Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

BS, it’s the color of the jersey that gets adjudicated on. There was another few hip drops this weekend that didn’t even get citied
Yep there have been a few hip drops missed in the past couple of weeks but as Tucker said Api's tackling technique is poor he often tackles from the side or behind and wraps his legs around. Always going to be contentious.
 
Yesterday and last week shows that things aren’t working in the halves …

Madden deserved a couple of chances as he did the job early in the year … but Benji can’t go with the same halves combination again … Latu to starting 7 this week …

Not sure about the 9 though just yet …best option would be signing someone from elsewhere

Could madden be an option at 9? With hope a reserve do they can share the duties
 
I worry about how the club is managing Latu this year. His role is all over the place. He needs game time in state cup playing 5/8 or half
I really don’t know why he isn’t next cab off the rank in the halves. Especially how when given the chance last year, he tore the Roosters apart. I know it’s easy to stick the boot in after a loss, but I’ve been saying it for a while. Madden is not the answer. He should be behind Latu. You hear how good Latu is, yet he’s hardly ever given an opportunity.
 
Maybe the idiot should stop doing that tackle?
He deserves time out for doing it so often
I can just see a situation where Api spends another 3 or 4 weeks suspended this season, the match officials will scrutinize the hell out of him and playing long minutes and fatigue will lead to him making crucial errors unless something changes.

Still cannot believe we have gone into this season without a reliable back up for him.

When we let TDS go to Parramatta, I just assumed we had some sort of a plan as far as a back up for Api was concerned and I could understand that we were never going to compete with the dollars that TDS was offered, but we just moved on and "Hoped" for the best.

I think we all could see that Benji was killing Api playing him longer minutes than he should and that things were only going to get worse as Api got older and the pace of the game got faster.
 
People calling for Heywood need to chill out. You introduce kids to a team that is travelling okay, with plenty of quality players to bounce off. You don’t throw them into a patched up team that has most of its quality players in rehab, that is really struggling. Heywood will get his chance, but hopefully not now

Agreed,i think it would be far more long term damage to Heywood's future as a player than a short term quick fix for the team.The option has far more dangers than solutions.
 
People calling for Heywood need to chill out. You introduce kids to a team that is travelling okay, with plenty of quality players to bounce off. You don’t throw them into a patched up team that has most of its quality players in rehab, that is really struggling. Heywood will get his chance, but hopefully not now
As I said yesterday, not only are people suggesting these kids, but suggesting them with the expectation they’ll make a difference.
 
I really don’t know why he isn’t next cab off the rank in the halves. Especially how when given the chance last year, he tore the Roosters apart. I know it’s easy to stick the boot in after a loss, but I’ve been saying it for a while. Madden is not the answer. He should be behind Latu. You hear how good Latu is, yet he’s hardly ever given an opportunity.
I think goal kicking and tactical kicking is giving Madden edge especially with Doueihi out.
 
Well if true and Kit and Luke and Geyer all to Perth that’s 3 spots plus 1 we have now = 4 plus we need to dump again starting with Toa = 5 then skim through the rest and find min 2 more = 7 new players for 2027 , 3 need to be first grade quality ( Centre , Hooker , to start with ) centre 3 year deal Hooker now 1.5 year deal so Haywood stays in line for 28
 
All this PNG talk tbh all i care is that they took JL of us as he is the most OVERRATED player in the NRL. They are kidding if they think hel make them competitive . They are going to need every advantage if hes there marquee player. He does nothing but steps sideways . All this talk abt stepping out of Nathans shadow lol.
Yeah, agree. I cant fault Luai for what hes done for us off the pitch. At the time for us where we were at as a club he was worth every penny of the 1.2 million. He showed the lads how to train and what it took. Were struggling now cause were massively down on troops. No team with our injury list is going to compete. Not with your top 5 players out. On the pitch hes no leader. He might be great behind the scenes but in the heat of battle he nowhere to be found. We need him now to keep the guys togeather and their head in the game and hes gone missing. If P.N.G think Luai will bring them success theyre kidding themselves. Hes the best signing to make to help build the club. If they did it thinking he will win them games theyre in for a rude shock. Its the unlimited 3rd party agreements and tax free dollars thatll win them games not Luai.
 
Well if true and Kit and Luke and Geyer all to Perth that’s 3 spots plus 1 we have now = 4 plus we need to dump again starting with Toa = 5 then skim through the rest and find min 2 more = 7 new players for 2027 , 3 need to be first grade quality ( Centre , Hooker , to start with ) centre 3 year deal Hooker now 1.5 year deal so Haywood stays in line for 28
When you look at ot that way we will have a massive offseason with new signings. Id assume within the next month or two we would start hearing of the guys were signing. I can see us promoting 2 maybe 3 players but we just dont have the depth. We need to bring guys in from outside.
 
Well if true and Kit and Luke and Geyer all to Perth that’s 3 spots plus 1 we have now = 4 plus we need to dump again starting with Toa = 5 then skim through the rest and find min 2 more = 7 new players for 2027 , 3 need to be first grade quality ( Centre , Hooker , to start with ) centre 3 year deal Hooker now 1.5 year deal so Haywood stays in line for 28
Unfortunately I think they are upgrading from within
 
Really he kicks it straight down the players throat, if that’s all he is there for , he’s not worth having him in the team
Didn't see yesterdays game, doesn't sound like he went too well. I wouldn't dump him yet, his kicking was very good in the 3 game window he played earlier in the year.
 

Latest posts

Members online

No members online now.
Back
Top