Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

We have now played 5 games where Sukkar and Seyfarth have been in the 17.
We are 0 - 5 in those games.
It just isn't possible to win an NRL game carrying 2 park standard footballers who offer nothing to the team.
Some of the efforts or lack of last night from both these passengers were so lacking of any athleticism and skill that it was hard to believe I was watching NRL.
I have said this previously but we will not win a game carrying the 2 of them.
It's a shame that the blokes who can play got us so close to a win. It must be heartbreaking for them.
Time to urgently try to get ANY NRL standard backrower before June 30.

 

[Fainu Brothers]

We have now played 5 games where Sukkar and Seyfarth have been in the 17.
We are 0 - 5 in those games.
It just isn't possible to win an NRL game carrying 2 park standard footballers who offer nothing to the team.
Some of the efforts or lack of last night from both these passengers were so lacking of any athleticism and skill that it was hard to believe I was watching NRL.
I have said this previously but we will not win a game carrying the 2 of them.
It's a shame that the blokes who can play got us so close to a win. It must be heartbreaking for them.
Time to urgently try to get ANY NRL standard backrower before June 30.

Seyfarth doesnt win any contact in Defence and adds nothing in attack. I thought Sukkar has shown real potential last 2 weeks

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Seyfarth had a great game last night and it is clear Marshall has confidence him. Sukkar is a young player on the rise.

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

Seyfarth had a great game last night and it is clear Marshall has confidence him. Sukkar is a young player on the rise.

0-6 incoming if they're in the 17 next game.

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

On the plus side, how much fun is it to watch another Michael Maguire close to tears press conference.
The bloke has a team with attacking threats across the park and he's spouting exactly the same rubbish as when he was coaching us.
To any Broncos player reading this, here's a tip, coach yourselves and just nod when Maguire talks.

 

[Fainu Brothers]

Seyfarth had a great game last night and it is clear Marshall has confidence him. Sukkar is a young player on the rise.

Watch his defence contact, never wins it. He is a massive target for opposing teams. Horrid player

 

[Lestronge]

The roosters wont work him and neither should we.

60 potential roster spots closed to his clients probably forever.

Then he will only be able to gouge out the eyes and steal the bread off the table of the rest of them.

I hope Bratfink fails miserably.

Hes an utter failure of a human being already. Its a pity hes playing in an era where we have to tolerate his presence.

It’s hard though , you have kids in your junior system like Phoenix Godinet , who you’ve had eyes on since they were 13/14 , and then they sign with your worst enemy when they’re 16/17 . You now have to deal with the grub .
Same as Bula really . He signed with Moses after we negotiated his contract.
He offers the players heaps external of on the field . It’s why they all go to Cove.
The funny thing is we just negotiated a new contract with him for Sukkar .
My guess is? He only does this shit , if the player and thier family gives him the green light .
The Galvin family are as much to blame , if not more so . Same as the bulldogs .
I honestly don’t think we miss much with him . I honestly don’t think he’s anything near the level of 1mil . I don’t see what everyone else is seeing .
I was thinking when Mason went over last night . When had the superstar torched a defence with him alone ? The only time I can remember is the eels game last year . Other than that , he’s been out through a few half holes and got an offload … cool that’s edge forward stuff .
When has he actually split the defence ? Since that 1 time ?

 

[Lestronge]

The Gold Coast is a rugby league nursery, yet so many great players who went to school there end up elsewhere.

Big time with Keebra Park , and the school that dominated schoolboy footy when I was a kid , Palm Beach Currumbin

 

[Tom Shines]

Seyfarth had a great game last night and it is clear Marshall has confidence him. .,.

What would you say were his biggest contributions last night ? His stats are nothing out of the ordinary… seven missed tackles

 

[JC99]

More and more obvious how badly we need a left centre. AD just offers nothing in attack anymore. Teams know if they rush him he doesn't have the speed or skill to evade then

 

[pawsandclaws1]

What would you say were his biggest contributions last night ? His stats are nothing out of the ordinary… seven missed tackles

Work rate and the capacity to cover for others in defence across the field. Seyfarth is valued by teammates and they want to play with him. Twal is similar. He is obviously valued by the coach.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

What would you say were his biggest contributions last night ? His stats are nothing out of the ordinary… seven missed tackles

Why is it the coach continues to select him and his teammates value him?

 

[pawsandclaws1]

More and more obvious how badly we need a left centre. AD just offers nothing in attack anymore. Teams know if they rush him he doesn't have the speed or skill to evade then

AD has developed into a very good defensive centre. Yes his running could improve and I'm sure once he regains full-confidence with his knee, we will see an improvement. I'm sure in the off-season he will work hard on his pace.

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

Why is it the coach continues to select him and his teammates value him?

1) We have no other choice.
2) you don't know that.

 

[Tom Shines]

Why is it the coach continues to select him and his teammates value him?

He has got to pick somebody … his CEO leaves him with no other options …

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

Work rate and the capacity to cover for others in defence across the field. Seyfarth is valued by teammates and they want to play with him. Twal is similar. He is obviously valued by the coach.

Please don't ever associate the reliability of Twal with the inept, chook with it's head cut off Seyfarth. The Benny Hill theme should play every time Seyfarth gets involved.

 

[Tom Shines]

AD has developed into a very good defensive centre. Yes his running could improve and I'm sure once he regains full-confidence with his knee, we will see an improvement. I'm sure in the off-season he will work hard on his pace.

Are there any “just average “ players in the team, or are they all very good?

 

[Tom Shines]

in other news , I see the Sheenius boycotted the 20 yr players reunion on Friday .. that will show the club that paid you millions Sheenius !

 

[pawsandclaws1]

1) We have no other choice.
2) you don't know that.

Seyfarth is a team man first, has a great attitude to training and competes every week. Not much to say about him because he gets the job done and his capacity for hard work is a good influence on our younger players. He is a squad player and is renumerated as such which offers the club good value under the cap. If players of more talent arrive, he may move out of the 13. I'm sure he is happy to just be in the 17. If you don't believe me, Marshall has noted these qualities when his re-signing was announced for 2 years in 23. Seyfarth admitted Marshall was his hero so you can imagine he wants to play for him.

 

[gregjm87]

Work rate and the capacity to cover for others in defence across the field. Seyfarth is valued by teammates and they want to play with him. Twal is similar. He is obviously valued by the coach.

Twal doesn't cover others in defence. He makes his tackles and his tackles only. Seyfarth does work his ass off for others, though agree with other commenters that he does so with winning any collisions.