Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

king_sirro said:
You haven't seen much of the Tigers and Magpies over the years if you think he is one of the worst. He would have walked into the starting lineup of many Balmain, Magpies and Wests Tigers teams over the years.
Click to expand...
Are you kidding? That blind?

He can barely make the 17 for the worst side we've ever had. Thus far in his career he has proven that he is currently not an NRL standard player. He has some potential but he hasn't improved whatsoever since his debut, and after years off fluffing around it's time for someone else to get a shot. If he had been toiling away in SNW Cup for the past 4 years then yeah maybe i'd think he deserves a shot in the nrl if he was dominating at cup level.

If he plays more than a couple of first grade games for us next season we're totally screwed.
 
Telltails said:
Not sure our club can rebuild without the FG team showing some form of growth and expect that you will retain the best, or attract players from other stronger clubs.
WTs Is the only club to my knowledge who tries to sell what might happen in three years time.
Even the Dolphins in their maiden year performed better than us and in doing so have recruited some very handy players to strengthen their team.
Gould has recruited players that strengthen the depth at the club with players who were blocked from playing FG in strong teams. To me that is smart recruiting and with Crichton as the cherry on the top. From where I sit they are looking far more likely at this stage than us.
Click to expand...
Other than the Panthers. In completely unrelated news, which team do you think has accomplished the most successful rebuild in the past couple of decades?
 
earl said:
It's not even this simple. Who is better - Pauga or Kepaoa ? I reckon Kepaoa by miles. Pauga gets a starting job for the rorters. Remember how highly rated Momo was. The guy was ordinary. He isn't a first grader. For some reason people still mention him on here as a signing target.

I'm not sold on Kepaoa but I'd state he is a borderline first grader who can play much more first grade over his career than guys like Momo or Pauga.
Click to expand...
Momo is no star, but he's still 2-3 times the player that Kepaoa is currently. I can't believe any would even question that.
 
WestsEffTheRest said:
Fulton was the one who told Blore he's free to leave which is why Melbourne reached out in the first place, he believes Blore is blocking Samuela Fainu's path & suggested Schuster as an upgrade to Blore.
Click to expand...

Do you know this for sure ? Surely Benji and the coaching staff were involved in telling Blore to leave if true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
balmain boy said:
Momo is no star, but he's still 2-3 times the player that Kepaoa is currently. I can't believe any would even question that.
Click to expand...

I would definitely question it. Momo is the more well rounded or technical footy player but Kepaoa is the better athlete. That matters a lot in today's game. I'd prefer Kepaoa in our squad compared to Momo. Momo isn't a first grader. Kepaoa is a borderline first grader.
 
jrtiger said:
it's hard to get a read mate. I don't think they have any players on anything above $850k. there's definitely money to play with and roster spots to fill but who they prioritise and chase is the question.
Click to expand...
I would estimate they have at least 5 players on 800k+ which is HUGE!

Burton (1mil), Crichton, Mahoney, Kikau, RFM. With JAC on 700k too. All of their signings would be on at least 300k too.

We in comparison have no one on 800k+....
 
balmain boy said:
Are you kidding? That blind?

He can barely make the 17 for the worst side we've ever had. Thus far in his career he has proven that he is currently not an NRL standard player. He has some potential but he hasn't improved whatsoever since his debut, and after years off fluffing around it's time for someone else to get a shot. If he had been toiling away in SNW Cup for the past 4 years then yeah maybe i'd think he deserves a shot in the nrl if he was dominating at cup level.

If he plays more than a couple of first grade games for us next season we're totally screwed.
Click to expand...

Are you kidding? I don't want to start naming past players, but I could name 3 full backlines of players that are much worse. Short memories
 
2041 said:
Other than the Panthers. In completely unrelated news, which team do you think has accomplished the most successful rebuild in the past couple of decades?
Click to expand...
I think the nature of the game has changed significantly to what it was a decade ago. Loyalty pretty much non existent. Young players very aware of the benefits of being associated with strong clubs rather than playing for their "junior" club. And for us as far as reputation goes - career wise - we have developed a rod for our own back that has had far reaching implications when competing for players against opposition clubs. The continued failure of our FG team has damaged the WTs brand let alone the performance of the admin to rectify it.
The Bulldogs as poor as they have been in recent times still manage to attract quality.
I think we have run out of steam when trying to sell a rebuild - why would any manager/ player buy it?
I hope Benji unearths something with the current crop and on top of that can jag Luai, cause too many off seasons of late have only produced false hope.
 
How about looking at Isaiah Tass from South Sydney for our centres .. ?? He could be forced out of the Rabbitohs backline now that they have to fit Jack Wighton inot their side. He goes alright and wouldn't be as expensive as some of the others we have been associated with in the papers by the so called League experts .. !!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 859 (members: 7, guests: 852)
Back
Top