$50 Million reason Wests Tigers are prepared to quit Campbelltown.

Tom Shines said:
I don’t see why that period alone matters …
Click to expand...
Because we are comparing commbank. The period matters because how can you compare results at commbank from 2019 when the club was at it's worst with periods where we were winning games.

During our worst period in history, Leichhardt has a 50/50 ratio.

Commbank more than 30%.

Campbo less than 25%.

I've provided the full history since 2000 and Leichhardt still wins at 56%.

It's pretty clear across a big sample size the casm between the results of both grounds.
 
weststigers said:
Because we are comparing commbank. The period matters because how can you compare results at commbank from 2019 when the club was at it's worst with periods where we were winning games.

During our worst period in history, Leichhardt has a 50/50 ratio.

Commbank more than 30%.

Campbo less than 25%.

I've provided the full history since 2000 and Leichhardt still wins at 56%.

It's pretty clear across a big sample size the casm between the results of both grounds.
Click to expand...

It’s a small sample size where they play different teams…they get to play Parramatta every year at Comm Bank …twice!
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
Old Wests fans cannot accept the stats are bad for Campbo. They still want to hold on in case something changes. Can't accept reality. Wouldn't you just want the team to win? At 56% we make finals most years.

Even during 3 wooden spoons, we have a 50% winning ratio at Leichhardt.
 
weststigers said:
Old Wests fans cannot accept the stats are bad for Campbo. They still want to hold on in case something changes. Can't accept reality. Wouldn't you just want the team to win? At 56% we make finals most years.

Even during 3 wooden spoons, we have a 50% winning ratio at Leichhardt.
Click to expand...

I’m an old Balmain fan …now I’m a Wests Tigers fan
 
weststigers said:
In the face of the full statistics over 25 years, you say it's a small sample size. This is difficult for me to swallow. Want to wait another 25 years?
Click to expand...

25 years is fine …I was referring to you wanting compare the last 5 years only…for Commbankv Cambo… I mean it’s not that hard to keep up?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BZN
Tom Shines said:
I have the sample size …my concern is with those wanting to move fulltime to Commbank… do you support that ?
Click to expand...
No. Where did I say that. I just gave the stats as you asked for them.

The clear winner is Leichhardt if going by results only.

100 games and both grounds and it's not even close.

Forget Commbank. It's always been a fill in stadium for money alone. With an upgrade to Leichhardt, our facilities and corporate dollar should be better there which has always been the issue.
 
weststigers said:
No. Where did I say that. I just gave the stats as you asked for them.

The clear winner is Leichhardt if going by results only.

100 games and both grounds and it's not even close.

Forget Commbank. It's always been a fill in stadium for money alone. With an upgrade to Leichhardt, our facilities and corporate dollar should be better there which has always been the issue.
Click to expand...

We agree on something at least …. And I never said you did say it …I’m arguing wih multiple people here if you didn’t realise…

Leichhardt has a superior record no doubt … unfortunately playing more than a handful of games there doesn’t appear an option
 
Tom Shines said:
25 years is fine …I was referring to you wanting compare the last 5 years only…for Commbankv Cambo… I mean it’s not that hard to keep up?
Click to expand...
Comparing the same team playing across the same period matters. It's apples for apples. You can't throw in results for 2005 in amongst results where we came last. It's a fair way to compare results across grounds. We only started playing at Commbank in 2019. I mean...it's not that hard to keep up?
 
weststigers said:
Comparing the same team playing across the same period matters. It's apples for apples. You can't throw in results for 2005 in amongst results where we came last. It's a fair way to compare results across grounds. We only started playing at Commbank in 2019. I mean...it's not that hard to keep up?
Click to expand...

5 years is meaningless because they play different teams… keep up so I don’t need to repeat myself
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BZN
Tom Shines said:
5 years is meaningless because they play different teams… keep us so I don’t need to repeat myself
Click to expand...
You could say the same about the 200 game sample size across 25 years because we don't play the same team at each ground in the same season.

By this logic, we can't accurately guage any season because we don't play each team twice at across both grounds.

if you don't accept the stats, that's fine, but there is a huge discrepancy between the results at the grounds. If you want to lay it down to other factors, no worries.

Please don't be rude.
 
weststigers said:
You could say the same about the 200 game sample size across 25 years because we don't play the same team at each ground in the same season.

By this logic, we can't accurately guage any season because we don't play each team twice at across both grounds.

if you don't accept the stats, that's fine, but there is a huge discrepancy between the results at the grounds. If you want to lay it down to other factors, no worries.

Please don't be rude.
Click to expand...

The bigger the sample size the better …

We have established there is a much better record at LO v Campbelltown ..So why don’t the players put the same effort in to win at both grounds ? Is that the reason?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 485 (members: 26, guests: 459)
Back
Top