TEAM LIST Wests Tigers Team v NZ Warriors

[Jedi_Tiger]

Hopefully Jock has a big game

funny would be hoping first thing fans would say is hopefully Brooks has a big game
I guess when you are hated you are hated hey

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

is there a chance McGuire could do something dumb like play Peachey at 6?

I think Peachey will end up at 6 and simpkin stays on bench and they bring in mikaele

 

[BAGNF05]

There is something seriously wrong with the judiciary when Collins tackle on hastings only cops a fine and his tackle against Newcastle gets him 3 weeks. Doesn’t anybody else in the NRL see that???

It’s not a rort if everyone is in on it

 

[BAGNF05]

I think Peachey will end up at 6 and simpkin stays on bench and they bring in mikaele

Same

 

[sparci]

funny would be hoping first thing fans would say is hopefully Brooks has a big game
I guess when you are hated you are hated hey

been hoping that for several years buddy, as recent as last game, where you been? seriously what a stupid comment.

 

[jirskyr]

I think he’ll be several rungs below those two players. Kurt Mann seems to be more his equivalent

Kurt Mann can tackle though.

 

[Demps]

funny would be hoping first thing fans would say is hopefully Brooks has a big game
I guess when you are hated you are hated hey

Already know what to expect from him and expectations are low.

 

[bigsiro]

No. Madden will probably be selected and he has 3 more matches to show he's capable of FG. Otherwise Hastings comes back in and we won't see Madden in FG again barring injury.

It might be the reality, but IMO he'd have to be completely awful for three games in a row to justify being dropped.

 

[TrueTiger]

I hope that if Jock gets the start,he plays as well as he did in the Roosters trial....
the thing I cant get past is how well him and Jacko combined...yet Brooks cant get it right...not bagging Brooks he maybe trying to do to much at the one time,but Hastings outshone him against Newy...Jock could be the thing that sparks Brooks up....

 

[Saturnalia]

funny would be hoping first thing fans would say is hopefully Brooks has a big game
I guess when you are hated you are hated hey

A big game for Brooks is a below average game for every other half in the comp. If you replaced Brooks with Tamou, our attack would look exactly the same.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

A big game for Brooks is a below average game for every other half in the comp. If you replaced Brooks with Tamou, our attack would look exactly the same.

Kyle Flanagan, Ash Taylor, Townsend, Hunt? You think they are much better?

 

[Needaname]

Might as well post it here as it’s somewhat related to this match.

Warriors set for emotional homecoming after more than two years amid NZ Covid changes

Warriors set for emotional homecoming after more than two years amid NZ Covid changes

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Kyle Flanagan, Ash Taylor, Townsend, Hunt? You think they are much better?

Agree with you.

FYI if anyone says Taylor has upside - it hasn't been seen for ages. Last week for the Warriors against the Titans he made 14 tackles, missed 11, ran for 14mtrs, gave 2 penalties away and threw an intercept whilst only making 49mtrs with his kicks. Explains why he got dropped from the Warriors this week.

 

[Needaname]

Agree with you.

FYI if anyone says Taylor has upside - it hasn't been seen for ages. Last week for the Warriors against the Titans he made 14 tackles, missed 11, ran for 14mtrs, gave 2 penalties away and threw an intercept whilst only making 49mtrs with his kicks. Explains why he got dropped from the Warriors this week.

Injured supposedly.

 

[Saturnalia]

Kyle Flanagan, Ash Taylor, Townsend, Hunt? You think they are much better?

I don't.

I think they're all in the same category. "Shouldn't be playing NRL".

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I don't.

I think they're all in the same category. "Shouldn't be playing NRL".

I just named a quarter of the halfbacks in the comp. There are a lot of average halfbacks out there. And no, not defending Brooks, not even saying criticism is unwarranted, BUT I do believe the people that are most vocal about him live inside a bubble and don’t really pay attention to these others. The halfback stocks are as shallow as a baby pool

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

Is Ash Barty about to replace Brooks at halfback?

 

[Cobarcats]

Surely that’s a joke?

I think he meant The Great Northern Hotel, not Saloon 🤣

 

[TieDye]

Kyle Flanagan, Ash Taylor, Townsend, Hunt? You think they are much better?

Tbf, I didn’t think Clifford was much chop!

 

[Cobarcats]

A big game for Brooks is a below average game for every other half in the comp. If you replaced Brooks with Tamou, our attack would look exactly the same.

Good grief, really?
All the top teams have better rosters, we've got more holes in our side than a block of swiss cheese.
Tamou at ½ back would make for good entertaiment I must admit