.
I'm not a ref mate !!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0
But you claim he was short :lol:

Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:30 pm
by hobbo
foreveratiger wrote:
hobbo2803 wrote:
foreveratiger wrote:Your saying ref's don't have the balls to make a decision, well he should of with the Woods Try cause he believed itwas a Try.
It's sad we have to rely on a video ref to make a call when the Ref is right there on this instance.
I'm not a ref mate !!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0
But you claim he was short :lol:
He was short but I'm not a F.......... Ref !
God knows what goes through their heads ...
Aaaaaaaaaaahhh !!!!!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:35 pm
by happy tiger
My understanding would of been that if the ball finished on the line and Woods promoted the ball with his grounded arm /elbow it should of been a double movement

If the ref calls TRY the video ref must disprove it was a try , the ball must never have reached the line according to the video ref

Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:37 pm
by hobbo
happy tiger wrote:My understanding would of been that if the ball finished on the line and Woods promoted the ball with his grounded arm /elbow it should of been a double movement

If the ref calls TRY the video ref must disprove it was a try , the ball must never have reached the line according to the video ref
Thank you !!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:42 pm
by foreveratiger
happy tiger wrote:My understanding would of been that if the ball finished on the line and Woods promoted the ball with his grounded arm /elbow it should of been a double movement

If the ref calls TRY the video ref must disprove it was a try , the ball must never have reached the line according to the video ref
It wasn't a double movement cause we had to play the ball and Titans didn't get a penalty.

In my opinion from that camera angle there is insufficient evidence to over rule the original ref's decision that it was a TRY . I mean the Ref is a couple metres away and his opinion is it's a Try.

What he should of said to the video Ref , I deemed it a Try please check for Double movement.

I was at the game so i have no idea what he was asking to check ? obviously it appears he wanted to check if he was short .

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:44 pm
by formerguest
hobbo2803 wrote:He was short but I'm not a F.......... Ref !
God knows what goes through their heads ...
Aaaaaaaaaaahhh !!!!!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0
Blind Freddy could see he was short, ref, well, who knows :wtf he was thinking.

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:44 pm
by foreveratiger
But the Video Ref has made the field Ref look like a fool.

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:50 pm
by happy tiger
foreveratiger wrote:
happy tiger wrote:My understanding would of been that if the ball finished on the line and Woods promoted the ball with his grounded arm /elbow it should of been a double movement

If the ref calls TRY the video ref must disprove it was a try , the ball must never have reached the line according to the video ref
It wasn't a double movement cause we had to play the ball and Titans didn't get a penalty.

In my opinion from that camera angle there is insufficient evidence to over rule the original ref's decision that it was a TRY . I mean the Ref is a couple metres away and his opinion is it's a Try.

What he should of said to the video Ref , I deemed it a Try please check for Double movement.

I was at the game so i have no idea what he was asking to check ? obviously it appears he wanted to check if he was short .
Just admit it , you were too busy taking happy honeymoon shots with UD to be watching the game or listening to the video ref live commentary :lol:

Re: Live Game Thread #GCTWST

Posted: Sun 15 Mar, 2015 1:51 pm
by happy tiger
formerguest wrote:
hobbo2803 wrote:He was short but I'm not a F.......... Ref !
God knows what goes through their heads ...
Aaaaaaaaaaahhh !!!!!

Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0
Blind Freddy could see he was short, ref, well, who knows :wtf he was thinking.
He was worried about his paycheck and doing his job I guess