Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

A lot of presumptions going around atm. Deals like this are made every year with players being co-operative.
Some resistance to signing Fogerty but 2 years I reckon suits, this probably means Doueihi is finished in the halves or they wouldn't be trying to sign him.

From what I've seen the roster has started to improve from 2 years ago and is at its strongest in probably a decade, those questioning the quality of the signings who do you think we are the Roosters.

We didn't have the cap to go out and sign a bunch of superstars even if they did want to come over.
 
Fogarty is a must. Our other guys aren’t ready. As for the comparisons with Madden, Maddens kicking game is shit house. He’s a good back up. Fogarty has also played finals. Perfect player to get us around the field.

Latu is too injury prone and Andrew needs time. If we don’t sign him, everyone will be complaining we need a game managing half. This is it.
 
He hasn't been told he is behind them. Manly has prioritised keeping them long term as they are young and they want them in the future. For next year Fogarty is still their 7.
wtf are you talking about . You’re just redirecting the conversation to win . It’s annoying . You stated there was no possible reason to go . I just gave you 2 . And now you want to play semantics.
 
Which juniors are ready to step up now and play a full season, I'll tell you none.

Maybe Latu his age is approaching it, but would you put money on him getting through a full season playing 80 minutes in the halves with his injury history, yeah right.
We have young guns like Godinet, Havea Jr, Van Drie, Roberts, Latu, Tavana and Javon. We managed to muck up the re-signing of Kit and Luke Laulilii. But all those maturing juniors should be prioritised in their development over our current recruitment drive.

Don't get me wrong, every team needs veterans who can lead. However, since the changes introduced by PVL, this is no longer a game for men in their mid 30s. The game is only going to get faster.
 
We have young guns like Godinet, Havea Jr, Van Drie, Roberts, Latu, Tavana and Javon. We managed to muck up the re-signing of Kit and Luke Laulilii. But all those maturing juniors should be prioritised in their development over our current recruitment drive.

Don't get me wrong, every team needs veterans who can lead. However, since the changes introduced by PVL, this is no longer a game for men in their mid 30s. The game is only going to get faster.
DCE says hi.
 
It just makes no sense to let a 26 year old Madden go who is on no money to sign a 34 year old on good money that does the same job. Both are poor defenders, both have no running game, both organise well and both kick well. Madden steps up with the game on the line while Fogarty crumbles with the game on the line. When you take into account future improvement and salary cap management, you take Madden over Fogarty every time.

Im ok if Fogarty comes so we can have like for like at 6 and 7 in NRL and reserve grade, but to replace Madden with a player costing us 500k more who is on the decline and offers no more than what Madden does is crazy.
You have convinced me.

My initial thought was similar. There is little between Madden and Fogarty in terms of playing style and playing ability. In a fairly miserable 2026 season one of the positives was the combination between Jock and Adam. I thought they played great together and we won 3 out of 4 with those two in the halves.
 
We have young guns like Godinet, Havea Jr, Van Drie, Roberts, Latu, Tavana and Javon. We managed to muck up the re-signing of Kit and Luke Laulilii. But all those maturing juniors should be prioritised in their development over our current recruitment drive.

Don't get me wrong, every team needs veterans who can lead. However, since the changes introduced by PVL, this is no longer a game for men in their mid 30s. The game is only going to get faster.
I don’t think we mucked up the resigning of Kit and Luke, I think a decision was made that they weren’t going to make it, just have to see what progress they make in WA , if any.
 
We have young guns like Godinet, Havea Jr, Van Drie, Roberts, Latu, Tavana and Javon. We managed to muck up the re-signing of Kit and Luke Laulilii. But all those maturing juniors should be prioritised in their development over our current recruitment drive.

Don't get me wrong, every team needs veterans who can lead. However, since the changes introduced by PVL, this is no longer a game for men in their mid 30s. The game is only going to get faster.
Out of our new recruits there's no long term contracts blocking their path what are you talking about.

Latu and Roberts are the only ones from your bunch of players that are up to playing a chunk of 1st grade this season the rest are a long way off.

If you predict the game will get faster that means more injuries and you need a deep squad.
 
DCE says hi.
DCE has always been on another level. If Manly thought Fogarty was at that standard, they wouldn't be shopping him around. It goes to show, though, how fickle Manly are, or how poorly managed their salary cap is. Even with Brooks returning in April, you would think Foz would hold on to Jamal.
 
Perfect scenario with latu at 6, Javon keeping pressure on and stepping up if injury. Then we have Averillo and some smokies young guns waiting for opportunity.

We are rich at 6 if we sign Fogarty at 7.

Madden covers 7.

Can’t see where we need AD in halves unless his form screams to be picked there . In fact with the depth we will have pressure is on all to perform.
 
Out of our new recruits there's no long term contracts blocking their path what are you talking about.

Latu and Roberts are the only ones from your bunch of players that are up to playing a chunk of 1st grade this season the rest are a long way off.

If you predict the game will get faster that means more injuries and you need a deep squad.
There is, and our depth is razor thin.

In the end, if any of our senior recruits go down, we will be relying on these young guns. I hope they are all put through their paces in pre-season and earn their spots, even if it's on the extended bench.

A lot of supporters will argue that we blood our players too early. I disagree. I think Big Mak will be better for the experience he gained this season, and it shows, considering Parra wanted to do a swap deal for JAC.
 
There is, and our depth is razor thin.

In the end, if any of our senior recruits go down, we will be relying on these young guns. I hope they are all put through their paces in pre-season and earn their spots, even if it's on the extended bench.

A lot of supporters will argue that we blood our players too early. I disagree. I think Big Mak will be better for the experience he gained this season, and it shows, considering Parra wanted to do a swap deal for JAC.
Depth is razor thin, you can't be serious, maybe 2nd row is light that's about it.

Gawd, I don't know why I reply to you sometimes, the crud you come out with.
 
Back
Top