He is 26 and hasn't cracked it yet, how would he make our side better?
We already have AJ, TT, AD, Gildart, JTJ, Toa who can play center and would be comparative.
Be a waste of cash & not how we should fill our last roster spot.
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
He is 26 and hasn't cracked it yet, how would he make our side better?
We already have AJ, TT, AD, Gildart, JTJ, Toa who can play center and would be comparative.
Be a waste of cash & not how we should fill our last roster spot.
tony soprano
Well-known member
Wouldn't write him off just yet maybe needs a proper shot.
You blokes don't make sense. Sit there being critical of him but happy to have blokes like junior tupou and William Kei in top 30.
LOL I wouldn't have Kei in my top 30 squad, think it's a wasted spot.
Tupou is about the future, the kid can still play Flegg, has speed/agility and is already bigger than any of our other backs. He is a longer term focus player. Have no issues but he isn't NRL ready.
You want us to get better but prefer a fringe 1st grader who won't actually make us better and has played for the Storm but yet doesn't have anyone knocking on his door. If we added Seve it shows we are wanting the spoon for a few years.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Both those guys are 19 and 21 respectively. Still have time to develop into being better players than Seve turned out to be. You’re dying on the hill of a 26 year old whose only played 20 games.
tony soprano
Well-known member
So if they're developing why they in the 30?
tony soprano
Well-known member
Thanks for your expert opinion. 👍
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Im not arguing semantics with you. If Seve is so good, why hasn’t he seen more first grade?
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
George Jennings and Reimis Smith, 2 bog average first graders before they got to Melbourne have improved their game and cemented spots in that team.
BAGNF05
Well-known member
Deadset should be the Wests Average Joe’s
balmain boy
Well-known member
He's a player that took 4 years after leaving us to crack first grade. That's not a loss. He was a long way from first grade when he signed with us as a junior.
Such a shame, we got all the stars from that keebra side yet none of them kicked in to be first graders
hammertime
Well-known member
Steve? Why don't we get rankin back while we're at it. Kept addo carr out of the side.
tig_prmz
Well-known member
Tedesco, Moses etc.. they all wanted to leave. JAC hurts because he wanted to stay but we were too unorganised to keep him. Was JAC the one where the CEO was on a holiday and his contract was in his drawer but never signed? Or was that Beau Ryan?
T
Tiger5150
Guest
Its actually a pretty short list
Teddy,
Koro
JAC
Ryan Hoffman
cant think of many others that were Juniors or debuted here and really kicked on to be stars. Who have I missed?
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Papenhuzen
T
Tiger5150
Guest
Agreed,
so 4.5 (Hoffman never really was coming here_
5 ish if you add M Moses. Its a pretty short list. Not sure why it has become a meme?
I guess some count people who aren't juniours.
Such as JAC , Taupua, maybe even Austin.
At least we got / had Elijah Taylor.
He was great for us.
Odessa
Well-known member
Jeff Lima
But if the entire account of his once were warriors rendition in a Sydney pub is true no thanks
tony soprano
Well-known member
Yeah was the same time TMM, Lamar, cherrington, Heleta not many played too much nrl.
I'd like seve to have a proper go done well to hang around thereabouts at the Storm squad.
tig_prmz
Well-known member
I had big hopes on BMM. Tbh, I feel if he was in a Storm or Roosters type system, he may have cracked 150+ games by now.
Also Jake Mullaney, thought he would be our Billy Slater before Tedesco.
Also Jake Mullaney, thought he would be our Billy Slater before Tedesco.
Coastie_Tiger
Well-known member
FFS i was think about who Anthony Mundines grand father was
