Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tony soprano]

But Maguire achieved something many of us never experienced:
- he managed to transform the team with a solid defence (under Cleary), to arguably the worst NRL defence team, in only three (3) years!
- he secured the spoon for us! 🤬

Plus a shocking Mockumentary

 

[Dennisspicer1]

If you get Brooks contract for 750k less the long service player discount on 170k is about 580k on the cap. That is good value.

But, Would you want him in the team at any cost.

why would you not want to pay over a million a season for him.

Because he doesn't perform well. ( DAH )

So why would you want him in our team at any price if he doesn't play well.
??????

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

But, Would you want him in the team at any cost.

why would you not want to pay over a million a season for him.

Because he doesn't perform well. ( DAH )

So why would you want him in our team at any price if he doesn't play well.
??????

He does play well
woukd happily lose Douhie and keep Brooks and Hastings

 

[Elderslie_Tiger]

SEN just reported Madden to Broncos

 

[Tito Santana]

I’m over Papalii. The guy seems like a knob. I don’t want him. Why would we want a guy that doesn’t want to be here? [This word has been automatically removed] him.

 

[Camel2281]

He’s not behind Junior Paulo and RCG here. Throw in Matto, Lane, Niukore etc. there’s no guarantees he even makes a difference behind our mattresses.

Despite that. Moses was a better player while here than Brooks at the time. We placated the wrong bloke. Moses should have been the 7 and main man here instead of Luke. Time has proven that

 

[Stevec]

Plus a shocking Mockumentary

Couldn't agree more the airing the dirty laundry was a failed attempt at self promotion and further muddied our image I heard a lot of non tiger supporters calling it " fails from Tiger town "

 

[Camel2281]

Why? He’s not worth more than that.

He is when you consider we're paying Brooks $1mill next year

 

[ConePuncher]

the dominos have begun to fall. madden to broncos. expect some movement on the WTs front shortly.

 

[Halbrowne61]

SEN just reported Madden to Broncos

Did they also mention Garner to Penrith and Tuilagi to Manly ?

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Yes.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Yes, I always had a high opinion of him. I'm not sure of the circumstances surrounding him signing with Souths. Tatola was another.

 

[tony soprano]

Couldn't agree more the airing the dirty laundry was a failed attempt at self promotion and further muddied our image I heard a lot of non tiger supporters calling it " fails from Tiger town "

Ricky Gervais might as well directed it.

 

[WT2K]

Yes, Another one let go 👽

 

[balmain boy]

I’m over Papalii. The guy seems like a knob. I don’t want him. Why would we want a guy that doesn’t want to be here? [This word has been automatically removed] him.

What a pathetic loser attitude that is.

Are you on the Wests Ashfield board by any chance?

 

[tony soprano]

Yes, I always had a high opinion of him. I'm not sure of the circumstances surrounding him signing with Souths. Tatola was another.

Tatola, arguably the best prop in the NRL.

Souths did some good poaching.

 

[Camel2281]

He couldn't be a replacement for Madden. Madden is a halfback. An organising player. How good he is may be up for question but Asi is a utlilty back, but most definitely not a halfback. He's mostly a fullback/centre and a bit of 5/8 too.

If Brooks is going to be our 7 we need an understudy who is an organiser, someone who can kick us out of trouble. Asi could be a backup for Doueihi/Laurie

I agree with you. I don't mind Asi for depth but he's not the 7 depth cover. I'd be going hard for Dean Hawkins for that role