Judiciary and Game Officials

[Halbrowne61]

Carrigan 4 weeks, Hastings 4 months( or more).
Hardly seems fair does it.”, for our player and club.

 

[JRDee]

What a joke

 

[Spartan117]

Absolutely embarrassing.

But that's to be expected.

No faith in the NRL.

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

Light …. Very light

Gruesome ending to a tackle that was just uncalled for.

The game needs to start slapping players with double digit bans for dangerous tackles like this to get absolutely rid of them.

Even Corey Parker said he should've copped 8 weeks.

 

[tigerap]

Carrigan 4 weeks, Hastings 4 months( or more).
Hardly seems fair does it.”, for our player and club.

Fair is a 4 letter word in the NRL....

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Back just in time for finals

 

[Jimmy]

Please let’s be real its fair, as unfortunate the injury is there was no malice by patty, was it a poor tackle yes but players don’t get punished on the injury it’s about the tackle, the punishment fits the crime, if it were the other way around we’d agree.

 

[Merlot]

and top teams had their ?best rested on dodgy,against the rules of the game last week in suss tackles??Cooper Cronk is a Gronk

 

[Halbrowne61]

Please let’s be real its fair, as unfortunate the injury is there was no malice by patty, was it a poor tackle yes but players don’t get punished on the injury it’s about the tackle, the punishment fits the crime, if it were the other way around we’d agree.

Disagree entirely. He could have eased out of that situation but went on with it. WT playmaker caught in an awkward position, I think he made a meal of it and was thinking at least 5-6 weeks.
But only my opinion, however, you are referring to him like a relative( patty).

 

[Merlot]

last weeks Dearden eye gauge- never happened-BOO.

 

[Halbrowne61]

last weeks Dearden eye gauge- never happened-BOO.

“Patty” and Dearden, sounding like this is a QLD thing.
“Patty” pleaded guilty but got off light, imo.

 

[Merlot]

“Patty” and Dearden, sounding like this is a QLD thing.
“Patty” pleaded guilty but got off light, imo.

hope they win the lot

 

[Tiger Woods]

Carrigun dodged a bullet 🤣

 

[jadtiger]

Carrigun dodged a bullet 🤣

Different rules for different clubs,compare what Hastings was suspended this year for compared to what this suspension is.The NRL is governed by favouritism

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I can be a bit cynical by making the observation with the finals approaching, the NRL need eye candy to attract female clientele.

 

[TheDaBoss]

Had a geez at the Donkry forum

Shit they r smug

Saying that 4 weeks is fair and some were even saying that 2 weeks should of been the fine

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Please let’s be real its fair, as unfortunate the injury is there was no malice by patty, was it a poor tackle yes but players don’t get punished on the injury it’s about the tackle, the punishment fits the crime, if it were the other way around we’d agree.

It depends on your own perspective I guess.

I think the NRL need to send a clear msg that this tackle needs to be wiped out. Just like clearys spear tackle. It’s not about the injury, not about who did it, about making the game safer.

Is 4 games enough? Probably. It’s a big chunk of time.

BUT It would be interesting in both carrigans and clearys example how much time they would have got if finals were say 2 weeks away.

 

[trentrunciman]

Anyone notice the ref wasn’t going to blow a penalty until there was protest?

Lmfao 🤣