LIVE GAME 2023 Trial 1: Wests Tigers v Warriors

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cobarcats
  • Start date Start date
Live Game Discussion
Can’t get too worried about this trial. You never know what their training load was leading in to this.

Never fun to concede 50 points though
 
Best compliment for Stef and Pole has been the difference through the middle with them on/off the field. The only players really in contention for round 1 apart from them would be Kepaoa, Simpkin and Staines.

Stefano
1 try
1 line break
127m from 11 runs
24 tackles
3 tackle breaks

Great to have the big man back injury free

šŸ’ÆšŸ”„
 
Bula is a real prospect.. great positioning and shame we didnt have possession 2nd half, love the way he sniffs around the ruck. Has that change of pace too.

Also has a good athletic frame for the position. Will likely fill out a bit as he ages.
 
Would have liked to see Feledy and Hill actually get some ball. Bula probably the one, along with these two, who I want to see dominate NSW Cup at some point this year.

Junior Tupou is a guy I'd like to see get an extended run in FG. Neither Nofo or Ken are going to improve much from this point and he can't be far behind them.

Scolari and Ngatakaura disappointing.
 
Not affecting the outcome, but she is shite.
What was the call .. you put the ball on the ground to play the ball .. the tacklers foot then kicks the ball as our played the ball .. but no she called knock you placed the ball on the ground to play the ball .. heh excuse me but isn’t that how you are supposed to play the ball .. crikey .. some weird calls there tonight .. that ref was not up to NRL standards .. !! Actually not even on top of the general rules .. !!
 
pathway system seems all systems go 🤠
There were quite a few young players out there that looked like NRL players but need experience. Faagutu and Feledy in particular did well considering their experience. Bula had an outstanding game when he came on. Tumeth played most of the game and looks to be ready for the NRL. Reilly played well at 5/8 considering what many wrote about him last year. Matamua looks an NRL player as well but it wasn't his night with the passing.
 
Really shouldn't be looking too much into this trial. Yes, defensive structures were a worry but we won't be getting much insight into this until at least the next trial when more of the FGers are given a go. For now, should just be happy that the players relatively close to the first grade side (e.g. Utoikamanu, Pole, etc) looked great.
 
Totally outclassed across the park; although some of our forwards can hold their heads up. We didn't do ourselves any favours with the the ball turnover but the intent was there. Just not too many of our passes stuck. Overall it was our errors and our right side defence really let us down.

What really concerned me is our lack of depth at 6, 7 and 9. Although Reilly showed some starch in defence.

What I saw of our fringe 13 wasn't too bad - showed their intent even though the execution was clumsy.

I'm not concerned about the result. It is pre-season and most of the kids out there will go back to junior rep footy to learn their trade. I think is was good for them to get a taste of what FG is about.

Hopefully they can go back and focus on what they need to develop in their games to get to FG standard.

Bring on the next game,
 
That result has zero bearing on our
season or 1st's team. Who cares.
wasn't long ago we pasted Manly
in pre season and finished bottom
four while they finished top 4 four
That is not true. These guys may not have the experience and skill of some who weren’t there, but this is a look into our depth. Additionally, it’s an indication of exactly how little we have worked on defensive structures.
That was a weakened Warriors outfit and they easily ran 9 tries in.
 
thats a shit comment mate go cut your own wrists @Cobarcats @Demps obviously haven't lost someine . What a [This word has been automatically removed]

wrist slitter is not appropriate @Cobarcats

I absolutely apologise if that touched a nerve. It was intended purely to highlight panic over a trial, not literally. I have lost someone under those circumstances. Not sure if telling me to cut my own wrists is an appropriate reply though.
 
Let go of Seyfarth .. he plays to a different rhythm to everyone else .. gets monstered by their half back and number 9 .. gets pushed back every time he runs the back up .. out the back blind passes to no one .. actually not no one .. he passed it to them .. never liked him .. and it ain’t gonna change .. time to let go of the human pillow in Seyfarth ..
Seyfarth plays like a poor man’s Kyle Lovett
 
Back
Top