Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

pawsandclaws1 said:
It seems he may be with us next year so the Knights are inviting us to take him now. I hope this is the case because we have top 30 spots available.
Click to expand...
Ecto-1 said:
I called that we’d sign him early to free up money for the Knights to get Dom Young.
Click to expand...
Knights do have a top 30 spot, idk why everyone thinks they don’t Barry Toohey (top Knights insider for long time) has said they do after Pryce left
 
Rock Hopper Steve said:
Still need another big cannonball prop and Seyfarth goes back to reserve grade, the rest fight for their 1st grade positions for me.
Click to expand...
Completely disagree, it would screw up our cap and roster balance.

You can't have 7-8 props in a 30 man roster with the money that they are all on. Its not fantasy football. That's why its much more important to get a second rower and lock to free up Seyfarth and Twal to play prop.

If we were to get another FG quality prop (with KPP and a lock) that means that Sione, Twal and Seyfarth would all be in reserve grade. That's too much of the cap in grade. They would probably also look to leave, which puts you back to square one and having to replace them. Not to mention it would completely block the path of guys like Kit.
 
The reality is TDS is promising but unproven ,mainly because he hasnt had the opportunity...
Api is a slowly fading superstar...but at this stage Api is still miles in front ,and altho hes had a lot of footy hes still gonna >TDS for a cple of years yet
He sees his buddy moving on at 19 to bigger and supposedly better,so thinks he can do same..but 9 is tougher.
Think we got Harry Grant at 21...
Think we will lose TDS,but not a wrist slashing loss
 
Wiz said:
Our pathways are bad. So many players who are touted as the future end up anything but, and players who do show promise we can’t keep. 😞

I can only assume they rate Haywood more highly than TDS and the timing works better for a transition from Api to Haywood.
Click to expand...
TDS is a MUCH better prospect than Haywood. Haywood is u19 this year. Tallyn was u19 only last year.

By u19, TDS had already made his first grade debut and absolutely dominated SG Ball that year (he had something like 9 tries in 10 games). He then went and played 6 games of first grade that year (last year).

Haywood had a good year in Ball but wasnt even the best player in the team. He is only now making the bench in Flegg. Hes a long way off and well behind where Tallyn was at the same age (last year).
 
Can we just relax and look what we have in the no:9 position
API for 25/26
TDS currently contracted till ?

TDS is playing longer minutes this year than last and I’m sure will get even more time next year.
He is our future and I’m sure he will be getting told this with API near the end of his career.
 
Demps said:
I hope the 17 changes for Sunday and TDS is back in.

He's been playing well off the bench and now he's dropped.

Although I feel like he didn't see much game time against the storm.
There could be something more to the story, or they might not.

Just hope Tigers come out on top.
Click to expand...
This could be a tactical move for TDS to get some long minutes in before the bye. At this stage Benji could be preparing for if Api is out due to origin. Unlikely sure but it may be a reason.
At the same time giving Api more minutes might showcase him for origin in 1 last audition.
 
I'm concerned over the immediate need to fill 2 or 3 roster spots by 30 June. I still see Olam in the clubs website and have not seen anything official on his medical retirement having happened. Our State Cup team and development players are not bashing down the door for selection and in that case should not be rewarded by filling the vacant slots. We have to recruit to get some useful depth in the last half of the season. Dunno who, but we need both forwards and backs. Next season we have some 6 players with contracts ceasing end of this season but that's another issue. I think the 30 June squad deadline and lack of usable depth players is the now issue.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Put it into context, the Storm had Munster, Drinkwater, Hughes and Papenhuyzen on the books (not sure which one), but it was resolved.
Click to expand...
Yeah,but they had Bellamy improving all their individual prospects internally and externally
Plus a great winning culture to play in
Having said that,theres a cple of Storm players who need to move on..Pezet and Faalago..are both serious 1st graders and need to move on sooner rather than later
Pathways are totally blocked
 
Needaname said:
This could be a tactical move for TDS to get some long minutes in before the bye. At this stage Benji could be preparing for if Api is out due to origin. Unlikely sure but it may be a reason.
At the same time giving Api more minutes might showcase him for origin in 1 last audition.
Click to expand...
Wouldn't playing him in KOE over the bye weekend be the better choice?
 
Demps said:
I hope the 17 changes for Sunday and TDS is back in.

He's been playing well off the bench and now he's dropped.

Although I feel like he didn't see much game time against the storm.
There could be something more to the story, or they might not.

Just hope Tigers come out on top.
Click to expand...
Could also be to give a young player 80mins prior to coming into a bye weekend.

Rather than the 10-20 mins so far this season.

Just a thought.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 611 (members: 48, guests: 563)
Back
Top