Page 1 of 1

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 2:31 pm
by smeghead
Um according to Hollywood Harrigan the Lote call was a strip every day of the week as he "deliberatley attacked the ball"

Did not answer my question about the non penalty for 2 player strip right in front of Souths sticks

Crocker copped a grade 1 charge and is free to play

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 4:12 pm
by 1/4 chicken,chips
happy tiger wrote:Watched game over
The Gareth 40/20 very tight Reckon they should of got checked by Video referee 5 minute mark

Penalty to Souths for hold down Tigers in tackle going backwards no dominant call WHY Souths penalty stopped counting at least 15 worse in next 30 minutes

7th minute strip Soths penalty Wasn't bad ball control

7th Minute Offside Benji complained no one called offside ( That is strange ,usually hear them screaming in mic)

13th minute Fulton not square Souths should of got penalty

19th minute Ellis applies obvious chin strap Souths should have got penalty

25th missed forward pass crossed thrown one side of line caught on other turnover to Tigers

34th minute Really slow play the ball (Non dominate ) Tigers should of got

45th minute Strip very dodgy Souths get penalty and score CRITICAL


57 minute Luke not square Wests should of got

58th minute Play the ball Rhino really 50/50 call

59th minute strip Yes refs we can strip to try and prevent try Bloody hell 1 metre out

66 minute Strip by Tigers Souths should of got

71 minute Meaney's 40-20 very tight

72 minute Rhino strip 50/50 penalty call CRITICAL

74 minute strip dropped cold

52 minutess (missed ) Moltzen in touch penalty
Missed 50/50 calls Tigers 13 Souths 5

Still think we got the rub of the green Hayne made 9 of the 13 calls

I know it is fish n chips now but we were the better side and bad refereeing cost us
Golly Gosh!
are you still on the ref beat us story .
We led a side we totally outplayed for 75 minutes by two converted tries and we let them roll over the top of us .I cant recall the ref missing any of the tackles that led to Souths tries.We are a dumb football team that has no idea how to close a game down . 12 friggin points up with 5 on the clock and we blew it . It was no different to last years warriors final when we didnt have the brains to close that game down.
At least we competed for 75 , thats the only plus i can take out of it .
We are giving away stupid penalties because we struggle to win the ruck ,its as simple as that .

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 5:26 pm
by happy tiger
1/4 Chicken and chips If you got the stuffing out of your eyes you would see I called both sides impartially for infringements

And you say 12 point lead with 5 on the clock If the referees get the Rhino call right we lead by 14 with 5 on the clock and we win

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 5:33 pm
by innsaneink
happy tiger wrote:Watched game over
The Gareth 40/20 very tight Reckon they should of got checked by Video referee 5 minute mark

Penalty to Souths for hold down Tigers in tackle going backwards no dominant call WHY Souths penalty stopped counting at least 15 worse in next 30 minutes

7th minute strip Soths penalty Wasn't bad ball control

7th Minute Offside Benji complained no one called offside ( That is strange ,usually hear them screaming in mic)

13th minute Fulton not square Souths should of got penalty

19th minute Ellis applies obvious chin strap Souths should have got penalty

25th missed forward pass crossed thrown one side of line caught on other turnover to Tigers

34th minute Really slow play the ball (Non dominate ) Tigers should of got

45th minute Strip very dodgy Souths get penalty and score CRITICAL


57 minute Luke not square Wests should of got

58th minute Play the ball Rhino really 50/50 call

59th minute strip Yes refs we can strip to try and prevent try Bloody hell 1 metre out

66 minute Strip by Tigers Souths should of got

71 minute Meaney's 40-20 very tight

72 minute Rhino strip 50/50 penalty call CRITICAL

74 minute strip dropped cold

52 minutess (missed ) Moltzen in touch penalty
Missed 50/50 calls Tigers 13 Souths 5

Still think we got the rub of the green Hayne made 9 of the 13 calls

I know it is fish n chips now but we were the better side and bad refereeing cost us
Good sides got over bad refs, you know this in your heart...were were better for 70 mins, souths played their worst footy of the year yet still beat us....says not much for us

Thats embarrassing going thru the tape looking for the ''poor us'' decisions

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 5:43 pm
by happy tiger
Ink agree Said it a few times before good sides should beat bad referees

I wouldn't normally do this Ink , but after listening to game on radio originally and here the booing of the sides with the calls Hearing David Morrow compalining about the bad calls throughout . Watching the game the first time and just scratching my head with disbelief about some calls I thought maybe breaking it down Don't mean to embarass you Ink , usually it just the wife ,kids and myself who are embarassed

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 6:04 pm
by innsaneink
You didnt embarass me......i think you know who you emarassed.
All those you listed combined wouldnt be worse than the shocker the ref ruled against the sharks in GP rd 1....karma.

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 6:09 pm
by happy tiger
innsaneink wrote:You didnt embarass me......i think you know who you emarassed.
All those you listed combined wouldnt be worse than the shocker the ref ruled against the sharks in GP rd 1....karma.
I just admitted that Ink And should you be worried bout tht Probably not I;m big enough and ugly enough to look after myself

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 9:39 pm
by Marshall_magic
innsaneink wrote:Good sides got over bad refs, you know this in your heart...were were better for 70 mins, souths played their worst footy of the year yet still beat us....says not much for us

Thats embarrassing going thru the tape looking for the ''poor us'' decisions
Well said, in every game of rugby league ever played the refs would have gotten calls wrong. A good side shakes it off and keeps going, a bad side uses it as an excuse. You have 2 choices, 1. Put up with the odd poor decisions and realise that less than 5% of games are decided by a referee or 2. Get every decision correct and revert to a game roughly the speed of gridiron.

Re: In this thread we complain about the refs

Posted: Mon 02 Apr, 2012 10:42 pm
by Tigerdave
Funny how when we win with a ref decision, that's all anyone talks about, we were lucky, ref won us it...the Sharks game comes to mind, but when we lose by a ref decision, then we shouldn't be mentioning the ref at all.