Tallyn Da Silva #270

I know there’s another issue behind it all.

Wouldn’t be as big of an issue outside of football.

I won’t publicly draw attention to the specific issue. But I do think there is a few who know in the game

Reading in the thread, where some of comments and theories were going. I have attempted to realign the discussion or expectations.
You are not saying that Manly is not a good option for him?? 🤫
 
I understood we used a data analyst in the past for recruitment. It seems the smart way to operate. Don't we also have officers in the Western Suburbs and Balmain junior districts as well?
Yes, it’s a good idea to have the stats lady on hand, I’m a fan, but she can only take us so far.

She’s confined to recording past facts which doesn’t offer any guarantee of future performance nor can she address the volatility of the market.

But essentially, I think r&r- it gets down to people management and the mental arts.

Benji is strong in some aspects of this, but it’s impossible to be everything to everyone.
 
As good as Api is, we really can't be counting on him as a full-time player in 2027. He'll be 34 turning 35.

It's a real possibility that Da Silva will be as good as Api some time in 2026, let alone 2027.

If the club is lower of Da Silva then everyone others in footy, so be it. But if we do think of him as a great prospect, then it's just stupidity to prioritise Api.

Latu Fainu, Galvin and Da Silva could've potentially been our Munster, Hughes and Grant. Instead, we bullied one on the way out of the club, tried to sign a busted 35 year old to play halfback alongside a 5/8th we overpaid for and are going to lose the other because we want to keep a 34 year old hooker showing signs of slowing down.

Like what are we doing here? Are we trying to build for the future or win now?
... like sands through the hourglass,
so are the days of our lives 🥴

The great (& tragic) Wests Tigers melodrama lurches on ...
 
Also it's pretty clear Da Silva's been made to feel uncomfortable about the whole Galvin situation.

I don't blame him for wanting to leave when the club's leadership is essentially endorsing a culture that could be taken as seeking to exclude you.
Nothing is clear i reckon...

Is this, "I want 600k and a starting role over one of the best hookers in the game" even real?

I think a lot of KIDS were made promises under Sheens and MacD. Now they're gone and the promises went with them.... which has upset a few people.
 
Yes, it’s a good idea to have the stats lady on hand, I’m a fan, but she can only take us so far.

She’s confined to recording past facts which doesn’t offer any guarantee of future performance nor can she address the volatility of the market.

But essentially, it gets down to people management and the mental arts.

Benji is strong in some aspects of this, but it’s impossible to be everything to everyone.
Male or female is inconsequential; they are a valuable tool for recruitment.
 
Nothing is clear i reckon...

Is this, "I want 600k and a starting role over one of the best hookers in the game" even real?

I think a lot of KIDS were made promises under Sheens and MacD. Now they're gone and the promises went with them.... which has upset a few people.

This is how it’s looking isn’t it.
Sucks though as a Wests Tigers fan especially when youth/development club was the statement motto Richo/Benji paraded around 12ths back
 
FWIW. There is 💯 more to this story.

Over the previous few weeks, it’s essentially been confirmed for me.

This isn’t just about the patience behind api. Although a big factor. There’s a little bit of uncomfortableness around a few things that are and have happened.

Apologies for anyone wanting specifics, the last thing I currently want is any more media attention or stories getting out.

But there’s more to this, which when I had heard, made it all make sense.
Doesn't like Pacific Islanders & is a closet KKK member?
 
This is how it’s looking isn’t it.
Sucks though as a Wests Tigers fan especially when youth/development club was the statement motto Richo/Benji paraded around 12ths back
Yep

I really like TDS too but as others said, he isn't ready to start.

Ideally he's 14 and plays the bench hooker role giving Api a break, which we all know is needed.

Going to Newcastle & sharing the role with... MATT ARTHUR, under a spud like O'Brien and a squad full of divas (Ponga, Brown) and fresh on the scene kids.... I cannot see how thatd make him a better player.
 
I've liked what TDS has offered the club since I first saw him.

Great potential.

But if you don't want to be at a club- no amount of potential is going to get the investment from the player.

You want out because you feel uncomfortable about something? Cool. Go find someone that buys in instead.

The NRL is populated with juniors playing for teams they did NOT develop in.
 
We weren’t able to convince TDS to chill and are now resigned to losing him.

It’s not catastrophic, as he will be replaced.

I don’t see a future for Api beyond the next few years and we aren’t performing to a level where we will hit our stride this year and probably next year.
 
No ideas about any other clubs and or discussions.
Nah, I was kind of saying that with manly and their pride jersey stance and all but who cares .. I think talyn is a teriffic young man that will choose to stay.. I’m hoping that these issues will be resolved because he has grown up wanting to play for the tigers
 
Makes it sound like he was promised more playing time by Richo but Benji doesn't want to take the risk during games. He did for a few games and then turns around to Richo and says "see, it didn't work out".

And the whole line on Friday that he wanted to play Api because that's who gave him the best chance of winning...you still lost! How would you know what TDS would have done/ wouldn't have if you don't play him.
1750553401955.pngOur record using Api and Tallyn is 6 and 6
Our record using Api for the full 80 is 5 and 22
Its clear so far that we win more games when they are used in tandom. That is extra frustrating as our past 4 games were all winnable and we went Api the full 80 in all of them rather than use the pairing that has a 50% win record.
 
Nothing is clear i reckon...

Is this, "I want 600k and a starting role over one of the best hookers in the game" even real?

I think a lot of KIDS were made promises under Sheens and MacD. Now they're gone and the promises went with them.... which has upset a few people.
I've read this article from the SMH this morning with Richardson advising the swap with the Knights is not a goer. This is what he said -

“We thought the idea of swapping Tallyn just for this season was a good one that would give him exposure this season, and we would get Kai Pearce-Paul,” Richardson said.

“That’s changed and now we’ll see what happens.

“But just because you give permission to negotiate doesn’t mean you have to accept it. We’re trying to do everything we can to keep Tallyn in our system, but obviously he wants to play first grade and we don’t blame him. We’ll see how it unfolds.”

 
Nah, I was kind of saying that with manly and their pride jersey stance and all but who cares .. I think talyn is a teriffic young man that will choose to stay.. I’m hoping that these issues will be resolved because he has grown up wanting to play for the tigers
Yeah, he’s a promising youngster and we have looked after him in terms of acclimatising him to fg.

Spirited and club first countenance.

He’s great.
 
As good as Api is, we really can't be counting on him as a full-time player in 2027. He'll be 34 turning 35.

It's a real possibility that Da Silva will be as good as Api some time in 2026, let alone 2027.

If the club is lower of Da Silva then everyone others in footy, so be it. But if we do think of him as a great prospect, then it's just stupidity to prioritise Api.

Latu Fainu, Galvin and Da Silva could've potentially been our Munster, Hughes and Grant. Instead, we bullied one on the way out of the club, tried to sign a busted 35 year old to play halfback alongside a 5/8th we overpaid for and are going to lose the other because we want to keep a 34 year old hooker showing signs of slowing down.

Like what are we doing here? Are we trying to build for the future or win now?
Yep, thats the concerning part. All this BS about 5 year plans is so transparent.
 
Back
Top