SMH Article 'We’ve lost faith in them’: Balmain consider shock exit from Wests Tigers merger

If anything, this Muppet has probably solidified support & united fans who previously followed Balmain & Western Suburbs. This show of solidarity is heartening & certainly light years away from what was being posted the first few years of the Joint Venture.

Here's to a huge season next year & even better seasons in the next few years. We have seen what our young guys are capable of.

After a season under their belts in the top 30 & some good recruiting (so far at least) we should be more excited for 2025 than we have been for quite some years.
 
Tigerdazz2 said:

Behind paywall, anyone a subscriber?
Click to expand...

Article was put up yesterday dazz in different thread

Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Anyone got the Benny Elias article from Bulldog Ritchie NRL 2024: Wests Tigers CEO Shane Richardson and captain Api Koroisau hold peace meeting with club critic Ben Elias NRL Hall of Famer Ben Elias has been regularly critical of the Wests Tigers over on-field and administrative failures...
weststigersforum.com weststigersforum.com
 
Tigerdazz2 said:
If anything, this Muppet has probably solidified support & united fans who previously followed Balmain & Western Suburbs. This show of solidarity is heartening & certainly light years away from what was being posted the first few years of the Joint Venture.

Here's to a huge season next year & even better seasons in the next few years. We have seen what our young guys are capable of.

After a season under their belts in the top 30 & some good recruiting (so far at least) we should be more excited for 2025 than we have been for quite some years.
Click to expand...
Yes... 20 years ago, even only a decade ago a topic like this would degenerate very quickly into an us/them shit fight.
The division among the fan base has thankfully tapered right off to near nothing... Still a few that can't accept the JV and that's their right but to cause drama and have digs at one or the othsr on WTs pages is just sad
 
Bring it on. Please oh please make this happen. The merger hasn't worked. It has no soul. People talking about all the fans and sponsors walking away are kidding themselves. What matters is success. If the Balmain Tigers (one of the most iconic 'brands' in rugby league potentially playing out of the most iconic suburban ground in rugby league) go it alone and, god forbid, manage to make the finals more regularly than three times every 25 years, then they will have a massive (existing - both pre and post merge - and new) fanbase. Please Harry, kill this pathetic chimera and bring back the (proper) Tigers.
 
1908 said:
Bring it on. Please oh please make this happen. The merger hasn't worked. It has no soul. People talking about all the fans and sponsors walking away are kidding themselves. What matters is success. If the Balmain Tigers (one of the most iconic 'brands' in rugby league potentially playing out of the most iconic suburban ground in rugby league) go it alone and, god forbid, manage to make the finals more regularly than three times every 25 years, then they will have a massive (existing - both pre and post merge - and new) fanbase. Please Harry, kill this pathetic chimera and bring back the (proper) Tigers.
Click to expand...

I'm going to ignore this judging by your post history
 
A stand alone Tigers would have to switch to becoming a recruitment club wouldn’t they?

I think Richos view is that you need to stack a roster with multiple juniors to augment the imports.

Melbourne don’t have that luxury, but what they do have is superior recruiters and coaching staff. I don’t think Balmain have that. What is their plan to achieve that?

I think the future is in the South West but we’ve only just opened an office there.

The neglect has been almost criminal.

Both the old clubs can be proud of their history and also happy it’s been carried on. Best of both worlds.
 
1908 said:
Bring it on. Please oh please make this happen. The merger hasn't worked. It has no soul. People talking about all the fans and sponsors walking away are kidding themselves. What matters is success. If the Balmain Tigers (one of the most iconic 'brands' in rugby league potentially playing out of the most iconic suburban ground in rugby league) go it alone and, god forbid, manage to make the finals more regularly than three times every 25 years, then they will have a massive (existing - both pre and post merge - and new) fanbase. Please Harry, kill this pathetic chimera and bring back the (proper) Tigers.
Click to expand...
For sure they will make the finals more often…in NSW Cup !
I’m a Balmain diehard, but that ship sailed 20 years ago. I want a team to support in the NRL. Look at the Bears and Jets. It’s sad to see them getting out the begging bowl to be a piece of some expansion club that want nothing from them apart from a logo.
 
JoshCE23 said:
The Football Club is technically solvent, but is being funded by Wests Ashfield, with the funding guarantee ending at the end of this year. The point I'm simply making is it's clear that all parties involved want to support the proud history of Balmain into the future. They would need to find an alternative financier if they wished to split, but the Wests Tigers franchise licence would still be controlled by HBG, unless they chose to relinquish it, which I highly doubt they would. Would be great to see Balmain remain a part of that.
Click to expand...
Balmain don't want to split - but voicing their objections im the media to HBG's self-serving rejection of the review recommendations has been done to place pressure on Romero & HBG to follow-through on their commitments to an independent WT Board... or justify why they've chosen to not do so!

It's strategic PR!
 
TSP said:
A stand alone Tigers would have to switch to becoming a recruitment club wouldn’t they?

I think Richos view is that you need to stack a roster with multiple juniors to augment the imports.

Melbourne don’t have that luxury, but what they do have is superior recruiters and coaching staff. I don’t think Balmain have that. What is their plan to achieve that?

I think the future is in the South West but we’ve only just opened an office there.

The neglect has been almost criminal.

Both the old clubs can be proud of their history and also happy it’s been carried on. Best of both worlds.
Click to expand...
The last "successful" local Macarthur junior before the recent few debutants was fricking NOFA!!!

Galvin was a Parra junior - NOT Wests!

Seyfarth is a Balmain junior!

Stop making shit up to fit a popular narrative!!

The slums of Macarthur are not a quality breeding ground for elite junior talent!
 
1908 said:
Bring it on. Please oh please make this happen. The merger hasn't worked. It has no soul. People talking about all the fans and sponsors walking away are kidding themselves. What matters is success. If the Balmain Tigers (one of the most iconic 'brands' in rugby league potentially playing out of the most iconic suburban ground in rugby league) go it alone and, god forbid, manage to make the finals more regularly than three times every 25 years, then they will have a massive (existing - both pre and post merge - and new) fanbase. Please Harry, kill this pathetic chimera and bring back the (proper) Tigers.
Click to expand...
You must like the idea of watching them in the Reggie's....or them being based outside of Sydney.
 
Snidest 0 said:
The last "successful" local Macarthur junior before the recent few debutants was fricking NOFA!!!

Galvin was a Parra junior - NOT Wests!

Seyfarth is a Balmain junior!

Stop making shit up to fit a popular narrative!!

The slums of Macarthur are not a quality breeding ground for elite junior talent!
Click to expand...
Galvin was born & bred in the "slums" of Macarthur....and a bunch of those juniors from the "slums" won a comp together in the recent past. With the huge growth in the Macarthur & Wollondilly, the Western Suburbs junior catchment will be greater than that of Penrith in just a few years. If those juniors are nurtured right, Wests Tigers may have similar success to that of Penrith in recent years.
 
TSP said:
A stand alone Tigers would have to switch to becoming a recruitment club wouldn’t they?

I think Richos view is that you need to stack a roster with multiple juniors to augment the imports.

Melbourne don’t have that luxury, but what they do have is superior recruiters and coaching staff. I don’t think Balmain have that. What is their plan to achieve that?

I think the future is in the South West but we’ve only just opened an office there.

The neglect has been almost criminal.

Both the old clubs can be proud of their history and also happy it’s been carried on. Best of both worlds.
Click to expand...
I 100% agree with everything you say.
 
  • Love
Reactions: TSP
mtd#2 said:
"Balmain tigers" and "wests tigers" and "castleford tigers" and "east's tigers"... they are all clubs that use a tiger as their mascot. Balmain do not own the word "tigers".

It won't get ugly.

Balmain don't have a leg to stand on lol.
Click to expand...
Don’t think Balmain have any voting rights on the board anymore either
 
I thought Barry O’Farrell was being quiet, it now appears as though he’s been busy with the usual stuff, persuading the controlling boards to make good on their promises and do their job.
A big no no Barry.
Honestly, would any of us be surprised if O’Farrell gets sacked, then Marshall, followed by Richo?
 
  • Sad
Reactions: BZN
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 501 (members: 31, guests: 470)
Back
Top