Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Glenji95 said:
Which one? Moses returning or AD 6?
Click to expand...

What I'd prefer is for AD to turn into a great player and not to sign Moses. AD plays some awesome footy at times and I like him but you got to be rational. He didn't perform last season. Admittedly it was coming back from an ACL injury but he hasn't performed well enough at fullback or in the halves last season and he is on good dollars. I don't think he has been any better in the centres. His defense is terrible at times.

I don't like Moses. He was so talented when he was here but he just had no respect at all for the club. Moses is miles ahead of Doueihi in relation to performances on the park.

I'm not getting excited about either signing.
 
Earl said:
What I'd prefer is for AD to turn into a great player and not to sign Moses. AD plays some awesome footy at times and I like him but you got to be rational. He didn't perform last season. Admittedly it was coming back from an ACL injury but he hasn't performed well enough at fullback or in the halves last season and he is on good dollars. I don't think he has been any better in the centres. His defense is terrible at times.

I don't like Moses. He was so talented when he was here but he just had no respect at all for the club. Moses is miles ahead of Doueihi in relation to performances on the park.

I'm not getting excited about either signing.
Click to expand...
Well if we have lost Hastings and if Brooks is heading to Newcastle than re-signing AD is more than likely on the agenda unless the club feels confident in signing Dylan Brown to play at 6. AD can play great footy he was one of our best in 21 until his ACL injury and this season unfortunately was shit all round for everyone. Hoping in 23 he bounces back but he does have stuff to work on no argument there. But unless we can sign better we would be dumb to let him go. If we have lost all 3 well our halves are much weaker going into 24.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
weststigers said:
Have no idea if there is bad blood with Hastings or not. Just a general comment…

Looking at it another way, we all have the right to choose who we work with…it just might not be our current employer.

Co-workers that can’t work with each other just creates a toxic environment. From a managers point of view, the pros far outweigh the cons of removing the source of the problem regardless of talent. Everyone is replaceable.
Click to expand...
"Everyone is replaceable" - not in elite sport that is not true. Good/ great players are not easily replaceable and the very reason why we are in the position we are in.
 
Glenji95 said:
Well if we have lost Hastings and if Brooks is heading to Newcastle than re-signing AD is more than likely on the agenda unless the club feels confident in signing Dylan Brown to play at 6
Click to expand...

There is no way the club should feel confident of signing any top player and that is what Brown would be paid as. Let's wait and see what happens with Hastings. I think Brooks is going to Newcastle but there hasn't been anything official so who knows.

If Doueihi can get his game together he could be a weapon but this is already starting to sound a little like supporting Brooks.
 
Earl said:
There is no way the club should feel confident of signing any top player and that is what Brown would be paid as. Let's wait and see what happens with Hastings. I think Brooks is going to Newcastle but there hasn't been anything official so who knows.

If Doueihi can get his game together he could be a weapon but this is already starting to sound a little like supporting Brooks.
Click to expand...
I agree on waiting and seeing Hastings may not be leaving but still we also can’t wait around either. Sooner or later a decision has to be made.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
This will be the 3rd which has failed to do it, so we're not alone.
Click to expand...
Never said we were alone. But considering we hold the title of the club who has had the longest spell of not playing finals footy - we are clearly not finding the replacements we need
to effectively compete, although we have lost plenty who have played finals at other clubs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Telltails said:
Never said we were alone. But considering we hold the title of the club who has had the longest spell of not playing finals footy - we are clearly not finding the replacements we need
to effectively compete, although we have lost plenty who have played finals at other clubs.
Click to expand...
We seem to be doing well with recruitment now, perhaps our best year including three participants in the grand final.
 
Telltails said:
Two real good players but they come from strong squads we need to be realistic about how much difference they can make to our team. We have a long way to go before we can compete with the best imo - but always hoping for the best.
Click to expand...
Robinson, Hasler and Sheens are all premiership winning coaches. You've given Sheens a serve but perhaps these coaches know what it takes to assemble and nurture a squad capable of contesting for the premiership.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Robinson, Hasler and Sheens are all premiership winning coaches. You've given Sheens a serve but perhaps these coaches know what it takes to assemble and nurture a squad capable of contesting for the premiership.
Click to expand...
I'd say every premiership coach knows what players are the type they need to win a premiership but if they havnt got access to them when other clubs do, then they are on a hiding to nothing - despite any success they may have had previously.
The success of any club relies on a lot more than just an ex premiership winning coach no matter who it is.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 541 (members: 24, guests: 517)
Back
Top