Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Tom Shines said:
Mate …I’ve been down that rabbit hole three times already about the contract leaking …no one is ever going to know with certainty who leaked the story …

Who are the people saying they were actually the good guys ? Haven’t read that ?
Click to expand...
The club knows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Tom Shines said:
Mate …I’ve been down that rabbit hole three times already about the contract leaking …no one is ever going to know with certainty who leaked the story …

Who are the people saying they were actually the good guys ? Haven’t read that ?
Click to expand...
The inflammatory quote that got my back up was the suggestion that Richo is no better than JP.

I now realise I was just being trolled.
 
Lestronge said:
When did this whole “we’re Pascoe and Lee actually the good guys “ narrative start ? I’ve seen it 3 or 4 times in the last few days .
What the actual ….. Some people are hilarious in their constant desire to be edgy and contrarian …
Click to expand...
It’s not that contrarian to some. They were protected for years on here, especially Pascoe. Even those who started the petition which led to their demise used to defend them quite staunchly. The mob really turned on them only a couple of years ago.
 
Tom Shines said:
centers are definitely still a question mark heading into the season…leading contenders are Olam with his bung knees, and unproven Turuva …. Then we are back into the also rans of Doohey and Toa ….
Click to expand...
Agree. The hope is Olam cements his spot post-surgery. But by midyear we could potentially see a wing/centre combo of Skelton, Turuva, Makasini and May which is exciting.
 
Tiger Tarl said:
Agree. The hope is Olam cements his spot post-surgery. But by midyear we could potentially see a wing/centre combo of Skelton, Turuva, Makasini and May which is exciting.
Click to expand...

I actually still think Olam can be a contributor if he is now recovered from the knee issues …. I recall Richo recently saying he was training well or some such…hope that is correct …
 
Spacecub said:
Hey tigerdazz, you should try the chew n spew at the taree service centre, you might re-evaluate port and Goulburn
Click to expand...
I live in the area (20km N/E of Taree) I avoid the Taree Service Centre like the plague 😂.
I'd rather walk in to the old Airds Pub or go for a jog in Claymore (used to live in Bradbury) than go anywhere near the Taree Service Centre.

I don't even take the Taree exit, especially after dark. I'd rather take the Cundletown or Coopernook exits, they are closer to my joint anyways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Tom Shines said:
I actually still think Olam can be a contributor if he is now recovered from the knee issues …. I recall Richo recently saying he was training well or some such…hope that is correct …
Click to expand...
There was a couple of guys yesterday, and to be honest I misinterpreted your tone , as I thought you had jumped on that bandwagon aswell . Clearly not .
I think Richo has done a great job in this first year , at the very least the vision is 💯 clear to everyone , and transparent .
The comment about the spine , was a little bit OTT , but to be fair I’ve also seen 3 or 4 spine rankings from various media outlets since then , and all of them have the tigers spine in the top 5 , some top 3 .
So , as yes he shouldn’t have said it , it’s not a crazy thing to say really . Stupid thing to say . But not crazy !
It’s crazy when you think how far the spine has come . 2 years ago we were trotting out Guys like Wakeham ,Laurie , Hastings and a past it Smith . Chuck in everyone’s favourite Luke brooks , and it’s crazy how far we’ve come .
They just to get wins now . The team on paper really is top 8 . IMHO it’s better than the bulldogs , it’s better than the roosters , and it’s better than anyone else who didn’t make the 8. But sport isn’t won on paper , so we need to get our shit together . There’s really no excuse anymore .
And I know you’re not a Benji fan , I get it , he got the job through nepotism, But we need him to lift and be a decent first grade coach , because if he succeeds we all do .
And god it would be good to go to the SFS in week 1 and host a finals game .
 
craigtob said:
Who cares??????
Contracts mean nothing these days,players break contracts all the time.
He is with us now so it’s up to the club to preform so he doesn’t need to sign anywhere else.
Click to expand...
If contracts meant nothing, Galvin would be gone. Contracts mean a lot if clubs have backbone. There would be no circumstance where they would release Luai without a clause.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
If contracts meant nothing, Galvin would be gone. Contracts mean a lot if clubs have backbone. There would be no circumstance where they would release Luai without a clause.
Click to expand...
Not delighted ,but both contracts are fully understandable given our circumstances as 3 times wooden spooners.
Its totally up to US..and that includes those two players...to change that
Weve given ourselves every opportunity to succeed with exceptional talent..we need to do something with it
 
GNR4LIFE said:
The only time i advocate putting someone on ignore is if the person is consistently belligerent or abusive. For which there are a couple of great examples, which I’m sure people could figure out who they are. If you’re gonna put someone on ignore because you can’t handle their opinion, then that feels a little precious
Click to expand...
There's no obligation on anyone to read anything anyone posts.
 
Lestronge said:
There was a couple of guys yesterday, and to be honest I misinterpreted your tone , as I thought you had jumped on that bandwagon aswell . Clearly not .
I think Richo has done a great job in this first year , at the very least the vision is 💯 clear to everyone , and transparent .
The comment about the spine , was a little bit OTT , but to be fair I’ve also seen 3 or 4 spine rankings from various media outlets since then , and all of them have the tigers spine in the top 5 , some top 3 .
So , as yes he shouldn’t have said it , it’s not a crazy thing to say really . Stupid thing to say . But not crazy !
It’s crazy when you think how far the spine has come . 2 years ago we were trotting out Guys like Wakeham ,Laurie , Hastings and a past it Smith . Chuck in everyone’s favourite Luke brooks , and it’s crazy how far we’ve come .
They just to get wins now . The team on paper really is top 8 . IMHO it’s better than the bulldogs , it’s better than the roosters , and it’s better than anyone else who didn’t make the 8. But sport isn’t won on paper , so we need to get our shit together . There’s really no excuse anymore .
And I know you’re not a Benji fan , I get it , he got the job through nepotism, But we need him to lift and be a decent first grade coach , because if he succeeds we all do .
And god it would be good to go to the SFS in week 1 and host a finals game .
Click to expand...

I’m glad I could set you straight then about Lee and Pascoe …

In respect of Benji I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again now …. There is no bigger name from the Wests Tigers club, and no person I would enjoy more having success in the coaching role …

I just think that he was a bad choice to coach this team through this time given his lack of coaching experience …and I think the chances of him succeeding next year are not great… he really has to have success next year he is going to continue …my expectations are not massive ….10 wins
 
jirskyr said:
Wind-assisted but it looks probably he'll break 10 seconds soon enough, 17 years old in a few weeks.
Click to expand...

yeah …was wind assisted…

He is an exciting prospect…. You can see he has plenty left to improve on …his start was nothing great …. I suspect the 200m will be his main event
 
Tom Shines said:
Mate …I’ve been down that rabbit hole three times already about the contract leaking …no one is ever going to know with certainty who leaked the story …
Click to expand...
I'll repeat what Pascoe told me a few years ago - if you hear anything about contract negotiations in the media it's the player manager not the club. He said the club gains nothing from those details being aired because it only complicates roster development for the club.

And why do the agents do it? Because it lets them set a public narrative to pressure the club. There's always an obvious angle for the player manager if you read an article carefully.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 339 (members: 2, guests: 337)
Back
Top