Tallyn Da Silva #270

I know it seems simplistic but if Benji would just utilise Tallyn off the bench for 30 or so minutes each week, he would get his experience in first grade. You would think just being named in the top 17 would be enough incentive for these young guys to hang around and ply their trade, knowing that Api is not going to last forever. It’s not like he’s stuck in Koe waiting. That said, Benji needs to use him and not just leave him sitting on the pine for 80 minutes.
 
Really. Your a stats man. How are our tries conceded when TDS is on the field either as the sole Hooker or playing alongside Api, as opposed to playing just Api.
Im not going to compile that as it isnt my point.
I am not arguing that Tallyn is better currently. I never have been arguing that.
What I and others are saying is that Api doesnt have the motor for 80 and never has. For some reason this club thinks he will get better at this as he ages...its misguided and stupid.
Forget about Tallyns record in 23 and 24...he was starting out as an 18 and 19 year old. This year as a 20 year old, he has undergone 3 pre seasons as well as 3 seasons of senior footy. His value to the team has improved a lot.
He and Api have combined for 5 wins and 4 losses. It is immaterial who did the lions share of the work as they compliment each other. Api shoulders the tough start, Tallyn comes on and gets the defence second guessing, Api comes back on and closes out. Each have their purpose, each provides the other with opportunities...i.e. Tallyn gets the defence hesitating thinking he'll run, Api comes back on and gets to work the ruck with short balls to runners. Tallyn works the ruck with structured play, Api comes back on and finds room to scoot. As a pair, they make a very competitive 80 minute hooker.
The reason we need that is because neither can go 80 at this stage.
 
So other players believing there was better in Galvin position
How can that relate to bullying surely it can be just their opinion
Its not their job to approach the coach and get their mate selected ahead of the guy who is the incumbant and has prepared for 2 preseasons to play there.
 
Im not going to compile that as it isnt my point.
I am not arguing that Tallyn is better currently. I never have been arguing that.
What I and others are saying is that Api doesnt have the motor for 80 and never has. For some reason this club thinks he will get better at this as he ages...its misguided and stupid.
Forget about Tallyns record in 23 and 24...he was starting out as an 18 and 19 year old. This year as a 20 year old, he has undergone 3 pre seasons as well as 3 seasons of senior footy. His value to the team has improved a lot.
He and Api have combined for 5 wins and 4 losses. It is immaterial who did the lions share of the work as they compliment each other. Api shoulders the tough start, Tallyn comes on and gets the defence second guessing, Api comes back on and closes out. Each have their purpose, each provides the other with opportunities...i.e. Tallyn gets the defence hesitating thinking he'll run, Api comes back on and gets to work the ruck with short balls to runners. Tallyn works the ruck with structured play, Api comes back on and finds room to scoot. As a pair, they make a very competitive 80 minute hooker.
The reason we need that is because neither can go 80 at this stage.
Ok well my point is carrying both weakens our side defensively so it’s the risk you take for the impact you want to gain in attack. I believe we lose that same impact in defence.
So on that note I would be playing Api 80 or less being replaced by a utility with the capability of playing hooker and giving TDS the chance to build his motor in NSW Cup.
 
You just compared 3 different positions ? What are you even talking about ?
Who’s the better prop ? Lockyer or Fittler ….. huh ?
Read the thread ...

I said -
“I see this as yet another Tedesco moment in our club’s faltering retention history”

Others introduced talk of positional comparisons
 
Forget about Tallyns record in 23 and 24...he was starting out as an 18 and 19 year old. This year as a 20 year old, he has undergone 3 pre seasons as well as 3 seasons of senior footy. His value to the team has improved a lot.
He and Api have combined for 5 wins and 4 losses.

Why is it ok to make exceptions for TDS as a rookie player, but can't exceptions for Benji as a rookie coach? Benjis valid to the team has also improved alot..
 
.
Surely he must be staying or that wests tigers sponsored video is a sick joke. Wouldn’t surprise me though….

What’s the video?

Edit - Just saw it on the clubs Twitter site ..

WTF is up with this club ? The Social Media hacks probably aren’t even aware with his situation
 
Last edited:
Its not their job to approach the coach and get their mate selected ahead of the guy who is the incumbant and has prepared for 2 preseasons to play there.
So what are the roles and responsibilities of the senior playing group in your opinion?

In my opinion it's to work with the coaching staff to ensure they are achieving the best possible results as a team.. this involves giving feedback and opinions..

If someone in your business came up and said bob had been doing really well and you think that he deserved a shot on a project over bill, there's nothing wrong with that at all..

If they turn treated bill like a piece of sh1t then yes that's bullying.

But providing opinions/feedback is far from bullying...

Drawing a long long bow mate
 
.


What’s the video?

Edit - Just saw it on the clubs Twitter site ..

WTF is up with this club ? The Social Media hacks probably aren’t even aware with his situation
I love it..
A little reminder to TDS where his head was at not that long ago..
and that he might be emotionally reacting to a situation.
 
From all accounts he is disposable compared to young Haywood, who the club rates very highly and has apparently a lot higher ceiling. TDS going won't scare the club too much with Haywood the long term option after Api, also the club will not lose Api you can bank on that.
What makes you think the club will keep him
 
No doubt he is a very good player of potential, but so is Haywood so there is no need to be a downer on a young player's career. Haywood has the advantage of being able to play 9 as well as 6 or 7.
I’ve got nothing against Haywood.
He’s doing quite well at the moment, in the Flegg side.

I’m just trying to recall - has Da Silva ever played Flegg ?
I seem to remember he went from SG Ball
straight to NSW Cup 🤔
 
I’ve got nothing against Haywood.
He’s doing quite well at the moment, in the Flegg side.

I’m just trying to recall - has Da Silva ever played Flegg ?
I seem to remember he went from SG Ball
straight to NSW Cup 🤔
Can’t remember, though he did debut in first grade the same year he played his final SG Ball season.
 
Yes it is difficult but Anasta confirmed Da Silva doesn't want to serve an apprenticeship under Koroisau. That he is hot property strengthens our position and hopefully if he is released, we see a player(s) in return to strengthen our team. I haven't seen the Bulldogs linked to Da Silva? Is their cap full😁?
They will be linked after a deal is done. I'm sure Gus is keeping an eye on the situation.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top