OFFICIAL Q&A Club discussion with Shaun Mielekamp

Hi @ShaunMielekamp ,

You’ve been pretty vocal about the importance of the club having a long-term plan and sticking to it, which is why this whole Latu decision feels so short-sighted.

Benji has consistently spoken about coaching for the long-term future of the Wests Tigers, and yet here we have a young player who has been identified and sold to us fans as a potential long-term half, seemingly ready for an opportunity, only for the club to change direction yet again.

With the constant change of direction, the ongoing uncertainty and what feels like one embarrassment after another under HBG, I genuinely question what incentive there is for fans to renew their memberships and continue spending their hard-earned money on a club that repeatedly lets them down. Fans are constantly asked to show loyalty, patience and faith in the process, but that loyalty needs to be reciprocated. At some point, the club has to give its supporters genuine reasons to believe that things are heading in the right direction, rather than expecting us to blindly stick around regardless of what happens.

What I don’t understand is Benji took Adam out of the halves earlier this year because he didn’t think he was doing a good enough job there. Now we’re talking about loaning Latu out and putting Adam back in the halves again? How does that make any sense?

This is exactly the sort of thing that frustrates fans. We’re constantly told there’s a long-term plan, but then the club keeps changing direction and going back on decisions. How are we supposed to have confidence in what we’re building when it feels like we’re just going around in circles again?
If you answer any post Shaun reply to this one. Well said mate
 
Hi Shaun if the Latu loan becomes a reality then I will certainly not renew my membership it just shows how incompetent our club is by contradicting everything the club has said about Latu.

You moved on Luai so our young gun halves in Javon and Latu have a clear path to first grade and now you want to go and sign a 33 year old halfback and loan out one of the best young halves to another club to develop when he should have been given a go at the tigers in his preferred position.

This reeks of a desperate coach and club looking at another short cut fix which will only end one way in tears for all involved and you risk loosing one of the best young talents.

Unfortunately as a long time weststigers supporter I have had enough and have lost the love and interest I have had for this club.
 
Last edited:
I support the majority of the posters on this forum in regard to the supposed loan of Latu, what a dumb idea, we seem to hover from one self inflicted bad idea to the next, it is dead set embarrassing being a fan of this club, whoever came up with this needs to be shown the door, and if this was you Shaun, then you can go also. Like others, I will not be renewing my membership, I have had enough, if it's not the board meddling and nuking the place down, it's decisions (supposedly) like the loan of our young players to other clubs playing out in the news.
Someone needs to own this if true, and if not, then you Shaun need to come out and kill this rubbish story, sorry there's no other way of putting it.
This type of news, whether true or false destabilizes our team, we did this with the board sackings last year that put us in the news for all the wrong reasons, and just as I thought that we can go through pre season without any noise, this happens, and I am filthy about it, all I can say is GET YOUR ACT TOGETHER!
 
The club in the past has been quick to deny some false reporting on things

Nothing on this from them tho
Given the talk of Makasini last week, it seems obvious they are keen to loan somebody for a year. My question for Shaun would be what happened to this great cap position we’re supposedly in? And if it’s roster spots we need to free up, why sign a has been like Kurt Mann? Terrible roster management to put themselves into this position.
 
The club in the past has been quick to deny some false reporting on things

Nothing on this from them tho
To be fair, he must have been fully busy with the light and dark jersey announcement - I mean, that is pretty heady stuff. I mean, not Black & White, which conjures up massive HBG conniptions, but rather - Light & Dark, chiaroscuro, if you will, which made DaVinci famous. The Moaning Latu is probably the last thing he is worried about whilst ever a jersey needs to be sold before Christmas!
 
To be fair, he must have been fully busy with the light and dark jersey announcement - I mean, that is pretty heady stuff. I mean, not Black & White, which conjures up massive HBG conniptions, but rather - Light & Dark, chiaroscuro, if you will, which made DaVinci famous. The Moaning Latu is probably the last thing he is worried about whilst ever a jersey needs to be sold before Christmas!
I think the light and dark jerseys will transition into one white one black. Just give them time as they manoeuvre in the coming years
 
To be fair, he must have been fully busy with the light and dark jersey announcement - I mean, that is pretty heady stuff. I mean, not Black & White, which conjures up massive HBG conniptions, but rather - Light & Dark, chiaroscuro, if you will, which made DaVinci famous. The Moaning Latu is probably the last thing he is worried about whilst ever a jersey needs to be sold before Christmas!
Just another embarrasing chapter...it was cringe to see how much attention it recieved.
As.if we dont have mamy many more pressing issues than home away light dark...but thats this fanbase for ya and has been for 26 petty divided years
 
I think the light and dark jerseys will transition into one white one black. Just give them time as they manoeuvre in the coming years
Dark jersey will be the jersey HBG tell them team to play in more often, especially those day games in the heat.
predicting the orange jersey does not get a run at Campbelltown
 
This loan garbage is another example of how this club has no idea how to develop young players.
Makasini needs a lot of work and he doesn’t need continual exposure in NRL. Sending him away to another club would set him back further. I know the club shut this down, but it was considered and the rejection should have been a lot more confident and aggressive.
Now we hear Latu, the prodigy that has shown glimpses of handling NRL is being offered? This is surely wrong reporting as it’s tantamount to a sabotage of season 2027 if true.
 
Just another embarrasing chapter...it was cringe to see how much attention it recieved.
As.if we dont have mamy many more pressing issues than home away light dark...but thats this fanbase for ya and has been for 26 petty divided years
And here I am wondering why everyone my age isn't a Wests supporter, cos all we had was 2 kinds of TV - Black n White! How on earth did anyone know who the teams were during the 2nd half of the CH7 Rex Mossop Live coverage?
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Back
Top