3, 2, 1 vs Titans (Round 4)

[Demps]

Incredibly safe and they killed him with the high ball.

Did a couple of exciting runs too.

To come back from the disappointment of last week like this was good to see. Could have easily gone into his shell after that.

Disagree.

Looks shook out there.
Saw him get tackled on one occasionally one.

Quick to pass the ball and avoid contact.
The opposite of Papenhyauzan.

Fail for mine.

 

[Merlot]

Disagree.

Looks shook out there.
Saw him get tackled on one occasionally one.

Quick to pass the ball and avoid contact.
The opposite of Papenhyauzan.

Fail for mine.

he played with out his demons,unsure if he's a FB.he showed heart 2day

 

[Fade.To.Black]

3. Roberts
2. Luciano
1. Laurie

 

[Cobarcats]

3 Ofahengaue
2 Leilua
1 Madden

Save repeating, what he said is close to the mark

 

[balmain boy]

Joffa 3
Roberts 2
Madden 1

 

[balmain boy]

3 Brooks
2 Joffa
1 JTJ

Surely you could see that was one of brook's worst games for us, ever. He literally cost us the game

 

[clontarfkid]

Laurie ?

He's a passenger out there.
Scared little boy.

Laurie was uninvolved...MIA when theres a half break,which is part of the attack problem
Caught hj ball well and tackled well one on one...but theres no other dimension to his game
Hes not an NRL no1 IMO,never will be becuase of size/disinterest and lack of comittment,and lack of vision .....and we need to plan now for his replacement
Starting with Standford ma at 1 next week and Laurie in 6 to identify if he has anything to offer there

 

[clontarfkid]

I don‘t think he‘s even reserve grade standard.

His final execution under pressure is abysmal..panicks.But that trainable

 

[Merlot]

Laurie was uninvolved...MIA when theres a half break,which is part of the attack problem
Caught hj ball well and tackled well one on one...but theres no other dimension to his game
Hes not an NRL no1 IMO,never will be becuase of size/disinterest and lack of comittment,and lack of vision .....and we need to plan now for his replacement
Starting with Standford ma at 1 next week and Laurie in 6 to identify if he has anything to offer there

keep it simple 1 2 3

 

[clontarfkid]

3 Lucy 126m half were post contact, always looked damaging.
2 Twal, 139m in 64 minutes, 34 tackles none missed, 2 tackle breaks.
1 Offa 139m in 66 minutes 30 tackles

Hard to argue with those stas..and it was the backs who let us down

 

[clontarfkid]

keep it simple 1 2 3

see next post

 

[Merlot]

half a team stood up

 

[Goldust]

3. Roberts .Looked dangerous every time he got the ball,defensively was strong also.
2. Madden .Starting to play with some confidence,we may be onto a winner here.
1. Luciano .Massive loss for us next season.provides lots of energy with each carry,it’s a shame no one supports him.

 

[Cobarcats]

I don‘t think he‘s even reserve grade standard.

Rubbish, he's a quality footballer.
What qualifies you to make such a comment.
He has made mistakes trying to get to the line for sure but “not good enough for reserve grade" your talking out of your butt again Gunner.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Rubbish, he's a quality footballer.
What qualifies you to make such a comment.
He has made mistakes trying to get to the line for sure but “not good enough for reserve grade" your talking out of your butt again Gunner.

Hear that everyone. If you don’t rate Gildart, you are clearly talking out of your butt. This man knows ^^^

 

[loklok]

The only thing that keeps brooks in the side is his defence .

 

[Demps]

Hear that everyone. If you don’t rate Gildart, you are clearly talking out of your butt. This man knows ^^^

You said Brooks and Nofo are your favourite players.

I think your opinion is invalid at this point.

😂

 

[innsaneink]

Laurie ?

He's a passenger out there.
Scared little boy.

Wrong.
He showed some ticker... He went ok

 

[GNR4LIFE]

You said Brooks and Nofo are your favourite players.

I think your opinion is invalid at this point.

😂

I’ve never said no such thing. If I did though, still better calls than pumping Cherrington and Steve’s tyres 😉

 

[Demps]

Wrong.
He showed some ticker... He went ok

Not from what I saw...

I did see him:

- Pass the ball almost every time to avoid contact.
- Catch a bomb then immediately submit to avoid being tackled.
- Make 1 run into the opposition defence.
- Avoid all collision possible other than that one run.
- Be out of position multiple times especially on that final kick that set the boys up to fail.

I feel like some times people don't pay attention to individual performances close enough.

He wasn't as bad as last week but this was still no way an acceptable effort.