Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Betterdays22 said:
To'a was probably our 2nd best player over the first half of the year. The knock on him is inconsistency and injuries, unfortunately the 2nd half of the year has done nothing to disprove the knocks.

My feel is Benji likes him but is running out of patience
Click to expand...
He’s definitely got the injury prone label on him based on the past few years and I think that leads to a lot of the perceived inconsistency.

Will he continue to be injury prone? That’s the gamble.
 
Canadian Club said:
Said this all along, it was always easiest to point to finger at Moses. Its true that Benji and Moses don't get along, but Moses loves money more than he dislikes Benji. Godinet and Sukkar both re-signed this year along with Doueihi (even though Moses was just an advisor).

The Galvin release and pile on was always from the Galvin camp. From what i know, the Moses camp was not happy with the Galvin camp after all was said and done as Moses helped orchestrate the whole debacle to get him Parra. Galvins family and Vella were secretly working to get him to the Bulldogs for months.
Click to expand...
I... I really don't know.

So I am very bitter at Issac Moses. It's clear that he had some role in getting Galvin to pull out of the club. I think though you have a point and the parents did not want Galvin to settle here.

What gets me through all of this is the Bulldogs poached Galvin's childhood trainer. We could have easily hired him to keep Galvin and made "small" adjustments. Premadonna's though... it's better to let them walk.

Clearly the Dogs were angling for Galvin for a very long time. Gus bragged about talking with Burton's parents and I highly suspect he helped get into their heads. Hoping such schemes will cost them a grand final.
 
Demps said:
Having a back up hooker that can play elsewhere would be very beneficial to the top 30.

Latu is probably the closest we have, being able to play in the halves, at hooker and at 13 but Benjis saying he's the long term 7.

With our squad filling, I'm not sure how we could land such a player and who it'd be.

Perhaps Jock could play some 9 if needed !?
Click to expand...
Maybe that's why they retained AD, Latu and Hope share the 9 and AD slots into 7 from 13 while Latu is at 9.
 
weststigers said:
Dodd is going to be hard to shift. Hasn't had much game time and the team is decimated, so can't show much. The biggest sticking point is the big salary.

I think Bird stays as depth because he is on low money. Hunt is in the firing line, but no one is going to pay 600k for him...we'll need to pay his bus fares to shift him.

To'a may get moved on if Makasini takes his spot, but players can still move after the season starts, so we might start with him and move him closer to the June 30 deadline.

Definitely players will get punted in something decent pops up.
Click to expand...
Dodd is a weird one.
Yet if Bennett can't make a halfback out of him, no one can.

The fact that Sullivan is running ahead of Dodd either means Dodd is being pushed out OR he is crap.

What to do with Hunt?
IMHO we shouldn't move him on. Give him an ultimatium "your on 500k now. you want to be in the starting side, so we want to see you put in... and you can do this. Else we will put you on Bench/reserve grade duties and your next contract will hurt".

I get this feeling that Craig Fitzgibbon can read people well. He could have built Hunt into an awesome forward, but knew the attitude was wrong. Trent Robinson is kind of the same, although his players do well elsewhere. Ivan Cleary is a horrible signer but a great coach.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
That feels very convoluted. Would be much easier just to have a specialist.
Click to expand...
This would only be to cover if Api is injured...not a week to week proposition. You will always have a few weak spots in a roster. Both in terms of timing i.e. young guns you don't want to lose/block however maybe 12 months away from first grade, or cap restrictions. Teams with top 3-4 hookers don't always have quality first grade ready back-ups as all the money is pumped into the starting 9, unless you are the Storm.
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Hope so Ink. Just think his decision making & skill errors (poor handling & ptbs at times) need work & he is not an aerial threat for a winger his height. I just think he'll get overtaken by others in our squad.
Click to expand...
As gunther said hes 20 odd firsr grade games...still developing.
Been a long time since weve had a big strong fast winger.
I like him...still raw but just goes about his business quietly no lairising
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Hope so Ink. Just think his decision making & skill errors (poor handling & ptbs at times) need work & he is not an aerial threat for a winger his height. I just think he'll get overtaken by others in our squad.
Click to expand...
In fairness to him, he was a flanker in union from memory...still learning to an extent.
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
I agree re Makasini. Can see him become an exceptional left winger to start his NRL career with his fend, decent speed, tackle-breaking ability & pretty good aerial takes from what I have seen.

Skelton will be a great depth option next season in the final year of his contract.
Click to expand...
I think a world needs to exist where the back 5 are Bula, Skelton, Masi, May and Tito in the short to medium term.

Whether they can get the timing and positions right for each is the challenge.

Jeral is probably then the most upgradable of them all in the longer term, depending on how it all plays out.
 
We're gonna have some tall timber in the engine room next season joining Sam Fanua.

Samuela Fainu - 194cms - 109kgs - 21 years young - 2nd row
Maverik Geyer - 191cms - 104kgs - 24 years young - 2nd row
Ethan Roberts - 195cms - 105kgs - 20 years young - 2nd row
Kai Pearce-Paul - 198cms - 108kgs - 24 years young - 2nd row
 
Vicious said:
I highly doubt Douehi would have taken unders to stay,
If we have only paid him around that 400k value, I’d say there’s an additional 3rd party agreement involved.
Click to expand...
Yes. Under 400k doesn't fit your narrative so what you say must be true.

He's staying...and he stayed for less than what St George was offering. Instead of acknowledging that (which is a club feat in itself) you go on with the story that it can't possibly be right when you have no idea.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 354 (members: 27, guests: 327)
Back
Top