Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[BlackWhiteGold]

Who? I think we have enough lottery tickets for the future…we need experience and at least proven NRL capable players for the backline

I do agree with you, an experienced outside back is what we need.

Just putting it out there re. Tartak/Crown given the Thompson links. I know that Kalo Kalo was highly regarded but must be injured/fallen off the radar.

 

[BZN]

He is always injured and terribly overpaid,i would not want him even on a train and trial contract.

Luv your emojis Jt, as they add a bit of colour to an otherwise boring and repetitive Rumours thread that 99% of the time lead to zilch.

He is always injured and terribly overpaid,i would not want him even on a train and trial contract.

 

[tiger_scott]

I'm not sure that whether they did the wrong or right thing is the issue. I think many people would be wondering about the club's inability to be decisive on such matters?
I wonder if the issue is a result of the committee decision making process. We've all heard the story "whose job is it anyway" about a committee of 4 people named everybody, somebody, anybody and nobody..

In 2019 we finished 9th.
2020 11th.
2021 13th.
2022 16th.
2023 looking like 17th.
2024 ? we're hoping there isnt an 18th team, because it could be us!
We can't blame this slide on Maguire for the next 10 years.

Some part of our future success (which hopefully commences in 2024) can be attributed to Maguire getting our salary cap back in order. He had a shocking team/s to work with. He could/should have done better with the cattle he had, but should also be thanked for leaving the cap in a better state than when he found it.

It looks like all the teams down the bottom are struggling to get to the top again. Even the Dogs, with their "astute" accounting practices, are finding it hard to climb the ladder to relevance.

 

[member850]

Some part of our future success (which hopefully commences in 2024) can be attributed to Maguire getting our salary cap back in order. He had a shocking team/s to work with. He could/should have done better with the cattle he had, but should also be thanked for leaving the cap in a better state than when he found it.

It looks like all the teams down the bottom are struggling to get to the top again. Even the Dogs, with their "astute" accounting practices, are finding it hard to climb the ladder to relevance.

Don’t worry the dogs have only just started, they will buy their way off the bottom

 

[balmain boy]

It means that we are being manipulated by Tartak who is taking advantage of a club who can't recruit and is using that to get deals for his clients that other clubs want off their books.

He can ask the question, and we can tell him no. It's not in the best interests of the club, nor the players he has at the club to waste a precious top 30 spot on an injury prone forward when we have so many other positions that need addressing.

 

[weststigerman]

I'm not sure that whether they did the wrong or right thing is the issue. I think many people would be wondering about the club's inability to be decisive on such matters?
I wonder if the issue is a result of the committee decision making process. We've all heard the story "whose job is it anyway" about a committee of 4 people named everybody, somebody, anybody and nobody..

In 2019 we finished 9th.
2020 11th.
2021 13th.
2022 16th.
2023 looking like 17th.
2024 ? we're hoping there isnt an 18th team, because it could be us!
We can't blame this slide on Maguire for the next 10 years.

Maguire was never the reason we were going backwards. He was made the scapegoat for that and since he was sacked we have gone from gradually going backwards to anchored on the bottom of the table.

He was sacked largely because of our poor start with 3 wins from 12 in 2022. The facts are since then we have won 4 out of 32 games. I'm not sure there has ever been a team with a lower win % over 32 games.

 

[SeanT]

Maguire was never the reason we were going backwards. He was made the scapegoat for that and since he was sacked we have gone from gradually going backwards to anchored on the bottom of the table.

He was sacked largely because of our poor start with 3 wins from 12 in 2022. The facts are since then we have won 4 out of 32 games. I'm not sure there has ever been a team with a lower win % over 32 games.

Maguire did some good things but he did have some issues. His bench rotation wasn't Greta and he wanted to play a forward dominant game plan when we didn't have the forwards. He needed to plan to the team he had and not what he wanted.

 

[LeichhardtTiger]

Sorry hit wrong button , question why would u return to a club that sacked u and won two titles in a row . And Nic has said he will return to the club in some way if not as a player . So how much did the roooters pay him to leav

A pallet of PAL?

 

[weststigerman]

Maguire did some good things but he did have some issues. His bench rotation wasn't Greta and he wanted to play a forward dominant game plan when we didn't have the forwards. He needed to plan to the team he had and not what he wanted.

Ironically, this year we have the forwards to do that, but the management panicked, just like they did when signing Fulton without telling Benji/Sheens.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

I'm not sure that whether they did the wrong or right thing is the issue. I think many people would be wondering about the club's inability to be decisive on such matters?
I wonder if the issue is a result of the committee decision making process. We've all heard the story "whose job is it anyway" about a committee of 4 people named everybody, somebody, anybody and nobody..

In 2019 we finished 9th.
2020 11th.
2021 13th.
2022 16th.
2023 looking like 17th.
2024 ? we're hoping there isnt an 18th team, because it could be us!
We can't blame this slide on Maguire for the next 10 years.

Yes but as we all know the key metric to success is how many hats Pascoe sold between 2019 & 2023. I bet we're in the top 4 hat merchandisers.

 

[tony soprano]

Maguire did some good things but he did have some issues. His bench rotation wasn't Greta and he wanted to play a forward dominant game plan when we didn't have the forwards. He needed to plan to the team he had and not what he wanted.

What were the good things?

Ultimately, madge didn't have player buy in, could not identify juniors for the life of him and couldn't recruit good players. Receipe for disaster.

He annoys me too with his mates always pushing him in the media.

 

[teddy23]

Justin Olam is being shopped around - I'd definitely be making a call.

Melbourne trying to clear some cap space for Haas....

 

[Halbrowne61]

View attachment 6175

Already toured the CoE.

Pascoe telling him where North is !
Assume that is Mrs Sullivan on the left and his manager in the middle ?

 

[Halbrowne61]

View attachment 6174

Hope they give his hamstrings a real good check, we don’t want another Brooks situation.

 

[boonboon]

Hope they give his hamstrings a real good check, we don’t want another Brooks situation.

Brooks situation ? Brooks for all his faults has hardly missed a game in 12 yrs. Missed a few this yr but every player does eventually

 

[Roar_Power]

Justin Olam is being shopped around - I'd definitely be making a call.

Melbourne trying to clear some cap space for Haas....

Be stupid not to invest in this bloke. Hard as nails.

 

[Tom Shines]

Hard to see them moving him on
- Unless he's busted and they're not telling anyone...
Or fallen out with one of the golden boys.

There was a media rumour last week Storm aren’t happy with his form…he might be the one to make way when Pap is back.

Edit - I see he is already playing Reggie’s..

 

[Fainu Brothers]

Justin Olam is being shopped around - I'd definitely be making a call.

Melbourne trying to clear some cap space for Haas....

Not at full freight

 

[Fallen Angel]

Just read a quote stating Haas is very close to SBW, and SBW could have a major influence on whether Haas stays loyal to the Broncos. Pretty much seals the Broncs fate, given SBW‘s history of loyalty.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Brooks situation ? Brooks for all his faults has hardly missed a game in 12 yrs. Missed a few this yr but every player does eventually

Settle down, just meant he’d been troubled by hamstring injuries over past few years. Not having a shot at him, ok.