Recent content by Ed_Reschs

I took this comment a bit seriously until you rated Kevin McGuinness above Chris Lawrence. Let yourself down at this point. You need to remember Lawrence did his hip before his prime. He could have been a great centre but only as good as the 6 inside him.

On 2 occasions in the first half Brooks died with the ball on the last tackle. Happy to spend his $500,000 elsewhere

100%. if he wasn't a first grader Ivan wouldn't pick him. This forum only highlights blokes that have no idea. Every club has a dozen clubman and Chris Lawrence is one of ours.

Skandalis, Gibbs, laffranchi, Payten wasn't a bad pack. Gibbs very underrated

And so it begins tomorrow in the telegraph….rothfield writes one Sydney team has to go...no guesses as to who it will be if and when it happens.

rugby league is dying in MacArthur. Wests Tigers and the NRL are to blame. The AFL has moved in and now it is only a matter of time. Tv and greed have killed the goose.

In 1991 the Wok bought Gillespie, langmack, Thomas, wynn, Rampling, Gibbs, Farrah , & dymock to compliment henjak, Lindner and if it wasn't for the roosters we would have got terry hill. Transformed wests from easy beats to semi finalists in 12 months. They could have won the comp that year but...

On the other hand is opposite in this game te Marie Martin has class

I'm not sold on him. Pretty average in my view.

…yes and im willing to bet none of the above were offered $500k plus a year to move clubs from reserve grade apart from Austin who was a first grader at the time. big difference

agree - buy reserve graders get reserve grade results waste of money

Kelly Egan was quoted as saying each time the club and the players reached agreement they would return to the next meeting anticipating the players putting pen to paper for Isaac Moses to turn up with a new list of requirements that had never been previously discussed. They were never going to stay.

Most of the old magpie fans had t raudonikis and t lamb jerseys in the late 70's early 80's. as a 7 year old I remember losing tommy which was shattering then we discovered baa then he left. Double dose of trauma. However then came the great one and he stayed forever and became a legend - T Cogger

we should only be pillaging players from 3 clubs. Roosters, dogs and eels. Happy to grab a couple of warriors but I want us to do some serious damage to their rosters. At least force them to pay overs to keep players.

Ditto