$50 Million reason Wests Tigers are prepared to quit Campbelltown.

Look, we play badly there because no one in our first grade team feels connected to that place. There is no-one in our dressing room that played at that stadium as a kid. Can you imagine if we hadn't won at LO for 2 years?? It'd be a scandall!!! But for Campbelltown its like .... ahh jezz thats a shame....rrrmmm who has $100,000,000 to kill this weird vibe??? No chance....

Leichhardt draws on decades and decades of history but Campbelltown is like half the idea of half of the joint venture. Most people involved in Wests Magpies (your Dennys of this world) wish the club never moved to Ctown in the first place. You can't build your future around that unless you are located out of that area full time.

Yeah lets keep the place on Blaxland road and pay lip service to the area, but just play at Commbank instead. Our team seems to detest playing at Campbelltown.
I know you've all been pacing the lounge room waiting for me to weigh in, and I've tried to resist...really, I have tried.
But this topic dragged me back like a dodgy pass to the in-goal.

There's no denying our recent form at Campbelltown has been ordinary but results alone shouldn't dictate our identity or commitment to the area.

A footy team doesn't become part of a region by flying in once a month.
It requires roots, relationships, and representation.
That's something the Magpies embodied when they 1st aligned with C'town, and while some wished it never happened, history doesn't move backwards.

What I am now seeing is the tide turning, consensus shifting, that's moving forward.
Slowly there's recognition that C'town can't just be an occasional pitstop...it needs to be a strategic home base, complete with academy infrastructure and genuine junior development.
The area deserves more than lip service.
We can't build connection if the current squad barely knows the turf they're walking on.

If we're serious about long term success and cultural grounding, locating ourselves more fully in C'town isn't a radical idea...it's overdue.
 
So players get off scot free cos the stadium doesn’t look good?
I'm speaking as a fan going to game, nothing to do with results or players.

But im sure if fans don't enjoy it, then crowd energy will be flat, having an indirect impact on players (as opposed to a crowd right into it, lifting the team).
 
It might appeal more post upgrade
Not it might TS, it will.
I used to enjoy going to Pratten Park to watch the Magpies play from 1964 till the end of days there.
I used to enjoy going to Lidcombe when the Mighty Magpies were winning games consistently.
It was pretty ordinary to say the least.
I think the mens toilet on the hill was probably as bad as the Glen Morrison toilet at Leichhardt.
But I was fairly young and at that age you adapt to the conditions pretty quickly and grow to love the place.
WTs haven't won enough games there for most people to grow to love CSS as it is.
 
Last edited:
If we're serious about long term success and cultural grounding, locating ourselves more fully in C'town isn't a radical idea...it's overdue.
Agreed, if we can pay the bills with it, along with the necessary upgrades (or HBG is happy to subsidise).

Let's be frank, if it were the caliber and revenue generator of a Parramatta stadium, we'd be there full-time with a token game at Leichhardt. Unfortunatly it's not.

It seems Richo has been asked to make sure our finances are in the black - HBG must be unwilling to invest here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
Agreed, if we can pay the bills with it, along with the necessary upgrades (or HBG is happy to subsidise).

Let's be frank, if it were the caliber and revenue generator of a Parramatta stadium, we'd be there full-time with a token game at Leichhardt. Unfortunatly it's not.

It seems Richo has been asked to make sure our finances are in the black - HBG must be unwilling to invest here.
I guess we'll find out sooner rather than later, as Richo has given until the end of this month for the finance he has asked for to roll in.
And I reckon if the $$$ come in to Richo's liking, and a solid commitment is made for more games to be played there every year, the fans will roll in.
Gee, I might even make the 5 hour drive to go to a game there.
 
I will never understand why a club would want to remove themselves from an area where they are embraced, to another area in hope to find the same there. The thing we dont have a problem with is the fan base. Yet for some reason people are fixated about Campbelltown being the only way forward.
You don't have to play our of an area to support the juniors and develop pathways. Melbourne and the Roosters have been doing it for years
Our problems have all been to do with administration and the in ability to attract and retain talent. Start winning on the field and the juniors from all areas will want to play for you and their managers will steer them towards us instead of away.
 
you say the growth isn’t in Campbelltown …I show you it is and you still ignore it … how about you google something to prove your point ?
What ? Get out the violins you clown ! I didn’t argue with you . I was asking literally where …. As I spend a lot of time in Campbelltown and can only think around Appin - c town , where there’s development .Maybe down around ingleburn and Munro , but I don’t think that’s Campbelltown council… you’re stating “facts” but you don’t actually know the where and how ..
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
You’d think so, but apparently it’s the soil and the grandstands fault.
There’s heaps of people sports who complain about playing in half empty stadiums with no atmosphere . It matters . It gives the players a 2nd leg . Should it mean you give less and blame the ground … of course not … but is the reverse true that a pumping stadium can get the boys/ girls home . Well there obvious…
 
What ? Get out the violins you clown ! I didn’t argue with you . I was asking literally where …. As I spend a lot of time in Campbelltown and can only think around Appin - c town , where there’s development .Maybe down around ingleburn and Munro , but I don’t think that’s Campbelltown council… you’re stating “facts” but you don’t actually know the where and how ..

Mate … if you are gunna be disrespectful with juvenile name calling … then don’t bother interacting with me …

It is the Campbelltown Council own figures from their website ..: so it’s more of a “fact” than your whatever it is you are saying … but I don’t think it makes any difference to the crux of my point anyway …Ingleburm is 10 mins drive away from the stadium …Appin 20 mins …this is the local team …

Edit -minto and ingleburn are within Campbelltown council area … Appin isn’t
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: BZN
Have been to all grounds multiple times this year and the best atmosphere was at commbank during our loss to Parra. Leichhardt is dead quiet and you can feel the sense of “here comes the next error” people yelling out “why are we so shit” etc.

Bottom line, Richo needs to turn us into winners so we actually have a home ground advantage where the fans create some atmosphere. Only time the crowd got into the GC game was the field goal.
 
We agree on something at least …. And I never said you did say it …I’m arguing wih multiple people here if you didn’t realise…

Leichhardt has a superior record no doubt … unfortunately playing more than a handful of games there doesn’t appear an option
Why? HBG factor?
 
Back
Top